Explaining The Ethics Of War: Examples From The Fall Of Constantinople And The Afghanistan War Grade 12 Philosophy Class Assignment

2306 words - 10 pages

Ethics of War
Ethics of War
Ethics of War
Simal Gormus
HZTU41
Mr. Smith
November 30, 2017
Abstract
The morality of wars has been discussed over the centuries and has been a critical subject. This essay examines the ethical aspect of wars by introducing the Just War Theory; its history and criterias, discloses the ideas of St. Augustine, Cicero, Hugo Grotius, Nicollo Machiavelli, Thomas Hobbes and Immanuel Kant about the reasons why and when a war should be waged and analyzing two widely known conflicts that have occured throughout the history of war: The Fall of Constantinople and The Afghanistan War.
Ethics of War
Human beings have been fighting each other since the prehistoric times, and the rights and wrongs of it have been argued for almost as long. Despite the undeniable fact that some wars have been fought for justice and peace, wars have always led to fear, destruction, and hatred. Causes of wars raised curiosity about the ethics of war by questions like;
· Is it ever right to go to war?
· When is it right to conduct a war?
· How can war be fought so that our moral standards are not violated?
These questions have been confronted for thousands of years by philosophers, political scientists and historians and led them to a doctrine called “Just War Theory”, which says that certain series of criteria must be met before a war is considered just. Just War Theory emerged from the writings of various ancient and medieval thinkers over the world as they sought to understand the morality of war. Eventually, a general agreement has been reached about the criterias that makes a war just. These criterias include;
· Just cause:
The aim of war needs to be in response to wrong or suffered. A war can be fought for self-defence, but not for national interests, such as revenge or acquiring power.
· Right intention:
The criteria of right intention is closely linked to the criteria of just cause. The primary purpose of a war must be to establish peace.
· Proper authority and public declaration:
A war can only be conducted if declared by a legitimate authority. Not only it has to be disclosed publicly, it also must be disclosed by the proper authority.
· A reasonable chance to success:
A war can be waged only if there is a rational chance of success. A nation cannot enter a war without a reasonable possibility of a favorable outcome.
· Last resort:
A war can be just only if all other means of avoiding a threat have been used up. These alternatives include: negotiations, economic sanctions, trade bans, etc.
· Discrimination:
The use of force must be limited by combatants. Innocent citizens must not be attacked and soldiers should always avoid harming civilians.
· Proportionality:
In order for a war to be just, it must not exceed the harm caused by the act (Paquette, P. G., & Gini-Newman, L., p. 289).
Many philosophers have argued the rightfulness of conducting war. According to early North African philosopher and Christian theologian St. Augustine, no matter...

RELATED

Cold War In The Middle East: Afghanistan

1937 words - 8 pages history of the Cold War in Afghanistan and its impacts on the troubled region, although in hindsight, can prevent similar antagonistic situations occurring in the Middle East. It will also provide greater understanding and appreciation for local context, a key variable not appreciated by megalomaniac outsiders.The Middle East is a region of vast geo-political importance. The ensemble of countries which constitute the Middle East are situated in the

The Tsar and the First World War - Year 12 - Essay

1195 words - 5 pages reached their tipping point without the first world war. WW1 made the difference between the 1905 revolution and the one in 1917- the lack of support from the army. As Walsh outlined, concerning the failure of 1905, “It was clear that no revolution would succeed as long as the army stayed loyal to the Tsar”. In conclusion, R Services perspective that the First World War was responsible for the fall of the Romanovs is sufficiently convincing

Explanation Of Moral Panic, Examples From The Uk

878 words - 4 pages The idea of moral panic was first widly introduced by Cohen in his paper 'Fork devils and moral panics' where he examined how police attempts to control youth culture in the 1960's only succeeded in more attention being focused on the sub-culture and in it escalating in popularity.After initial clashes between the 'Mod's' and 'Rocker's' in the 1960's the media sensationalized and defined the two groups. They emphasised the differences between

Portrayal of masculinity in Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and The Red Badge of Courage - Fractured Identities: American Literature from the Civil War to World War II - Essay

1594 words - 7 pages Marthe Tanghe GL/EN 3472 Fractured Identities: American Literature from the Civil War to World War II Portrayal of masculinity in ​Adventures of Huckleberry Finn ​and ​The Red Badge of Courage​: Two opposite sides of the spectrum. The representation of gender in literature has been studied in depth in the last half a century. We seem heavily engrossed in how gender portrayal can mean so many thing in novels; it can reveal plot points, character

Assignment On Weapons Of The Civil War

1424 words - 6 pages For four years, American blood spilled upon the soil of the so-called "United States". The cause of this bloodshed is known as the American Civil War, which lasted from 1861 to 1865. It put family against family, and neighbor against neighbor until the newly formed country split into the North and the South. The North, also called the Union, fought to keep the country intact. The South, also called the Confederate, fought for their right to own

