Gothic Elements And Guilt In "The Black Cat" And "The Tell Tale Heart" West Valley College English 1b Essay

1410 words - 6 pages

McGinley !1
Neal McGinley
Professor Richey
English 1B
10/03/2018
Essay 1
A big aspect of Gothic literature is the focus on the fault of man. We see insanity and
guilt reflected in Edgar Allan Poe’s short stories, “The Black Cat” and “The Tell-Tale Heart”.
In “The Black Cat”, subconscious guilt plays a big role in the narrator unwittingly exposing his
crime, and in the progression of the story, while in “The Tell-Tale Heart”, our narrator does not
realize that he is imagining his victim’s heartbeat, and that this auditory illusion is brought on by
his guilt. Both men try to convince the reader of their sanity. The narrator of “The Black Cat”
does this to distance himself from the guilt of his actions and to convince us he is a regular man
in unfortunate events, and not a cold-blooded murderer, whereas the narrator of “The Tell Tale
Heart” wants to convince us he is sane, to justify his crime and explain why he needed to get rid
of the “evil eye”
The narrator of “The Black Cat” uses alcohol to allay his guilt and as an excuse for the
way he treats his wife and pets. He tries to convince the reader that he is truly a good person, by
explaining that he always loved animals: “From my infancy, I was known for the docility and
humanity of my disposition” (Poe 151). Our narrator tries to convince us that alcohol made him
wicked: “Through the instrumentality of the Fiend Intemperence, (I) had experienced a radical
alteration for the worse” (Poe, 152). The man furthers his alcohol use to numb his feelings of
guilt for taking the cat’s eye out and then killing him (although I believe he really hanged his
McGinley !2
wife and is feeling guilt over that.) As the narrator says, “ I again plunge into excess, and soon
drowned in wine all memory of the deed.” (Poe, 153). He uses alcohol to cope, because he
knows that what he did to his cat and wife are grievous deeds. When he is drunk, he isn’t
reminded of what he did.
The story that the narrator of “The Black Cat” tells us is obviously a lie to convince us,
the reader, and ultimately himself, that he is not guilty, and that his actions were out of his
control. Susan Amper in her article, “Untold story : The lying narrator in ‘The Black Cat’”,
states that the story makes sense “ when understood as part fact and part misrepresentation
designed to minimize the narrator’s guilt …” (Amper 476). Amper also claims that there never
was a second cat. Instead, the narrator hanged his wife, and then made up the second cat to
provide a reason for why he still had a cat, after claiming he killed it, to provide justification for
his drinking problem, to provide a plausible scenario for killing his wife in order to avoid
premeditated murder charges, and to protect his pride when his “perfect murder” is discovered.
He tries to convince us, and himself, that it was not his guilt that made him get caught, but
instead the cat revealing his crime. According to Amper, “The narrator is a man at war with
himself,...

Other Essays On Gothic elements and Guilt in "The black cat" and "The Tell Tale Heart" - west valley college english 1b - essay

Edgar Allan Poe's The Black Cat - English - Essay

1364 words - 6 pages Edgar Allen Poe’s “The Black Cat” Edgar Allan Poe’s short story “The Black Cat” emphasizes the story genre of horror and romanticism. This is displayed through most of Poe’s stories including gruesome details, but furthermore he creates a nonchalant mood, which leaves the audience baffled in mind. In his story specifically, the phenomena portrayed is a man with a psychotic personality justifying and defending his irrational and disturbing acts

Edgar Allan Poe's The Black Cat - MassBay Community College - The Black Cat

1568 words - 7 pages Benedict Cezair-Thompson Professor Ohren Freshman English II 05 May 2019 Poe’s Use of Literary Devices in The Black Cat Before we jump into analyzing the textual themes and writing characteristics of The Black Cat which make it the great story it is, we should touch on the main plotlines in the story---so I’ll give a quick recap. At the opening of the story, the reader is addressed by an unnamed narrator, in prison, awaiting his execution the

The tell-tale heart building suspense - Winston park - Assignment

571 words - 3 pages “The Tell-Tale Heart” Building Suspense As you read “The Tell-Tale Heart,” consider the ways in which the author, Edgar Allan Poe, creates suspense. Use this chart to keep track of just how Poe unsettles and unnerves his readers! At each of the stopping points below, record why this passage is suspenseful/identify the technique(s) Poe uses. Then rewrite the passage in a non-suspenseful way. Some techniques authors use to create suspense

The Importance of the Black Lives Matter Movement - Writing 383 for Diablo Valley College - Essay

2005 words - 9 pages mistreatment or the african american daily hassles. They are not qualified to have a strong opinion on the subject if they have not thoroughly experienced the inequality. Similarly, people against the Black Lives Matter movement also believe that these instances do not occur more often that similar situations with other races but rather the racial police brutality cases receive more attention and result in a greater public outcry. They also argue that

popul vuh and old testament flood comparison essay - West Los Angeles college/english 203 - essay

1488 words - 6 pages ancestor who had been murdered after playing a ball game on Earth and annoyed those in the underworld. Xquic was angry and embarrassed and explains to her father but he wants her to be killed for her disobedience. Owls were sent to murder her, but they let her live-in exchange for retrieving aa heart made from a bleeding tree. Xquic was banished from the underworld and forced to live on the Earth. The likeliness of Adam and Eve in Genesis and “A

