Analysis Of Two Opposing Arguments - Should Euthanasia Be Illegal Due To Malpractice?

1175 words - 5 pages

Section 1: The Argument
1. Debate question: Should euthanasia be illegal due to malpractice?
2. Title: Euthanasia: We can live without it CNN. com 3. Publication and Date: 12:29 PM ET, Wed November 27, 2013 4. Form: Argument 5. Viewpoint: In the article, the author states the principal reason of euthanasia and how it came to be legal to relieve terminally ill adults and possibly children. Instead it is now being taken advantage of by doctors, nurses and patients. The assisted suicide is now being used to help the disabled, depressed, etc. The author's viewpoint in this article is to state and point out all of the negative outcomes and exploitations of assisted suicide. The author, Dr. Kevin Fitzpatrick, incorporates many studies, statistics, and cases that prove that practitioners of euthanasia in Belgium are misusing the drugs and their power as doctors.
6. Conclusion: At the end of the article, the statistics stated that euthanasia cases aren't
reported, which play a part with the corruption of the doctors. He also states many cases done by Dr. Wim Distelmans, a "protege" in euthanasia. With the cases Fitzpatrick proves the drugs are being used on the disabled instead of critical patients. He also asserts Sanchez 2 how doctors don't explain any other options for the patient, which makes the patient lack support. Therefore the article suggest that the euthanasia law in Belgium law is not safe and it should be stopped before they extend the law to children.
7. Reasons: The article statistically proved that euthanasia is unsafe because approximately
half (47%) of euthanasia deaths that have been done in Belgium are not reported, which makes it illegal. Deaths are also being carried out by nurses instead of doctors, and some deaths are even done without consent. Dr. Distelman, the "protege" in charge of doing many euthanasia cases, has ended the life of many people who weren't terminally ill. For example, Nancy/Nathan Verhelst was botched after many sex change operations, and he/she desired death by euthanasia. Distelman also killed Mark and Eddy Verbessem, 45-year-old twins who were deaf and wanted to end their life because their eyesight was soon going to fail them too. Another case was a woman Ann, who was anorexic and was seeing a psychiatrist that was helping her with her condition, but decided she wanted to end her life after being sexually abused by her psychiatrist.
Section 2: Critique Questions
1. Argument structure: The article is structured in sections: introduction, background
information, statistics/results and a conclusion at the end. The author takes a medical outtake on the situation and uses statistics and patient cases to prove the argument.
2. Ambiguous or prejudicial words: The author does not use any ambiguous word or
prejudicial words in the article. Only proven statistics and professional viewpoints were used.
3. Fallacies: The article does not contain any fallacies....

KEEP READING

Are There Any Arguments To Be Made That Self-sufficiency Is Desirable? What Would Be The Arguments Of Those Who Contend That Trade In Cultural Relics Should Be Strictly State-regulated?

395 words - 2 pages ... to the less developed. Less radical analysts called for policies of temporarily restricting imports so that countries could develop a comparative advantage in higher value added products.Adam Smith argued that it would be foolhardy to purchase higher priced domestically produced goods if such goods were available elsewhere at a lower price. Mutual gains from trade are due to division of labor (advocated by liberal economists). Self-sufficiency ...

Should Euthanasia Be Legalized In Canada? (FOR)

776 words - 4 pages ... our lives? Firstly, euthanasia should be legalized because patients who are terminally ill will die anyway; they should not be forced to experience their bodies disintegrate. In the state of Oregon, the only place in North America that has legalized euthanasia, a report revealed that among terminally ill people, one of the most common reasons for wanting to die early was the decreased ability to participate in activities that made life ...

Animal Testing Should Be Illegal - Moscow - Research

987 words - 4 pages ... 1 Armendariz Leo Armendariz Mrs. Dance ELA 9/3rd Hour 21 March 2016 Animal Testing In Medical Research Should Be Illegal Animals are being killed every day due to research in cosmetics, medicine, and other human products. Drugs we get from animal testing are extremely dangerous to both animals and humans. Creatures used in medical labs get treated poorly. What happens to animals after they are done with their research? There are other options ...

NAPLAN Practice - Tobacco Should Be Illegal Essay - Year 9 - Essay

734 words - 3 pages ... Production and sale of tobacco should be illegal Lethal, Damaging and carless. With every breath, 7000 cells are murdered. The numerous negative health aspects of tobacco use should enforce the idea that this drug sale should be illegal, for the sake of our families, children and pets. The many risks of smoking out way any positive outcome from the sale of this corrupting drug. Tobacco kills a person every six seconds. The governments ...

Lack Of Communication Due To Technology - San Jacinto College - Essay

2158 words - 9 pages ... Saber 1 Saber 5 Mostafa Saber Professor Casey Zander ENGL 1302-7F5 24 April 2016 Lack of Communication Due to Technology Communication is one of the most fundamental aspects of human life. You can imagine how life would be without communication. Technology, on the other hand, is the solution to human problems, in the sense that technology makes work easier (Bargh, John, and Katelyn, 2004). Simply, it means that both of these aspects are vital ...

