Reasons For Civil War Articles David M. Potter And Micheal F. Holt Comparison Austin Peay State University/History 2010 36 Essay

1317 words - 6 pages

Clarissa Huesca. History 2010 36 E. November 18, 2017.
The Civil War was a very significant part of American history and has immensely shaped the United States as we know it today. The direct cause of the Civil War is probably one of the most controversial topics in American history. Many believe its cause was the conflict between the North and South on whether or not to preserve the institution of slavery. During that time, slavery was the law of the land but the North wanted abolishment while the South did not. Others thought its cause was not directly the conflict of slavery or sectionals but a variety of other reasons. Some historians feel that the Civil War was a result of political mistakes and that slavery did not cause it at all. Several others believe the expansion of slavery, and its entrance into the political scene was the real causation.
In “The Sectional Divisions That Led to Civil War,” David M. Potter agrees that the sectional divisions and their many problems were the primary causes of the Civil War rather than politics. As stated in the Article,
“Once the government under the constitution went into effect, bitter sectional conflicts raged over the assumption of state debts, chartering of the central bank, and other matters.”[footnoteRef:0] [0: David M. Potter, The Sectional Divisions That Led to Civil War: Major Problems in American History. 387]
Although, Potter explains that politicians wanted to deal with the reason that divided the country. The "most serious cause of sectional conflict," according to Potter was slavery. The tension over slavery was the conflict considered to be the problem of the individual states, rather than a problem of the country as a whole.
In “The Political Divisions Contributed to the Civil War” Michael F. Holt expresses that the Civil War’s cause is instead the fault of political aspects. The political leaders, parties, and issues at the time. Stating in his article,
“Historians have minimized the internal solidarity of both the North and the South and seriousness of disputes between them. They have blamed the war instead on the mistakes of political leaders and the effects of agitators such as the abolitionists and southern fire-eaters”[footnoteRef:1] [1: Michael F. Holt, The Political Divisions Contributed to the Civil War: Careening Towards Civil War. 384]
Holt sees the Civil War as portraying a breakdown in America's democratic political system, specifically the Second Party System of Whigs and Democrats. He mostly considers the timing of the conflict. He feels that the breakdown in the systems created a panic within the nation and that this panic turned into war.
The authors’ perspectives are similar in that they both have the same information as professors and know the sides of the controversial topic but differ on which side they agree with. They both see that sectional division is a factor of the Civil War but Holt focuses more on the political system and Potter focuses on the confli...

RELATED

Why The North Won The Civil War By David Donald: Reflection On The Economic, Military, Diplomatic, Political, And Social Reasons The South Lost

1391 words - 6 pages botheration and disagreement with their opposition. The purpose of this essay is to summarize each of the five arguments presented by Richard N. Current, T. Harry Williams, Norman A. Graebner, David Herbert Donald, and David M. Potter. Each author gives his insight on one of the following five reasons: economic, military, diplomatic, social, and political, respectively.The essay entitled "The Military Leadership of the North and South" by Harry Willams

Scultz Critical Summary- South Park and the F word - The ohio state university/ Criticizing television - essay

751 words - 4 pages more important than the actual definition because you could offend many people. Just because you didn’t intend to offend someone, doesn’t matter if you still did it. That is why I found Schultz’s argument to be strong. References Schulzke, M. (2012) Contentious Language: South Park and the Transformation of Meaning, Journal of Popular Film and Television, 40:1, 22-31, DOI: 10.1080/01956051.2011.62413 Trey Parker. (2009) The F Word [South Park] Hollywood, Calif: Paramount Home Entertainment.

Civil War Essay - Differences of the North and South - Monash University, ATS1320: Nations at War - Essay

1649 words - 7 pages of the Civil War (New York: Oxford University Press, 1980), 53] [11: Abraham Lincoln, ‘House Divided Speech’, (Springfield: June 6, 1858), Causes of the Civil War, ed. James F. Epperson, last modified June 8 2017, http://civilwarcauses.org/house.htm] [12: William H. Seward, ‘The Irrepressible Conflict’ (Rochester, 25 October 1858). In David Garrioch, ed. Nations at War: Revolution and Empire, (Clayton, 2018), 38-39] [13: James M. McPherson

Geography Essay about all Articles - Texas A&M University Geography 202 - Essay

1615 words - 7 pages be tied into the main topic of this essay, Geography. Over the course of this class, we read a number of essays over the Geography of the Global Village written about different parts of the world and by authors from different parts of the world. In these essays, there are key factors that should be sought out for, cultural attitude, ethical responsibility, and the essay that best shows geography, culture, and the similarity between the two

