Liberal Humanism Vs Critical Theory College Essay

506 words - 3 pages

Liberal humanism vs critical theory.
There are many ways why people study literature, one being that it emancipates us from the notions and habits of our every day life but instead, gives us something fixed and enduring. It was also believed that literature was studied to spread middle class values all around the world.
There are two tracks of literary theory, one being created by I.A Richards in which he discussed ‘practical criticism’ or close reading as we know it. This theory insists that the best way to study literature was to study the text itself, disregarding anything outside of the text, including the author, historical context or any reviews of critics of the text. In summary, this meant the text should be an isolated subject. The second track of literary theory looks at the text as a key to understanding questions and ideas beyond the text. Rather then centring on the text alone, it looks at the ‘big picture’ questions.
Current liberal humanism ideas come from both tracks, we begin the understand how the ‘words on the page’ are the foundation for any critical analysis. Both ‘tracks’ shared certain fundamentalist ideas called the tenets of liberal humanism. The tenets are as follows; Good literature is timeless, texts contain meaning within itself, texts should be studied in isolation, texts hold universal truths, in texts, form and content are fused together, literary works speaks truth about the human condition.
Although in the 1960’s, liberal humanism started to lose its credibility. Literary critics responded to the social and political questions arising about society, race, gender and sexuality by asking weather these ‘timeless universal truths’ were really timeless or universal. They asked is shake spear really universal or did he write as a white male in the 16th century, can everyone relate to his work?
Many writers in the 20th century questioned the tenets of liberal humanism. This included Marxist and psychoanalytic theorists who payed attention to how society, class and sexuality function in producing literature as well as authors and readers who challenged liberal humanism constantly. These critical theories throw all of the liberal humanism assumptions up in the air. The first critical theory is the idea that things we have thought as a constant, including our own identity are not stable or fixed but rather are fluid. Theorists also discuss objectivity, the idea that everyone someone thinks or does is in some degree the product of one’s past experiences, their beliefs and ideologies. Critical theorists agree that language is the most important factor in shaping all of our ideas about life, literature and the world. But rather then language reflecting the ‘real world’ language actually constructs our perspective of reality. Another theory is because all truth is relative, all supposedly ‘essential’ constants are fluid and language determines reality.
These critical theories conclude that there is no such thing as definite meaning, there is only ambiguity and multiple meanings in literary texts and because of the idea of ‘relativism’ there is no such thing as a ‘total’ theory.


A Satisfying Criticism of "The Scarlet Letter" - Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts, 2018 - Essay

2360 words - 10 pages provide a certain insight that a single critical vantage point might ignore. Romero is supposed to have used four perspectives—a feminist approach, a gender approach, a psychoanalytic approach, and a new historicist approach. Romero has several different points in her essay that come to a less than clear conclusion. She argued in her essay that Hawthorne was distinctly sexist: “Hawthorne imagined that the women writers of his day lacked the capacity

"Charity" versus "Self Reliance:" Winthrop and Emerson - Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts, 2018 - Essay

1618 words - 7 pages safe and definite ascent to Heaven. On the other end of the spectrum, Emerson’s “Self-Reliance” preaches exactly what the name of the essay implies: importance in independence and caring about oneself as a means to understanding that confidence breeds novelty. Emerson has a bit of an aversion to conforming, which basically directly disagrees with Winthrop’s attitude of a group of people functioning as a body. “…but the great man is he who in the

Singer vs. Frankfurt: How to Live - UF Theory of Happiness and Well-Being - Essay

1515 words - 7 pages Free important to us. For Frankfort, taking care of things that are important to us is a necessary condition of living well, and again, things are important to us because we care about it, and for no other reasons. There may be reasons that we care about it, for instance in the case of a college roommate, one will spend a large portion of his time with his roommate, and after going through a year of school and parties, one will start to care about his or her

An Eco-critical Reading of Philip Larkin - Beauchamp College - Essay

2057 words - 9 pages , Andrew, Larkin: A Writer's Life and Philip Larkin's Collected Poems (United Kingdom: Faber&Faber, 1993) Secondary Sources · Coupe. L, ‘The Green Studies Reader: From Romanticism to Ecocriticism’ in AQA Critical Anthology (Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2015) · Glotfelty, C, ‘What is Ecocriticism?’ in AQA Critical Anthology (Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2015)

moral ethics : kant vs korsgard - ualbany/college - essay

1692 words - 7 pages David Paper on Kant and Korsgaard Immnauel Kant was among one of the greatest philosophers of our time; during his relatively short lifespan he had managed to develop various theories and philosophies about many topics ranging from political philosophical theories to what we are going to cover in this paper; morality. Kant’s moral philosophy revolved around two main theories or supreme principles; the universal law formula and the formula

