This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Case Brief Essay

538 words - 3 pages

Brendan FulcherCase Brief 2Tor Wynn8 May 2013Case Brief 2This crime occurred on October 5, 1983. A man and his significant other (who occupy the same house) ate dinner together, and then met at a pool hall at separate times. The woman arrived first, when the man (also the defendant) arrived he saw his significant other talking to another man, he was angry because he thought that she was cheating on him. He states that the anger quickly subsided. He left the bar alone and walked home, 10 minutes later she arrived at their shared residence and told him that he had one week to find another place to live. He consented and went ...view middle of the document...

She had stabbed herself in the struggle for the knife.The man was convicted of manslaughter; he argues that it was self-defense and that the jury was not properly instructed on the stand your ground ruling in self-defense. The jury says that since he had an opportunity to get away, that deadly force was not needed, and it was no longer self-defense.The court disagrees, they stated that in Rhode Island the statute pertaining to self-defense states that if you have the opportunity to flee without being harmed, then you have no legal right to use deadly force on the assailant. There was no dissenting opinion.The legal issue here is the mens rea, the intent to end his significant others life. This is more of a justification defense, but it also uses the excuse that she was pulling the knife towards her and that he never intended to stab her in the first place.I personally think the court is out of line here. The stand your ground precedent in my mind makes what he did nothing more than an accident or self-defense. He never intended to end her life and he was only trying to keep himself from being stabbed. She started the fight in the bedroom up stairs, he left that fight, only to be met with a knife to the face, he was within his rights to take action in my opinion.

Other Essays On Case Brief

The Essence of Chocolate (brief introduction)

272 words - 2 pages The Essence of ChocolateThe pure indulgence of chocolate has become America's favorite. In the beginning chocolate, which is derived from a cacao bean, was worshipped as an idol by the Mayan Indians over 2,000 years ago. Dating back to the 1500's, the last Aztec emperor, Montezuma II, was consuming a drink called "Cacahuatt". Chocolate was a delicacy that only the rich and important could indulge in, it was treated as a "treasure". After Hernando

A brief biography of William Shakespeare

398 words - 2 pages William ShakespeareThe baptismal register of the Holy Trinity parish church, in Stratford, shows Shakespeare was baptised just 3 days after birth, this is probably because of the strong religious beliefs at the time. His parents were worried he would not survive his first few days, so they had him baptised to make sure he went to heaven. The actual date of Shakespeare's birth is not known, but, traditionally, April 23, St George's Day, 1564, has

Brief Outline Of Death And Diseases In The Medieval Era

951 words - 4 pages A disease is 'a disordered or incorrectly functioning organ, part, structure, or system of the body resulting from the effect of genetic or developmental errors, infection, poisons, nutritional deficiency or imbalance, toxicity, or unfavorable environmental factors; illness; sickness; ailment'.Six examples of diseases are;-Cancer-Meningococcal Disease-Hepatitis B-Hepatitis A-Hepatitis C-Black DeathThese can be transmitted by touch, saliva, air

"A Rose For Emily" by William Faulkner- A Brief Explanation

512 words - 3 pages Emily Grierson is the protagonist in the story " A Rose For Emily" written by William Faulkner. Emily, is an eccentric, unmarried, lonely, and sad person whos pride and loneliness cause her to murder her lover and persue endless love. Her family's position in the town used to be very prestiges. Mainly because of her fathers money. Since Emily's father is dead she has to make do with what little money she has got. While her father was alive he

Qualities Of A Good Parent -Short And Brief

497 words - 2 pages How is a parent supposed to become a good parent opposed to being a bad one? Many different people have different opinions on what makes a "good" parent. Many can agree that there are some general qualities that a "good" parent must have. A good parent is one who has a good source of income, has good ways of bringing up a child, and has time for their child.Income, ways of raising and time are all very crucial things to consider when being a

These Notes List The First 11 Presidents With Brief Reviews Of Their Presidencies

3990 words - 16 pages A)George Washington (189-1797) ("Father of His Country")In 1789 George Washington ran against John Adams and John Jay. Washington was part of the Federalist Party. Between 1759 and 1788 Washington was also member to the House of Burgess, the Continental Congress and Chairman of the Constitutional Convention. His Cabinet members were as follows:Secretary of StatesJohn Jay (1789-90), Thomas Jefferson (1790-93), Edmund Randolph (1794-95)Secretary of