Tell-Tale Signs of a Specific Criterion - English 102 - Essay

2436 words - 10 pages Tell Tale Heart.” The Complete Tales and Poems of Edgar Allan Poe, Sterling, 2015, pp. 498-501. The Tell-Tale Sign of a Particular Criterion Evaluation Essay Presented to Mr. Genre by Greyson Labasse on March 28, 2018 In fulfillment of requirements for English 102 Section 9

Tell Tale Heart Attorney Letter - Journalism - Assignment

764 words - 4 pages Gonzalez; Jess&Yayi Attorneys at Law 65-21 Main Street Flushing, New York 11367 (305) 340-4200 November 5, 2018 Narrator Murder of Father 885 Seventh Avenue New York, New York 10017 “Tell Tale Heart” : Insanity Plea Narrator mudered his own father due to his eye’s appearance, “ a vulture’s eye.” In this case, my client and I are requesting a insanity plea for this case. Narrator is not responsible for his actions for during the time of the

Character Analysis of the Narrator of a Tell-Tale Heart - ECC Literature - Character Analysis

809 words - 4 pages Luke Hughes ENG 111-06         The narrator in A Tell-Tale Heart by Edgar Allan Poe knows that people thinks he’s crazy. Although this may be true, his craziness isn’t the reason why he kills the old man. He kills him for reasons that agitate the insane part of the narrator’s mind. He obsesses about the old man in a very crazy way. As well as when he defends that he’s not crazy while he is killing the old man. For various reasons is why the

Sobibor, Tells The Story Of A Nazi Officer Gone Mad...Losely Based On Edgar Allen Poe's "Tell-Tale Heart"

1734 words - 7 pages see the boy's body goes limp as the father slowly turns around he reveals the lifeless body of his son in his arms. The first commandment is furious for the father spared his son from a worse fate; shouting erupts from the officer along with some blows to the prisoner. His skull is bashed in and the father is now down on his knees bleeding all over but not dead yet. A pistol is pulled out from the officer's belt and set down right on his heart. He

Adopt, Don't Shop: A Look into Pet Adoption - Golden West College English G110 - Persuasive Essay

1601 words - 7 pages 1 Pham Kristen Pham Professor A. Momeni English G110 30 October 2017 Adopt, Don’t Shop Do you remember running up to pet shop windows when you were little and squealing at the cute puppies walking around in the display cases? I remember and I remember begging my parents to let me take one home. I also very distinctly remember them telling me that we could not because we just did not have the time for a dog. When you are that young, you do not

The signs essay compared to the black cat - the ponds high school and class 10 - essay

1450 words - 6 pages English Essay (the signs and the black cat) Texts which scrutinize aspects of ‘the Unknown’ use a variety of techniques and camera shots to destabilise the audience. The texts ‘Signs’ directed by M. Night Shyamalan and ‘The Black Cat’ written by gothic writer Edgar Allan Poe both fall under the division of science fiction thriller genre which shows the unsettling nature of both texts. The film signs create a sense of suspense and tension by

Similar Papers

Guilt Trip: The Tale Tell Heart Cisco College And 1302 English Element Of A Story

626 words - 3 pages Young 2 Guilt Trip When reading Edgar Allen Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart” our narrator is motived to execute an elderly man with an unusual eye. The old man’s physical disabilities “would fancy him mad” (Poe 37), thus leading our narrator to become a cold-blooded killer. However, it wasn’t the death of the old man that would be our narrators undoing, it was his anxiety and the sound of a subtle heartbeat that would unfold everything. In the story

Three Short Stories Essay: "The Black Cat" And "The Tell Tale Heart" By Edgar Allen Poe And "Call It Madness" By Guy Du Maupassant

3193 words - 13 pages to kill it. In his rage he picks up an axe but his wife stops him. He swings the axe not thinking what he is doing, and embeds the axe into her head, killing her. This is when his insanity reached a maximum. He buried her body in the wall and felt no guilt for what he had done. From being a shy, timid human he became a violent killer.In similarity to "The black cat" "The tell tale heart" also starts off with the man denying he his mad. "But why

The Letter To Jing Mei In "Two Kinds" Mission College English 1 B Essay

855 words - 4 pages between you and your mom is the rising action which leads the story to the climax. I know your heart was broken; hence, you attribute failure to “I’m not a genius!”(Tan 495), but you actually understand that you have not worked hard on piano. Jing-Mei, how to identify a genius? I agree that everyone has a different potential genius; in fact, genius is not obtained overnight. Kobe Bean Bryant, who is widely regarded as one of the greatest basketball

“The Tell Tale Heart” Symbolism Analyze Eng 1102 Essay

859 words - 4 pages Herrera Diaz 1 Lisetty Diaz English 1102 Fiction Essay September 10, 2018 “The Tell-Tale Heart” Symbolism Analyze "The Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allen Poe is a famous American piece of Literature that is world well known. This short story is about a man that eventually becomes out of his right mind while taking care of an old man. The narrator begins to become furious and eventually build a plot to kill the old man in his bedroom. Poe in this