Lenin Was The Critical Factor In The Bolshevik Consolidation Of Power Year 12 Assessment Essay

1404 words - 6 pages

“Lenin was the critical factor in the Bolshevik consolidation of power”
To what extent is this statement an accurate reflection of the Bolshevik consolidation of power 1917 to 1924?
Vladimir Lenin was a highly critical factor within the Bolshevik consolidation of power; therefore, the statement is an accurate reflection of the period 1917-1924. Though many other factors, such as the Leon Trotsky and the weaknesses/unpopularity of the Provisional Government played a significant role within the consolidation, it was Lenin’s strong leadership, ideology and pragmatism during this period that enabled the Bolsheviks to strengthen and maintain control. Lenin’s role within the consolidation is evident through his significant contributions to the October Revolution, his implementation of various socio-political reforms, his signing of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, his actions during the Civil War and War Communism, and his implementation of the New Economic Policy.
The presence of Lenin within the October Revolution was highly critical to the accumulation and consolidation of Bolshevik power. ‘Had Lenin not managed to come to Petrograd…the October Revolution would not have taken place. Lenin was the “engine driver of revolution”, orchestrating (with Trotsky) the Bolshevik takeover and seizure of power from the weaker Provisional Government, leaving himself as head of a new Bolshevik administration. As the October Revolution laid the groundwork for Bolshevik control - marking the inception of the first Russian communist government - it was a highly critical event, elevating Lenin’s role by emphasizing the significance of his ideology (Leninism) and pragmatism, which underpinned all Bolshevik action.
Lenin’s importance within the early periods of consolidation is evident through his key role implementing various social and political reforms. In order to maintain power, Lenin needed to convince Russia that the Bolsheviks were more capable than the Provisional Government, which “had no popular mandate and little popular support.” To do this, Lenin needed to deliver on his promises of “Peace. Bread. Land.” Lenin initiated a series of decrees, partly intended to please the population and slowly introduce them to communist society. These decrees focused on the liberation and elevation of the peasantry, as it was his belief that through the rise of the peasants to that of equal standing with the proletariat, they would develop a new class consciousness and seek to transition to socialism despite only recently achieving capitalism (through Permanent Revolution). These decrees and reforms included the land decree (re-distribution of land to the peasants), workers decrees (8-hour working days and worker-committee-owned factories), educational reforms (including free education), women’s rights, independence of Russian-occupied nationalities (such as the Baltic states), and the Peace Decree, which addressed one of the most imperative of Russia’s problems – It’s unpopular involvement within World War I (WWI). The decree pressured the other governments involved to end the war so that Lenin could deliver his promise of “Peace.” A principal component of this was the signing of the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk.
The Treaty of Brest-Litovsk was highly significant within consolidation as it enabled Russia to focus on internal problems without worrying about the external enemies of WWI, Germany. Though the treaty was highly divisive amongst the Bolsheviks, when Trotsky’s “neither Peace nor War” failed as a German revolution did not occur, Lenin’s way was eventually followed – Accept all the terms of a peace treaty, no matter how harsh, in order to gain time. Lenin argued that any losses to Germany – a nation on the “doorstep ” of socialist revolution – would be temporary. The signing of the Treat of Brest-Litovsk was a critical component of the consolidation as it allowed Russia to focus on internal problems, such as the economic crisis and food shortages (caused by WWI). As it was Lenin who convinced the Bolsheviks of the Treaty’s necessity it is clear that Lenin played a crucial role within it’s signing, and therefore consolidation. However this peace did not last long due to the onset of the Russian Civil War (1917-1922).
Lenin’s role was crucial within the success of the Bolsheviks during the Civil War, a critical aspect of consolidation. After gaining power, the Bolsheviks faced massive resistance in the form of the White Army; a diverse group (including Tsarists, Mensheviks, Social Revolutionaries and 255,503 foreign troops) formed through mutual opposition of the Bolsheviks due to resentment of Bolshevik policy limiting their power, for example the closing down of the Constituent Assembly in the case of the Social Revolutionaries, after they had won the election 370-175. Though the role of Trotsky was more critical during this time, as his leadership and ruthlessness as Commissar-of-War (a position awarded to him by Lenin) inevitably led to Bolshevik victory, Lenin was still crucial as many organizational responsibilities (such as overseeing the “Red Terror”, whereby Bolshevik opposition and “kulaks” were massacred) fell to him as party leader. One solution implemented by Lenin was War Communism.
Lenin’s War Communism (1918-1921) was highly critical to the consolidation as it enabled the Bolshevik’s to win the Civil War. War Communism refers to the socio-economic policies implemented by Lenin at the time, their aim being to maintain supplies for the Red Army, at the expense of ordinary citizens. During War Communism, every aspect of working life was controlled. Businesses and factories were nationalized, strikes were forbidden, food was rationed (approximately 1/10th of British war rations) and peasants were forced to give their surplus produce to the government, as, according to Lenin; they were “saddled by the imperative conditions of war-time .” Lenin was critical to consolidation as his War Communism succeeded in meeting the immediate needs of the Bolsheviks during the Civil War, leading to victory. However, the effects of War Communism were severe.
War Communism left the economy devastated, with many disenfranchised from the Bolsheviks. War Communism “undermined the loyalty of the villages, the towns and finally sections of the army .” This damaged relationship led to many uprisings between 1920-1921 (Krondstadt Rebellion 1921) with a reported 118 separate uprisings during February 1921 alone. These uprising were critical as they enabled Lenin to understand that in order to consolidate power they would have to change the socio-political and economic structure of Russia. To achieve this, at the Tenth Congress of the Communist Party (1921), Lenin proposed his New Economic Policy (NEP).
The NEP was crucial to the consolidation as it showed the flexibility of Lenin in terms of ideology. After the Civil War, Lenin’s top priority was to stabilise the country. “We had to show the peasants that we could and would quickly change our policy to alleviate their want ” Through the NEP, Lenin targeted the grievances of Russia by stopping grain requisitioning, shortening the working hours, giving trade unions (limited) freedom to operate, and letting peasants and small businesses trade freely to make a profit, therefore stimulating the economy (however the “commanding heights of the economy ” were still state controlled). This, however, came at the expense of many key Bolshevik beliefs.
Though Lenin saw the NEP as a necessary stage to amalgamate Bolshevik power and introduce socialism, many Bolshevik members saw the concessions to capitalism as a betrayal. Lenin’s authority and determination during this time is what convinced the Bolshevik party to introduce the policy, as Lenin argued that these reforms were vital in order to avoid famine and further instability, along with being a step towards socialism. The reality was that it would be impossible to introduce socialism to a post-civil-war Russia as the socio-economic and political grievances of the time were too great. The NEP was a practical “retreat” from socialism, which relaxed the tensions of Russia and led to an improved economy, leading to an increase in Bolshevik support, and therefore power. As it was Lenin who implemented the NEP it is clear that his role within the consolidation was highly critical.
Through his influence over October Revolution, his implementation of various social and political reforms, The Civil War and War Communism, and the NEP, it is clear that Lenin’s role within the Bolshevik consolidation of power was highly significant. Though other factors contributed to the consolidation, Lenin invariably either contributed to their success as a factor through collaboration (in terms of Trotsky) or by capitalizing on them to his own advantage (in terms of the Provisional Governments weaknesses). In this way it is evident that Lenin was the critical factor as his leadership and ideology underpinned all Bolshevik action, to the extent that without Lenin, the actual accumulation of power would have never occurred.


