Buddha And Jesus: A Comparison Essay

2029 words - 9 pages

"...nothing now remains for the honest man to do but acknowledge the truth, which is that the history of Jesus of Nazareth[,] as related in the books of the New Testament, is simply a copy of that of Buddha, with a mixture of mythology borrowed from other nations."~T. W. Doane, (Warren)Is it true? Could it be that the founder of the world's largest religion, a major prophet of another major religion, and self-proclaimed Son of God is nothing more than a Jewified compendium of stories about a man from India? Why would anyone think so? This paper is an attempt to point out the similarities and differences of the two religions, which are at first glance but mirror reflections of each other, set ...view middle of the document...

Both births were in unusual places, which the mother of the child had to travel to. Jesus was born in the town of Bethlehem, many miles from his hometown of Nazareth. Mary laid him in a manger. Buddha was born in a grove of sala trees at which his mother stopped while traveling from her home to her native city (Mitchell 15). Jesus' birth was accompanied by divine signs, such as choirs of angels and a new star. Three magi visited Jesus sometime in his infancy, worshipping him and presenting him with luxurious gifts. Siddhartha's birth was announced by the earth and heavens singing his praises (Mitchell 16). Siddhartha was also visited by a total of one hundred eight brahmins, who were considered the wisest men of India. Instead of worshipping him, they tried to divine his destiny in the world. All of the brahmins except one declared that he would be a great ruler. The other brahmin declared that the boy would become a Buddha (Mitchell 19).It was at this time in their life that the greatest differences between Jesus and Siddhartha began to occur. Joseph and Mary were forced to flee to Egypt in order to save Jesus from the genocide of children ordered by Herod. They were only able to return after Herod's death. The family decided to settle in the town of Nazareth, where Joseph continued his work as a carpenter. Joseph and Mary expanded their family until they eventually had four more sons and several daughters (Vermes 20). During this time, and in stark contrast to Jesus' difficult childhood, Siddhartha grew up in three incredible palaces. These palaces were constructed specially by Siddhartha's father, Suddhodona Gautama, in order that his son become a proper ruler instead of the Buddha. "And so Prince Siddhartha of the house of Gautama increased in stature, well nurtured, protected from the world, and surrounded by an immense retinue in regal splendor" (Mitchell 20).At this time, there comes a lull in the life of both boys. Jesus is mentioned only once in the Bible between his return to Nazareth and the beginning of his teaching. Other sources, not officially accepted by the Christian churches, do tell some about him. Anna, Jesus' grandmother, wrote that he was very generous, giving away fruit he had picked himself and losing races to make his opponent feel better (Gibran 9). Uriah, an old man from Nazareth, wrote: "Do you not remember Him, a boy overweening, who would argue with our learned elders, and laugh at their dignity? And remember not His youth, when He lived by the saw and chisel? He would not accompany our sons and daughters on their holidays. He would walk alone." (Gibran 98). The general consensus is that Jesus was a hard-working and skilled carpenter, who enjoyed solitary time very much. So it seems that his life was fairly uneventful until the age of thirty.Siddhartha also seemed to have a fairly uneventful life until the age of twenty- nine. In his boyhood, he was widely praised for his ability to master all skills without any...

Other Essays On Buddha And Jesus: A Comparison

Comparison Between "King Lear" And "A Streetcar Named Desire"

1918 words - 8 pages Tracing Aristotle's tragic hero model in "King Lear" and "A Streetcar Named Desire":Aristotle defines tragedy as a form of drama which imitates noble people through artistically enhanced language and through pitiable and fearful incidents. According to Aristotle, tragedy involves several aspects that eventually lead to catharsis, an emotional cleansing of the audience. Some of these aspects include pity, fear, reversal and recognition. Reversal

Transcendentalism At A Glance, The Comparison Between Ralph Waldo Emerson's Writings, And A Cat Stevens Song

880 words - 4 pages at last sacred but the integrity of your own mind." Ralph Waldo Emerson contends that if a person is evil by nature, then evil is good and good is evil. He also writes, "They do not seem to me such; but if I am the Devil's child, I will live then from the Devil." Basically the Devil, when he thinks of himself, does not infer that he is evil. He sees himself as doing something correct and good. "100 I Dream," by Stevens, displays the idea that

A Comparison Of The Imagery And Language In "The Handmaid's Tale" And Judith Wright's Poems

1021 words - 5 pages In Margaret Atwood's "The handmaid's tale" and Judith Wright poems, some subject matters are similar because there are a lot of imageries based on children and men, from voices of a woman. In "the handmaid's tale" the narrator has lost her child and husband, and in some Judith Wright poems it is about a woman's love for men, and a child being born. Looking at the imagery and language used, we can compare between the approach the writers are

Comparison Of "The Hearing Trumpet"-Leonora Carrington And "If This Is A Man"- Primo Levi

1542 words - 7 pages The Behavioural differences of both main characters in a forced institution.Primo Levi and Marian Leatherby both find themselves in a forced institution and they both have many obstacles they must face and as different that these institutions are, fundamentally both Marian and Primo Levi did not make a willing choice to be there.The obvious differences in the institutions both find themselves most likely changes they’re initial reaction