Critical Essay on Heart of Darkness - Patrician Brothers College Fairfield - Essay

1955 words - 8 pages , which is at worst symbolised through Kurtz, a highly acclaimed commander of Ivory trade in Africa, and a demigod among native Africans who Marlow seeks to return to the coast. Conrad writes in a way that seemingly makes Marlow the reader's guide into the conception of the false image that the ‘European self’ puts forth vs. the true agenda and malevolent desires of that same ‘European self.’ This image of the worst aspects of humanity may very

University vs. Two year college - Southern University A&M College - Essay

1407 words - 6 pages Morgan Weaver ENGL 111:01 02 December 2017 Research Essay High School Study Abroad Programs It is typically a big deal when deciding what one wants to do with their life after high school. There are many different routes for people to chose from. Some decide to attend a four year college, two year college, trade school, military, and some rely on talent. However, not all students are as fortunate as others to have long term goals or parents to

The ones who walk away from the Omelas - College of Charleston - critical essay

867 words - 4 pages Darien The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas: Critical Analysis The author begins this short story vividly comparing the city and citizens of Omelas to a “city in a fairytale”. He scripts a city full of “sunshine flickers”, “children playing”, and “citizens smiling” to emphasize the positivity and perfection of this Omelas society. In almost every fairytale there is a villian set in place for the meer purpose of allowing the citizens to understand

the differences and similarities of Burglary vs robbery - college of southern nevada criminal justice - essay

751 words - 4 pages Running head: BURGLARY VERSUS ROBBERY 1 Burglary versus Robbery Samer Ghafarji College of Southern Nevada BURGLARY VERSUS ROBBERY 2 Burglary Versus Robbery Most people may not know the difference between the terms burglary and robbery unless you were living in the world of criminal justice. Burglary and robbery are two separate crimes that have similarities but they are completely different crimes. Robbery is a serious crime which is the action

Nature vs Nurture in We Need to Talk About Kevin - Spokane Community College English 102 - Essay

1097 words - 5 pages Free Alexis Binder  Sharon Miller   English 101   2/26/2019  Nature trumps Nurture   Nature verses Nurture has always been a huge topic among phycology and sociology for at least the last 20 years. Lionel Shiver’s novel We Need to Talk About Kevin is a perfect example of how nature verse nurture can play into the psychological development as we age. “A person with a psychopathic personality, which manifests as amoral and antisocial behavior, lack of

Robert Downey Jr vs Benedict Cumberbatch - Spring Hill College English Lit - Essay

1518 words - 7 pages Nikki Carpenter 10/19/18 English Lit .02 Sherlock Holmes vs Sherlock Sherlock Holmes is one of my favorite characters in fiction novels, movies, and shows. He uses his crazy personality in solving crimes, and the interesting and intellectual way of testing his hypothesis. There are two actors who that play Sherlock Holmes very well, Robert Downey Jr. and Benedict Cumberbatch. Robert Downey Jr. is an amazing Sherlock Holmes compared to Benedict

Nature vs Nurture assignments that explains the nature vs nurture debate in a scientific way - union county college/ General Psychology - Essay

834 words - 4 pages Nature vs Nurture What makes us operate in life the way we do? Are we genetically predisposed to have certain behavioral traits — or are we a product of the various experiences we have throughout life. The nature versus nurture debate is one of the oldest and most controversial debates in psychology. It’s popularity and relevance comes from our innate desire to become better as a society, through having a deeper understanding of what makes us

Nature vs Nurture: The Dichotomy of Gender Roles - Inver Hills Community College: Intro to Academic Writing - Essay

866 words - 4 pages Nature vs Nurture: The Dichotomy of Gender Roles The belief that gender roles are inherently biological is a cultural fallacy, which can lead to an inability to effectively communicate when we do not assess each individual’s personality. Research of this topic is necessary in order to learn how to completely understand how to communicate. When trying to communicate with an individual there are more variables than simply gender that need to be

Rough Draft Of Theory I Think

829 words - 4 pages Idealism through to contemporary neo-liberal theories and the democratic peace thesis.States are but one actor in world politics, and even states can cooperate through institutional mechanisms and bargaining that undermine the propensity to define survival interests simply in military terms.2. Traditionalist vs behavioristTaking place in the 1960's, this was essentially a methodological debate revolving around the belief of Behaviouralists that IR

Shakespear's exploration of action and inaction in Hamlet - High School - Essay

1249 words - 5 pages realisation that the only way to restore Denmark is to cleanse it of all evil, including himself, transcending the turmoil of the Claudian Court. George Knight’s critical essay aligns with the view of Hamlet’s ironic death as the means by which disturbance is transcended, as he says, ‘Hamlet is the ambassador of death walking amidst life’. Thus, Shakespeare explores the protagonist’s and society’s existential dread as means of disturbance; however, he