Assess The Role The European Court Of Justice Has Played In European Integration? University Essay

998 words - 4 pages

The process of European Integration, which began more than 60 years ago, is still developing and expanding. In this changing and developing process, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) has played and continues to play considerable role in the European Integration. In other words, the role of the ECJ has been central in the broader process of European Integration. While the ECJ makes binding decisions on disputes over Treaty provisions or secondary legislation and thus it has gained expanding power and role in the European Union (EU), it has been accused of generally ruling in favour of integrationist solutions to disputes. Moreover, decisions of the ECJ, which have direct effect on national jurisdiction and supremacy over conflicting domestic laws, have caused considerable debate on the dynamics of the sovereignty and reduction in the authority of national governments.
The Court of Justice of the European Union (ECJ), one of the seven institutions of the EU, was established in its first form in 1952 as the Court of Justice of the European Coal and Steel Communities. The Court encompasses the whole judiciary system within the European Union. Three limited roles were assigned to the ECJ when it was created. A first role was to ensure ‘that the Commission and the Council of Ministers did not exceed their authority’, subsequently extended on the other EU institutions. A second role of the Court was related to the dispute resolution by interpreting and filling in vague aspects of disputed EC laws, in other words the Court is ‘filling in the [incomplete] contract through its legal decisions’. And finally, the ECJ was also designed to ‘decid[e] of charges of noncompliance raised by the Commission or by member states.
To overcome collective action problems, EU member states had to establish a rule of law, which makes the agreements of the treaties binding on participants. In order to achieve that, a mechanism for punishing non-compliance (judiciary system) with common agreed rules is put in place. The European Union is characterised by an existence of a rule of law, and therefore the EU system of governance can be described as quasi-constitutional system, which was gradually established by progressive constitutionalisation of the treaties through rulings of the ECJ. Some scholars argue (eg. neo-functionalists), that in order to produce the incentive for parties to abide by the law it is necessary that the institutions enforcing law are independent from legislature, which means that a separation of powers between judiciary and legislature need to be present. This theoretical model assumes ‘that the separation of powers works because judges are neutral political actors: they exercise judgement instead of will’, it can be said with whole certainty that ‘judges do have will’ (preferences).
The phenomenon described above is defined by political scientists as “judicial politics" and it is clearly visible in the EU. The EU’s judiciary is able to exercise its...

Other Essays On Assess the role the European Court of Justice has played in European integration? - University - Essay

19th Century European Imperialism Data Based Essay; Identify And Explain The Political, Economic, And Social Causes Of European Imperialism In The 19th Century

406 words - 2 pages contributed to the need to pull ahead of other nations in the technological field. In Document one, "Imperialism and World Politics," Parker T. Moon argues that above political leaders, economic powerhouses were most interested in imperialism because of the need for raw materials. He continues to discuss the urgency of European companies to invest in the colonies in order to make new profit. Then, in Document two, Senator A. J. Beveridge debates how it

Assess The Roles Played By Science And Technology In The Construction Of C19th And/Or C20th American Urban Space?

1894 words - 8 pages After World 1 the United States were left virtually unharmed, the United States was even able to experience a decade of peace and prosperity following such a disastrous war. Of the many reasons for America's prosperity, technology played one of the most vital parts in bringing the great economic and cultural prosperity that America experienced during the 1920s. New advancements, new discoveries, and new inventions such as the car, radio

Is Racism in the Justice System - saint leo university - essay

2668 words - 11 pages of people of color sentenced to prison would have received a shorter or non-incarcerated sentence if they had been treated in court the same way as white defendants facing similar charges (Defending Justice). Inequality in the system is a slap in the face to every African American that is a citizen of this country. In September of 1998, a middle-aged black man by the name of Broderick James was arrested and charged

Ethical Violations in the Criminal Justice System - University of Phoenix CJS211 - Essay

896 words - 4 pages , 2014) Criminal Justice Agency’s Involvement The agencies involved in the sentencing for Spaulding include both the United States Attorney for the District of Connecticut and the Federal Bureau of Investigation along with the U.S. District Court. Spaulding’s actions were actually discovered as part of a larger criminal investigation into certain members of the East Haven Police Department. Some officers had allegedly been using excessive force

The Foundations of the European Union: Robert Schuman - ANU/ EURO2012 - Essay

2663 words - 11 pages ] Available at: http://aei.pitt.edu/11046/1/Silva-MonnetLong09edi.pdf [Accessed 25 Mar. 2018].] In conclusion, it is substantially demonstrated that Robert Schuman was the key founding ‘Father’ of the European Project in that he played the pivotal role of implementing European federalist intergovernmentalism ideals which allowed for European integration. However, Jean Monnet was in fact the brain architect of the European project and that Schuman in his