Causes of the Revolutionary War Essay

337 words - 2 pages Causes of the Revolutionary WarThe greatest power in the world defeated by itself. During the forming of America in the new land, America was part of Great Britian formed by religious Puritans who came over for religous freedomAfter the French and Indian war which was a bloody and expensive battle of Great Britian agianst France for control of East America the British won, being largely in debt Great Britian decide that the colonies should pay

global studies the causes of war - global studies - assignment

1598 words - 7 pages claim there are just as many which support the alternative view in which religion does not cause war. One alternative view is due to specific events like the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001 and the advancement of technology allowing for wide distribution of various types of media is peoples opinions of religion are being altered. A well know religion and ethics writer Barney Zwartz appropriately uses a quote from Mark Twain “when it comes to

The Sorrow of War Opening Passage Analysis - International School Zug and Luzern - Sorrow of War Analysis

1125 words - 5 pages Luka Mair - 22/1/2019 The Sorrow of War​, written by Bao Ninh, is an emphatic portrayal of the Vietnam War of the 1960’s and 1970’s. The outset passage of the novel occurs in the past and chronicles Kien’s experiences in the Missing In Action body-collecting team following its culmination, and the subsequent emptiness man has developed from the conflict. Bao Ninh expresses a tone of apathy as a result of torment in order to convey the mental and

The War Of 1812 - A Second War For Independence?

1083 words - 5 pages -Intercourse Act) that severely affected the economy. These boycotts caused the value of US exports to drop from $108 million to $22 million between 1807 and 1808. This was a major blow in just one year. All these reasons are why the US had a second war for independence; but what really makes it hold true to its name are the results that came out of concurring Canada and ridding our ties with Britain for good.The end of the War of 1812 created a more

Tokugawa Regime, fall of the shogunate, transfer from feudalism to capialism - History - Assignment

5607 words - 23 pages also made increasing use was the exaction of benevolences (goyokin) from the chonin, the rising merchant and financial class. After the collapse of the seclusion policy the Shogunate’s finances rapidly degenerated. The danger from abroad obliged the government to incur heavy expenditure for improving the national defences and for maintaining diplomatic relations. Moreover, it had to pay heavy indemnities to foreign powers for atrocities on their

an essay on the causes of the vietnam war - sydney grammar school, history class - essay

1322 words - 6 pages Embers of War: The Fall of an Empire and the Making of America’s Vietnam, (Random House Publishing Group, 21 Aug 2012) p.33-34] [7: Ken Burns, Lynn Novick The Vietnam War, episode 1, (WETA-TV, Florentine Films September 17, 2017)] [8: William J Duiker, Ho Chi Minh: A Life, (Hachette Books, 12 Nov 2012) p. 84] The war was drawn out due to the guerilla nature of warfare employed by the North, which not only suffocated the numerical and

Civil War Essay - Differences of the North and South - Monash University, ATS1320: Nations at War - Essay

1649 words - 7 pages convention: December 25, 1860), Causes of the Civil War, ed. James F. Epperson, last modified June 8, 2017, http://www.civilwarcauses.org/rhett.htm] [9: Leonidas W. Spratt to Hon. Mr. Perkins of Louisiana, ‘The Philosophy of Secession; A Southern View’, (13th February 1861), Causes of the Civil War, ed. James F. Epperson, last modified June 8, 2017, http://civilwarcauses.org/spratt.htm] The deteriorating relationship between the North and South

Marketing – The Ethics of Emotion from a Can - Thompson Rivers University - BUSN 6011 - Assignment

1747 words - 7 pages Assignment 3: Marketing – The Ethics of Emotion from a Can BUSN 6011 Business Ethics & Corporate Social Responsibility - Winter 2018 Dwight Linton - TXXXXXXX Page | 1 Assignment Overview Read Ethics in Action 8.1, “Marketing—The ethics of emotions from a can,” and answer the Think Theory question on page 349. Assignment 3 Question: • In the light of the normative ethical theories discussed in Chapter 3, how can we evaluate the use of the

The Terrors of War I Want to Escape From - English Extension 11B - Short Story

1150 words - 5 pages English Short Story By Thang Truong The piercing sound of bullets, the roaring sound of heavy artillery, and the resounding terrors of war has given me another chance to serve America. It feels like my mind has escaped from what I’d thought would be an eternal darkness, as my eyes slowly fluttered open, I found myself laying along the beach shores. The sea of waves diluted in the blood of my fallen brothers, slowly crept up to collide against my

The fights of war from writing JBBJ Speeches - Snyder/La Lit 2 - Essay

1497 words - 6 pages hunt for three couples getting married.  Include all the details from start to finish.  What treasure will be waiting for the winners? 42. Name someone you owe an apology, and explain what the apology is for. 43. Are celebrities today hurting or inspiring our youth? 44. Name the funniest or most creative costume you have ever seen or worn. 45. Have you ever wanted to set a world record or break one?  What was it?  Describe your plan of attack