Reasons for the Liberal Social Welfare Reforms - History - Assignment/Essay

1411 words - 6 pages Reasons for the Liberal Social Welfare Reforms Context For most of the 19th century, most people believed in ‘laissez-fraire’ and accepted that poverty and hardship were not things the government could or should do anything about. However, the Liberal Government (led by Prime Minister Herbert Asquith and Chancellor of the Exchequer David Lloyd George) introduced a range of social welfare reforms to help alleviate the poverty and hardship suffered

the reasons for hitlers rise to power - history - essay

1603 words - 7 pages The reasons for Hitler’s rise to power essay 1. The treaty of Versailles 2. Weaknesses in the Weimar republic= hyperinflation, occupation of the Ruhr, the great depression, economic downturn, fear of communism, wall st crash, extremism on the rise 3. Nazi party organisation, Hitler appealed to all classes, being able to deal will the communists, SA, Harzburg front 4. Tactical skills 5. Hitler Role of Hindenburg- used article 48, authoritarian

Nationalist victory in the Spanish civil war - History - essay

4434 words - 18 pages antimonarchist legislation.[footnoteRef:37] Franco allowed the Falangist leadership crisis to play out, with Manuel Hedilla eventually defeating Agustín Aznar for the leadership becoming ‘el Jefe’ before releasing a decree of unification forming the Falange Española Tradicionalista y de las Juntas de Ofensiva Nacional Sindicalista (FET y de las JONS). [37: Casanova, J (2010). The Spanish Republic and Civil War. Cambridge: Cambridge University

Terrorism in Syria - syrian civil war -2018 - St Johns University - History

1807 words - 8 pages Terrorism in Syria Marcus Poree April 24th, 2018 Professor Romano History 1000C There is countless problems in Syria involving the Syrian civil war, and a big part of the problem is innocent civilians being murdered by the hand of “terrorist”. I quote terrorist because the idea of terrorism can be pretty subjective depending on which side you’re representing. The US views groups like Al Qaeda and ISIS as terrorist, however some Middle Eastern

Regional Integration For And Against Articles

1014 words - 5 pages Regional Integration for and Against Articles PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 Regional Integration for and Against ArticlesUniversity of PhoenixCourse: MGT/448Instructor: Ben ZuckermanMarch 29, 2010Regional Integration For and Against ArticlesIn this paper we will need to select a region in which we will choose a regional trading bloc. Once that a region has been chosen we will further discuss the advantages and disadvantages of regional integration from

First world war key turning point in civil rights in the US? - History - Essay

899 words - 4 pages Black Americans. Race riot occurred in the North and the West due to increased racial tensions between Blacks and Whites, due to the Great Migration. For example, Black Americans faced violence from white racist mobs in Chicago, Illinois, 1919, and Tulsa, Oklahoma, 1921. However, was the first world war a key turning point in the changing geography of the civil rights issues? Years after the first world war, there was another major wave of

Civil War events that led up to conflict - AP History - essay

552 words - 3 pages formed around all this new growth. The expansion of slavery was the underlying reason for many political disagreements prior to the Civil War. Every new state added to the union caused a serious debate over the expansion of slavery. The Missouri Compromise was an agreement that prohibited slavery in the former Louisiana Territory allowing Missouri to enter the union as a slave state and Maine as a free state in order to balance out the Congress

song analysis related to post civil war - History after 1865 - essay

1526 words - 7 pages SOCIAL IMPACT AFTER THE CIVIL WAR 1 SOCIAL IMPACT AFTER THE CIVIL WAR 5 Social Impact after the Civil War Alexis Bibbee Professor Timothy Pitts We have conducted a series of investigation of what we already know about American society. They went through a series of political and social turmoil that ended up in a great Civil War. The great divide amongst the stated of the North and the South, slavery, people fighting for their rights, and a

Remains and war photographer comparison - Year 9 - Essay

1224 words - 5 pages gives an almost savage and sinister edge to the poem to make the act of war all the more evil. The poet does this to make the point that such wars create extremely dark times as explored in the sibilance of the piece ‘with spools of suffering set out in ordered rows’. The use of the word ‘suffering’ implies very bad conditions and the state of undergoing pain, distress, or hardship. As this is referring to war it is a safe inference to say that

Revolutionary War and War of 1812 - University of Hawaii - US History to 1877 - History Paper

1485 words - 6 pages The Revolutionary War and The War of 1812 The Revolutionary War and the War of 1812 were no easy feats for the United States. In both conflicts they faced an enemy that was far superior to them in almost every aspect. Victory was not straightforward, and at times did not seem attainable, but undeterred, Americans kept on fighting. Hardships were abundant after the Revolutionary War, yet through perseverance and democracy, those too would

Ap US History 2010 free response question answers - AP US History - Essay

403 words - 2 pages 28+How would you have planned the Jamestown colony to ensure a good and prosperous start? Include the kind of people you would have sent, supplies that would have been needed, type of government, choice of a location, and plans for growth. Your essay should be 350 words in length. Given the choice, the colony would be located at least seventy-five miles from the ocean. This is a precaution in case there is a tsunami. Furthermore the distance