"To what extent did France promote the unification of Italy?" Short Essay - European History - Essay

668 words - 3 pages To what extent did France promote the unification of Italy from 1848 to 1870? During the Italian Unification, France was one of the most prominent countries present as the revolutions played out. However, it is arguable whether France helped or hindered Italy during its unification. It is true that the Franco-Sardinian alliance provided Italy with protection against one of their biggest enemies, Austria, and that France bore the majority of the

Why did England lead in the Industrial Revolution? - AP European History - Long Essay Question

1327 words - 6 pages English Leadership in European Industrialization The Industrial Revolution of the eighteenth to nineteenth centuries, a time of severe change that included the economic development and creations of significant inventions that innovated specific industries such as the textile industry, was centered and initiated in Britain before spreading throughout the continent of Europe and the Americas. Inventions that aided the textile industry included the

Importance, or unimportance of the German Reformation in the mission work of the European church - History of the church BA Theology - Essay

2198 words - 9 pages the church in culture because resources, time and gifts are not combined to preach the gospel. However, Kim (2012, p. 101), claims reformation has given birth to Pentecostalism which is characterised by the experience of the Holy Spirit through healing. The growth of Pentecostalism has formed a basis for mission work in the present European church because people are attracted by the demonstration of God’s power of healing through prayer (Anderson

The role of Monomania in The Revenger's Tragedy - University of Bristol - Essay

3690 words - 15 pages Shakespeare's Theatre, H. Higbee & W. West Eds., (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000), pp. 180-215 ] [5: Particularly in The Revenger’s Tragedy, where even the authorship has been lost. ] Vindice’s blindness to all but revenge is maintained in the opening scene as he talks directly to the skull of Gloriana, ‘Thou sallow picture of my poisoned love’ (I.i.14). This subtextually instructs the actor to direct his speech physically to the ‘shell of

Who was the most Enlightened Monarch? - AP European History - Essay

797 words - 4 pages Which of the Enlightened monarchs was the most enlightened and why? In 17th and 18th century Europe, enlightenment was referred to as the age of reason. Enlightenment thinkers questioned traditional European authority and thought that humanity could be changed by rational thinking and change. They tried to apply the principles of the age of reason and the enlightenment into their kingdoms. Most of the philosophers during the time thought that a

‘Discuss the role of women in Homer’s Iliad.’ - Monash University - Essay

842 words - 4 pages ‘Discuss the role of women in Homer’s Iliad with particular reference to the character of Andromache.’ The role of women in Homer’s Iliad is one which is often overshadowed by their male counterparts. Much of the Iliad is focused on glory in battle and the heroic code, however Homer still manages to include scenes which show the effects of war on women. While Helen is generally considered to be the main female mortal character in the Iliad, I

Similar Papers

El Greco’s Assumption Of The Virgin: Man’s Lifting Of Mary Unto God De Paul University European Art History Essay

2053 words - 9 pages 1 El Greco’s Assumption of the Virgin: Man’s Lifting of Mary unto God HAA 130: Introduction to European Art The masterpiece that is El Greco’s Assumption of the Virgin leaves the viewer breathless upon first sight of it monumental stature. Without yet being close enough to notice the fine details it contains, Assumption draws you in to take a closer look because of its impossible-to-miss size. My eyes were drawn to the front-and-center image of

European Union And United States Comparison Report University Of Phoenix/Geo 155 Essay

490 words - 2 pages citizens. In essence, the EU’s Council, European Parliament and the European Council can be compared to the U.S. President and Congress who are representatives of individual states and its citizens and are elected into office to represent them and legislate on national and international issues. Europeans views of the EU are mixed, but the economic European crisis has caused its support to decline sharply within its members, with France leading the

The Impact Of European Imperialism In Africa

593 words - 3 pages European Imperialism started in the early1800's; with the goal to prove they had wealth andpower. European nations competed with each otherto gain territory in Africa. The more they gain themore powerful they thought they would become.Africa was soon bled of it's human resources. TheEuropeans induced slavery for the beneift of theMuslim countries, from the nineth century to thenineteenth century. The last four centuries of whichwere regular

The Effect Of Submarines In Ww1 Sjcs, Honers European History Short Essay

1321 words - 6 pages Dexter Schega Dr. Kevin Stanton Modern European History 3 rd Period Thesis Paragraph and Outline March 10 th , 2018 The Use and Effect of Submarines in WWI Early into World War I the Germans had perfected the submarine called the Unterseeboot or U-boat. This technology was a major advantage to the Germans, who at the time, were the only nation to have this technology. These crafts had a consequential impact on World War I. The U-Boats had sunk