Why The Us Constitution Did Not Contain A Bill Of Rights California State University, Northridge Essay

1171 words - 5 pages

Alexander Levin
March 10, 2018
HIST 370
Spring 2018
CSUN
Explain why the United States Constitution submitted to the states for ratification did not contain a bill of rights, what the two main motivations were that prompted the Anti-Federalists to demand a bill of rights, the two main reasons the Federalists Congress passed a bill of rights, and finally what was the main consequence of the passage of the Bill of Rights.
The two competing parties at the outset of this nation were possibly the two most cooperative in history despite being so polarized; The Federalists and Antifederalists. The Antifederalists were originally supportive of the Articles of Confederation, America’s first constitution, which weighed in favor of states’ rights. The Constitution as we know it today was a recent and newly drafted document, which the Antifederalists believed would give too much power to the centralized government. At this point they did not even consider themselves part of a bigger nation, but rather Marylanders, New Yorkers, etc. Many American colonists, like Patrick Henry, considered his country to be Virginia. The Federalist Party, formerly the Nationalist party, claimed the title Federalists for themselves in one of the most successful acts of political branding in U.S. history.
The leaders of the Federalists were the ones who named the competing party the Antifederalists thinking that the negative prefix of their name would make them less attractive to potential followers. Both parties could have been called federalists because most were in favor of a confederation of stronger independent states rather than one overarching unitary state, though their opinions on how strong the states should be varied. The Antis regarded the Federalists as power-hungry and conniving liars who used underhanded political tactics. For example, the Federalists drafted the new constitution in secret whilst throwing the Articles of Confederation to the side. They feared that this behavior would breed more such actions if the Federalists gained power. The Federalists saw the Antis as evil and ignorant people that would destroy the country. The Antis were opposed to even the creation of a national government, but the ratification of the Constitution in 1790 was clearly a win for the Federalists. This turn of events gave pause to the Antis, who were afraid that this new national government would inevitably infringe upon their rights and the rights of the states. This led to the Antis passing the first ten amendments to the constitution, later becoming the Bill of Rights. Most Federalists had not considered adding a bill of rights to the Constitution because all the freedoms declared in it would be implied by American citizenship. Through political promises and simple pleas in written letters, the Antifederalists got what they wanted from the Federalists; assurance that their basic rights would not be infringed.
When the Articles of Confederation were ratified m...

RELATED

Paul Ehrlich and the “Population Bomb” - California State University Northridge, URBS 150 - Research Paper

1232 words - 5 pages end of World War II. As human resources become more limited and our environment progressively degrades, the fear of overpopulation becomes more apparent with every passing day. “The Population Bomb,” is a book written by Stanford University professor Paul Ralph Ehrlich, in which he talks about overpopulation on Earth. He grimly warns his audience of mass starvations in the 1970s and 1980s resulting from overpopulation, shortage of human

How Did The Nineteenth Amendment Come To Be Part Of Our Constitution And Why Was It Significant? A History Of The Female Right's Movement And The Importance Of The 19th Amendment

1560 words - 7 pages the amendment would not pass, but twenty-four-year-old Harry Burn cast his vote for ratification giving them the one last vote necessary in the Tennessee house. Tennessee became the thirty-sixth, and final state for ratification. On August 24, 1920, the Nineteenth Amendment was finally added to the US Constitution. It is commonly referred to as the "Susan B. Anthony Amendment," in honor of her works and efforts. Sadly, she died fifteen years before

Does Australia Need A Federal Bill Of Rights? Discus With Reference To Specific Cases And Legislation

2002 words - 9 pages under a Bill of Rights.This decision finally highlights that investigation towards the procurement of a Bill Of Rights was done and suggested that Australia did not require a Bill Of Rights"If it ain't broke, don't fix it".The above saying encapsulates the fact that Australia does not need a bill of rights. The arrangements we have in place are the right arrangements. They suit our unique political and constitutional situation and have served us

Rattification of the Constitution - US History - Research Paper

985 words - 4 pages federal government would be too far removed to represent average citizen. They were also worried the original constitution did not contain a bill of rights, and they wanted guaranteed protection for basic liberties. They felt that Constitution did not protect the people’s rights. The purchase of the Louisiana Territory was another controversial issue during the early 1800s. The French having control of the territory, offered to sell it to the U.S. for

How the Constitution Changed America - College US History - Essay

597 words - 3 pages there would be stages for that law to go through. If power was abused by the president, the other branches would have the power to impeach the president. “The Senate shall have the sole Power to try all Impeachments” (The Constitution of the united States). Everyone was guaranteed to have a fair trial. The Bill of Rights that were given to each citizen to make sure everyone had freedom. The most important issue that the founding fathers inforced