To What Extent Should We Consider The Picture Of Dorian Gray To Be A Gothic Novel? - English Lit - ESSAY

2891 words - 12 pages Free ... ESSAY 5: To what extent should we consider The Picture of Dorian Gray to be a Gothic novel? Oscar Wilde’s first, and only, novel published in 1890 in Lipincott’s Magazine. Despite the censorship that the editor made unbeknownst to Wilde, his text still largely offended its bourgeoisie audience due to its critique on moral sensibility and public morality in the upper-class society. Wilde, irrefutably, includes many stereotypical conventions and ...

On The Negative Effects Of Natural Resource Extraction Due To Globalization - Mcgill INTD 200 - Essay

2521 words - 11 pages ... resource exploitation through the market driven incentives of companies, who are purely concerned with their personal profit and less so for the communities their extraction affects[footnoteRef:6]. Due to globalization nation states are very vulnerable to other countries decisions made abroad. Institutions who would not be impacted by their own choices for communities’ abroad, are not being held accountable for these choices, as they are not the ones ...

Should Tourists Be Able To Climb Uluru - English - Essay

527 words - 3 pages ... contended that tourists climbing Uluru was beneficial, however many of the arguments presented suggest otherwise. For starters, not many people climb Uluru anyway, so if it was banned, it would not be affecting a large amount of the population. The risk of climbing the sacred site would be completely removed, as well as the disrespect to the Indigenous beliefs. The article was ambiguous yet provided a clear intended audience consistently ...

Teens Should Not Be Allowed To Smoke Faizan Sadiq

1432 words - 6 pages ... smoking can do to them right now. Everyday, almost 4000 children under 18 will smoke for the first time, of which 2000 will become addicted. Teens should not be smoking-- at all! Teens are being influenced by tobacco advertisements. If teens are smoking around friends that don't, they are causing harm to their body by secondhand smoke. Smoking is causing damage to their education and is changing them. The most important thing teens don't understand is ...

What Should The Core Functions Of Policing Be?

2352 words - 10 pages ... activitieswithout disruption from either criminal threats or natural catastrophe.From this, it should be recognised that security has two bases: that of the individual or group, and as it applies to or concerns an organisation. (Victoria Police c2006 a)At special events such as the recent Commonwealth Games, Grand Pix and any AFL Football match you often see a lot more security than police. Security guards can be anyone ranging from patrolling the major ...

Should The Date Of Australia Day Be Changed - CSCS - Essay

770 words - 4 pages ... I address this speech to all those sitting in the audience without a heart. How do you live with yourself? Are you completely ignorant or do you choose to be completely insensitive to all those who are not white Australians? Yes, we all love our country, our beautiful country of “sizzling snags” and supposed multiculturalism. However, there is a point where you take your nationalism too far and let your narrow opinions prevent you from realising ...

Should The UK Join The Euro Or Remain Master Of Its Own Fiscal Destiny. What Are The Arguments For And Against?

3005 words - 13 pages Free ... benefited least from EU status . When assessing British business attitudes to Europe this cultural bias cannot be discounted. Certainly the government needs to help informed decisions. This document is intended to present facts by outlining the concepts of the Single Market and Currency, collate opinions and try to draw some conclusions on to which way Britain trade should proceed. Are its perceptions of Europe insight or inertia?The Single ...

Homosexuality In A Christian Society....this Essay Discusses Both Sides To The Controversial Subject Of Whether Or Not Homosexuals Should Be Accepted By A Christian Civilization

1268 words - 6 pages ... In today's humanity there are countless prejudices that occur. They vary from racial, and gender prejudices to sexual preference and religious discrimination. I have chosen to explore the statistics of people who are homosexual and if it should be morally accepted in a Christian society. I am not really positive on how I stand on this subject because I am a religious person, and my church has stated that, "all who seek to live faithfully ...

To What Extent Was The Rise Of The Nazi Party Due To The Weaknesses Of The Weimar Republic - HSC Modern History - Essay

1244 words - 5 pages ... To what extent was the rise of the Nazi Party due to the weaknesses of the Weimar Republic? While the weaknesses of the Weimar republic played a crucial role in the rise of the NSDAP, without the prolonged and devastating impact of the Great Depression Hitler would not have come to power. The inherent weaknesses of the Weimar constitution meant continuous political instability while the association of the democratic system with the defeat of WWI ...

Should Handguns Be Banned? "the Need To Live - The Need To Ban Guns"

610 words - 3 pages ... Description:This essay is an argument whether or not handguns should be banned. It is a pretty neat, a good persuasive essay.The Need to Live - The Need to Ban Guns Last year, about 50,000 Americans died from gun-inflicted injuries. Guns are, non-arguably, designed to kill. Carrying of guns has been a major topic of discussion and argument over the past several years and it has gotten no where close to a solution. Guns should be banned.The fact ...

Analysis Of Two Opposing Arguments - Should Euthanasia Be Illegal Due To Malpractice?

More like Analysis Of Two Opposing Arguments - Should Euthanasia Be Illegal Due To Malpractice?