The Country of Honduras: A brief report on Honduras, including its economy, culture, environment, etc

506 words - 3 pages Pablo Bryce AmackerSra. RobinsonSpanish 14/17/07HondurasHonduras is located south of Nicaragua and on the west of Guatemala. It is the second largest country in Central America after Nicaragua. The capital and the largest city is Tegucigalpa, a word which means "silver hills", derived from a dead Indian language. Even though Honduras has a population of 1,200,000 people, it is still Latin America's 2nd poorest nation. About 80% of Hondurans live

A brief paragraph on the analysis of the Attic scene in "Obasan" by Joy Kogawa

501 words - 3 pages The shaping of future through the Past and Prsent of Nomi in "Obasan" by Joy KogawaThe scene in which Nomi and Obasan are in the attic is a significant metaphor as it relates three of the most important recurring themes through the entire novel. The fact that Nomi's life is solely based on a confrontation of her past and present childhood, and how her past and present will shape her entire future. While rumiging through the attic, they both

This Essay Is A Brief History Of Rattle And Snap Plantation In Mt. Pleasant, TN. Describes Owners (Past And Present) And Other Information On The House

1726 words - 7 pages The history of Rattle and Snap dates back to just after the Revolutionary War. Back then, the U.S. Government did not have the money to pay its soldiers, so they issued land grants. One of those soldiers was Lt. Colonel William Polk. William was very good friends with the Governor of North Carolina, the governor was his brother-in-law.One day, William and the governor got involved in a gambling game. The governor was losing very badly, and in

Normal Case Study. About A Used Car Deal Gone Bad. Canadian Law Courts

770 words - 4 pages the parties is rescinded. The defendant shall return the plaintiff's money and the plaintiff shall return the Mercedes to the defendants. Also an extra $350 was awarded for work done on the car during the brief ownership by the plaintiff.Does the case make new law or did the judge apply existing law to the facts in the case?The judge applied existing laws. He used the Licensing of Trades and Business Act as a reference for the case.If the case

Business Structure

320 words - 2 pages Business StructureWhen Comencing a business, it is important to considr the best form of proprietorship or ownership of the business. There are four basic entities which are presently available:-Sole Traders-Partnership-Company-Trading TrustThe following points are a brief outline of these four entities. And i will be covering the Company part in this report.CompanyA business may be conducted by a Company as an entity in its own right and comes

Similar Papers

Ring V. Arizona Case Brief Essay

1533 words - 7 pages Ring v. Arizona122 S Ct 2428 (2002)Facts of the case:On November 28, 1994, The body of an armored van driver was found dead inside the vehicle. Also, there was more than $800,000 missing from the van leading police to believe that this was a robbery and homicide case. There were no witnesses to the crime except a local bystander who stated that two vehicles, a van and a red truck were speeding down the road earlier that day and had neglected to

A Brief Overview Of The Susan Smith Court Case

1070 words - 5 pages On the night of October 25, 1994 Susan Smith took the lives of her two sons. Susan Smith committed the most unthinkable act when she broke humanity's most sacred trust, the love of a mother for her children (Crime Library).On November 18, 1994, a hearing was held before Circuit Judge John Hayes at the request of Solicitor Thomas Pope. Pope requested that Susan undergo a psychological examination by an impartial physician to determine whether she

A Brief History Of Computer Essay

325 words - 2 pages The first all-electronic compute, based on vacuum tubes, was developed in 1946 by J. Presper Eckert and John W. Mauchly of the University of Pennsylvania. Atahis computer could make calculation a thousand times faster than earlier devices." The Macintosh must be running system software version 7.5 or higher and be equipped with a drive that supports Apple PC Exchange.1 Save your Windows file to a 3.5-inch floppy disk or a CD-ROM.2 Insert the

A Brief History Of Time Essay

446 words - 2 pages teach only what they believe. In science they only teach what scientist think is the way the universe works. In Stephen Hawking's book A Brief History of Time, Hawking's approach to science is not only to understand " God's mind," but also to look at the universe and test the hypotheses against the observation.Among the phenomenon he has an idea discovered on the eventual element of matter through his chapter " Space and Time", " The