Evaluate the view that the Nazi consolidation of power was a legal process - Modern history yr 11 KCAHS - Essay

1010 words - 5 pages Free Evaluate the view that the Nazi consolidation of power between January 1933 and August 1934 was a ‘legal process’. (10 Marks) The period between January 1933 and August 1943 was a key period for Hitler and the Nazi party to consolidate power in the form of a dictatorship. Hitler’s change of strategy to gain power legally was an effective process as he created a legal image in the eyes of the public. For example the appearance of legality was

Was Disease a Key Factor in the Depopulation of Native Americans in the Americas? - HIST 170 - Essay

1069 words - 5 pages It continues to be an ongoing mystery on whether or not Europeans purposely used disease to wipe out the Native American population. The truth may never be clear as to the intent of the Europeans but what is clear, is the fact that new diseases was brought over to the Native Americans. But the issue at hand is if disease was a key factor in the depopulation of Native Americans in the Americas. The debate between Colin Calloway and David S

how important was ideology to the development of the bolshevik state between 1917 and 1924 - morpeth - essay

671 words - 3 pages world of work. I was also introduced to the amount of group work that is essential in order to solve a particular problem as well as making certain decisions about a theory. In “Organic Chemistry: A Very Short Introduction” by Graham Patrick, I learnt about the typical approach to the development of a drug which involves multiple complicated steps including legal processes of patenting and because it is done so early on in the drug development

A day in the life of 12 year old me - CSN English 100 - Essay

664 words - 3 pages Free Sylvia Mejia English 100 My Life at 12 “BZZZZ!” “BZZZZ!” “BZZZZ!” goes my alarm at 5:30 in the morning. “It’s Monday again. Great.” I think to myself, already annoyed at the fact that I must go school because it didn’t burn down over the weekend, as I hoped it would. I reach over the side of my bed, turn off my alarm, my day has officially begun. I laid in bed a couple more minutes before I heard my mom walk through the question, per her usual

The Merchant of Venice Essay - Year 12 HSC - Essay

941 words - 4 pages relationship over Jessica however the interpositing of O my ducats between the repetition of O my Daughter questions whether he valued his daughter or wealth more. This patriarchal objectification of women is seen when Bassanio says In Belmont is a lady richly left, where he identifies Portia by her wealth. Similarly, the Moroccan prince also metaphorically monetarily objectifies Portia,Never so rich a gem was set in worse than gold. Shakespeare