The Life of a Legend - Bill Gates - Speech and Debate - Essay

715 words - 3 pages Bill Gates Akshar Sharma Bill Gates. A lot of you have probably heard this name. Business magnate. Investor. Author. Philanthropist. Humanitarian. So many different things and one man. Bill Gates is also very famous for being the cofounder of Microsoft Corporation, one of the most famous electronics company in the world. Currently, Bill Gates works a lot with the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. Today I will talk about Bill Gates’ early life

Models of Democracy- Essay about the models of democracy and how it is used in our US Government - Valdosta State University/ American Government - Essay

1557 words - 7 pages Jensen Armstrong American Government Professor- Ernest Smith Due date- 01/16/16 Models of Democracy Paper As Franklin D. Roosevelt once said “Let us never forget that government is ourselves and not an alien power over us. The ultimate rulers of our democracy are not a President and senators and congressman and government officials, but the voters of this country.” Which he is right, we the people have a lot of say in government and democracy

Nat Turner and the reasons behind on why he did what he did - MSJC /History - Essay on a historical figure

625 words - 3 pages , Turner was sold to Thomas Moore. In the beginning year of 1830, Moore died, and Turner was moved once again to another slave owner who ended up being Joseph Travis. His original owner was Putnum Moore, Cordova2 but he was still a young child. Turner described Joseph Travis as kind and did not have any complaints against him. It was amazing how the slaves could think for themselves and design the plan without the help of outsiders or just people

Article II of the US Constitution grants the president numerous powers and responsibilities - Government - Paper

1437 words - 6 pages within that time, the bill will not become law. In modern times, the president also has a responsibility to the legislature: he must annually address Congress on the state of the Union. The roles of chief executive, chief of state, commander in chief, chief diplomat, and a key legislator originated in the Constitution. But over time, the presidency has acquired many other roles that the Constitutions framers never imagined. One of these roles if party

State House Yard Speech On The Constitution

917 words - 4 pages the Constitution was perhaps even dangerous, because it allowed for an army to be in place, even in times of peace.The day before Wilson made his speech, anti-Federalist Samuel Bryan published an essay in the Independent Gazetteer, a Philadelphian newspaper. The essay attacked the power of the central government, the severity of state authority, and the absence of a bill of rights, which should have guaranteed individual liberties like freedom of

this reflects on the assignments of ucsb social 118c class - University of California, Santa Barbara/ Race - essay

644 words - 3 pages Professor Cruz Sociology 118C May 22nd, 2018 Reflection Music is the root to much joy, to expression, the capability to reference to something. Music is the tool that many individuals rely on to connectivity to their traditions, culture, etc. It helps individuals clarifying who they are, their gender norms, their likings, etc. Music provokes emotions in people and upraises discussions that not a lot of media is capable of doing. The thing with

Thomas Edison : the US Inventor - University of LA - Essay

745 words - 3 pages the citizen of their country who aimed high and achieved a lot in his field. It served as an encouragement among the rest of the Americans that poverty and physical incapability can not hinder one from achieving his dreams. Just like Edison who experience poverty once in his life, who was a railroad worker, sold candies, fruits and newspaper and then became partially deaf after his work in the rail road. Edison was optimistic and continued his dreams through his inventions that made him renowned all over the world by being a great and intelligent inventor.

This Is An Essay Analyzing The Articles Of Confederation As A First Draft For The Constitution

526 words - 3 pages have a rough draft and establishing a nation is no different. Without the experiences of inter state rivalries, lack of funding, and problems with foreign policy, they would not have been fixed or provided for in the constitution. The Articles proved to Americans the necessity of a strong federal government that still delegates some power to the states. With all its shortcomings, it did govern the U.S. for a short time without any huge disasters befalling the country. While not a good document in the long run, it was an excellent learning experience and a great short-term plan.

Why did the League of Nations fail? - High School/History - Essay

742 words - 3 pages Italy, Britain and France tried to make a secret pact to give Abyssinia to Italy. The reason why this was such a damaging occurence to the League was because they had continuously shown that when tasked with important issues, they did not have the resources in order to complete the tasks at hand. Disarmament, the Manchurian crisis, and the Abyssinian crisis proved that the leagues idea of collective security did not work. League members were not

To What Extent Did James Dean Impact Teenager Lives of The 1950s? - US History and American Lit - Essay

977 words - 4 pages Leah Allen Hane/Dawson American Lit/US History 5/10/19 To what extent did James Dean impact the lives of teenagers in the 1950s? Thesis: James Dean impacted teenagers in the 1950s by creating a teenage culture and a new American teenager, however James Dean’s rebellious life and actions inspired teenagers to act out through James Dean’s movie, Rebel Without a Cause. II./A The birth of Rock n Roll caused a uprising between parents, teenager, and