"Oh,Sweet Irony" / A Comparison/Contrast Paper About The Ironies In Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal" And Susan Glaspell's "Trifles"

1448 words - 6 pages Oh, Sweet Irony"A Modest Proposal" (1729) by Jonathan Swift relates one man's facetious point of view on the state of Ireland's impoverished. Swift offers a solution to the problem by suggesting that the overpopulation conundrum can by solved by indulging in the flesh of the nation's underprivileged infants. Susan Glaspell's Trifles (1916) depicts an early twentieth century murder-mystery and the role that two women take in solving the mystery

This is a comparison/contrast about love vs. infatuation. It dicusses the differences by considering three elements common to both: interest, concern, and endurance

511 words - 3 pages Love vs. InfatuationEveryone wants to be in love, but very few people know what it means. When someone sees another person he or she is attracted to he or she may think "Oh, my God, I'm in love" but is it real love or just simple infatuation? There is a great difference between love and infatuation, and when trying to determine the difference there are at least three things a person should consider: interest, concern, and endurance.The first

Buddha

905 words - 4 pages The teachings of Buddha are slightly different from those of other religions. Ultimately, it is focused on the clearing of ones mind and achieving a highly enlightened state called nirvana. This can be reached by doing many things. One of which is causing no harm to surrounding life. Also, the ability to control positive karma in their lives can increase their chances of reaching this state. Buddha stated the Four Noble Truths to explain

Response To Dharmasiri's "A Buddhist Critique"

598 words - 3 pages To utilize a Buddhist perspective and to quote the Buddha for the purpose of constructing an evaluation of theism seems to me singularly inappropriate, if only for the mere fact that these Buddhist beliefs are taken out of context. Early in "A Buddhist Critique," the author, Gunapala Dharmasiri, states, "it is the context that gives religious statements their meaning" (Kessler 1999, p.116). However, contrary to this professed belief, he

Jesus Of History, Christ Of Faith - Historical Evidence Regarding The Life Of Jesus

1101 words - 5 pages contain extrapolations of the truth designed to make Jesus appear greater than he was?The Gospel of Matthew is considered by some to be the most important of the four Gospels. Believed to have been written between 80 and 90 AD by an unknown author, it paints an image of Jesus as definitely being the Messiah and places emphasis on demonstrating that Jesus' life full filled the prophecies made in the Old Testament, portraying him as a second, greater

Jesus and the beginning of Christianity

493 words - 2 pages , resurrection, and his love for the people all had a major impact on the reason why Christianity was established.Jesus' message was an important art in the process of establishing Christianity. His teachings were pretty much the basic beliefs for Christians. They reminded the people of what God expects from the people. Jesus traveled on a pilgrimage with his apostles making miracles, spreading monotheism, and teaching people the principles of the

God, The Answer Of Life And Death

2001 words - 9 pages Jesus Christ travelled from village to village challenging religious authorities. Jesus was killed on a cross for his behavior, but he rose from the dead to become the Messiah. Jesus' followers brought Christianity to what it is today. Buddhism is an offshoot of Hinduism. Buddha Shakyamuni in approximately 500 B.C.E did not agree with the Hindu idea of reincarnation. He thought that being pure and good, would stop the cycle of reincarnation. There

Similar Papers

A Comparison Of Hinduism And Theosophy

2141 words - 9 pages become an essential part of the Hindu culture and help guide a day-to-day life.The Hindu's worldview is mapped out in four goals, Dharma, Artha, Karma, and Moksha. Each one of these elements deserves a separate essay on the sole subject in order to fully understand them, but for the sake of comparison I will present the basic idea of each.Dharma, the main goal in Hinduism, consists of righteousness and morality. Dharma is your social and religious

Kant's Moral Theory And Liberalism: A Comparison

775 words - 4 pages Kant's Moral Theory and Liberalism: A comparison Liberalism is a broad body of philosophy. It is defined as the set of philosophical and social theories that, despite their differences, are committed to a common set of presuppositions and principles (Goldberg 519). It is based on four general principles: individualism, universalism, equality, and reform. Individualism is the paramount principle. It is to protect the rights of people from the

The First Christians Proclaimed That The Crucified Jesus Was Raised To Life And Exalted Into The Realm Of God, A Metahistorical Event. Thus The Risen Lord Is The Resurrection And The Life

553 words - 3 pages The first Christians proclaimed that the crucified Jesus was raised to life and exalted into the realm of God. For them, this equals salvation. This affirms both the beliefs that Jesus lives on in the faith of the community as well as God acting in behalf of Jesus thus He is alive. Furthermore, they believed that His resurrection is not a return to life in this world but it is rather a passage into another world, an assumption into the sphere of

A Comparison Between Shelly's "Frankenstein" And Hopkins' Poetry

1244 words - 5 pages Jeremy Griffith: author of Free: The End of The Human Condition (1988), Beyond The Human Condition (1991), and, in 2003, the Australasian bestseller A Species In Denial...Philosopher, Albert Camus, said once. He who despairs over an event is a coward, but he who holds hope for the human condition is a fool.Humans to this day have struggled to find answers to two questions, who is our creator and what role does he or she play, and if there is a