“The experience of slaves who worked in the fields was typical of all slaves' - Pultney Grammar School Year 9 - Essay

2124 words - 9 pages “The experience of slaves who worked in the fields was typical of all slaves.” How accurate is this statement? Refer to a range of slave groups in your response. There were numerous experiences that all slaves had regardless of their situation. Slavery existed in the Americas from the sixteenth to the nineteenth century. Slaves were utilised for the most part to make or harvest materials, like sugar and cotton to export to European countries

Trotsky And The Bolshevik Revolution

1791 words - 8 pages Petrograd on 25 October 1917. The Bolsheviks, operating through th'e Military Revolutionary Committee of the City Soviet, seized power in a series of decisive actions. The post and telegraph offices and the railway stations were taken and the army garrisons put under rebel control. By the end of the day the Winter Palace had fallen to the insurgents" (Service 62). According to Pipes it was not quite so simple. Lenin sent anxious messages because

How is Fate and Chance presented in Thomas Hardy’s the Mayor of Casterbridge? - St.Albans year 12 - Essay

1968 words - 8 pages How is Fate and Chance presented in Thomas Hardy’s the Mayor of Casterbridge? The people of the 1800s believed in many superstitions however, the 19th Century is generally remembered as a time of science and technology, when the ideas of Charles Darwin and Samuel Morse changed the world forever. Perhaps the otherworldly was a way to hold on to a superstitious past. According to Thomas Hardy “an evil power rules the human’s destinies which thwart

Investigating a factor that affects the volume of H2 at the cathode in an electrolysis reaction

630 words - 3 pages IntroductionAn electrolysis cell uses an external source of voltage to bring about a non-spontaneous redox reaction. In an electrolytic cell electricity is passed through an electrolyte and electrical energy is converted into chemical energy. Electrolysis enables neutral elements to be released from ionic compounds by discharging the ions through oxidation and reduction reactions. The power source pushes electrons towards the negative electrode

Nazi consolidation of power between January 1933 and August 1933 - Modern History - Response Essay

985 words - 4 pages Evaluate the view that the Nazi consolidation of power between January 1933 and August 1934 was a 'legal process.' January 1933 and August 1943 were critical for Hitler and the Nazi party to consolidate power as a dictatorship. Hitler's change of strategy to gain control legally was an effective process as he created a legal image in the eyes of the public. For example, the appearance of legality was shown in his success in the public

how successful was the league of nations in the 1920s - year 10 - assignment

980 words - 4 pages Free France weren’t prepared for another war, if America was part of the League, oral condemnation would’ve been enough to stop countries like Poland as they would feel threatened by America’s power. This was a failure as The League didn’t take any further action as they are required to do so, therefore Poland didn’t feel threatened enough to stop, resulting in a war. Another example of this would be when an Italian General, Tellini, was murdered

What does Lenin mean when he says the state is an instrument of class rule - Newcastle, Politics - Essay

544 words - 3 pages What does Lenin mean when he says the state is an instrument of class rule. Unlike Bernstein who believes that the capitalist state will adapt and change, to protect the interests of the working class. Lenin disagrees with his suggestion that it would in theory be possible for the state to put measures in place for this to happen through socialist democratic reform. He thinks that it is the state itself which perpetuates the oppression of the

How does Orwell present the power of manipulation through Squealer? - Year 10 - Essay

756 words - 4 pages George Orwell’s 1946 novel Animal Farm uses the animals of Manor Farm as a metaphor for Stalinism to establish the corruption and dangers of a Communist leadership. In keeping with this theme, the novel uses many examples of propaganda–often used by totalitarian leaders–to illustrate that people can be easily influenced by faulty ideas if they are presented in an appealing manner. Animal Farm proves that true power may not come with the dictator

Assessing the reasons why Henry VII was able to reduce the power of the Nobility - Dhahran School / Grade 11 - Essay

1066 words - 5 pages fact that the marriage itself took place is testimony to the success of Henry’s foreign policy in this period, as it was only by increasing his power, status and wealth that Ferdinand was willing to permit him to marry his daughter. After his successes in achieving his foreign policy aims up to 1501, the success of Henry declined significantly after this point. Henry was forced to fundamentally re assess his aims following the death of Arthur in

The Tsar and the First World War - Year 12 - Essay

1195 words - 5 pages . According to Ben Walsh in Modern World History, by 1917 there was deep discontent in the army and that many soldiers were supporters of the revolutionary Bolshevik Party, so it makes sense that on the 12th of March, when the Tsar ordered the army to crush the revolt by force, they refused and marched to the Duma demanding a government takeover. The economic situation, spread of Marxism amongst soldiers, the mess of the Russian front line all