Should College Athletes Be Paid? English Persuasive

1461 words - 6 pages

Oscar Pavelich
Ms. Pritzel
English III
17 January 2018
Should College Athletes Be Paid?
Many people will tell you that the opportunity to go to college is enough for student-athletes, but it is time to start offering more than that and paying the athletes that take their talents to the collegiate level. These athletes bring in large amounts of money for their school and the NCAA and are not being fairly compensated for it. There are many different commodities and experiences that are given up to pursue college sports and the people that choose to do so should at least see some of the benefits of making that choice. The time has come for the traditional rules of amateur athletes not being paid to play to change. There are many good ideas that are going around about how to pay the athletes and they include using a free market technique or paying based on production. Some people believe that college athletes receive many luxuries, examples of the luxuries these athletes are known to have include full ride scholarships and a shot at the pros. The same people that argue these points will say that paying colleges athletes would be unfair to smaller schools, but if the rule change is approached correctly, it would allow for a fair and equal opportunity for all players and schools.
College athletes are defined by the NCAA as amateurs and their bylaws state "A student who engages in athletic contests for educational purposes, personal pleasure, satisfaction, and for the love of the sport, not for monetary or material gain" (NCAA). This means that while an athlete is participating in college level sports they can receive no payment, whether it’s in the form of cash or other goods. There have been instances in the past where athletes have received benefits for playing and the NCAA is anything but lenient with their punishments. The NCAA will strip the athlete of his/her eligibility and amateur status so they can no longer participate in intercollegiate activities in a particular sport. The rule has been speculated on by sportscasters and news people, but the NCAA has stated that this rule will not change. "College football and basketball are multi-billion-dollar businesses. Some schools have billion-dollar TV deals and team sponsors. The coaches for these teams make millions. Some schools have money for fancy training facilities, charter jets to away games, and state-of-the-art arenas. Yet, the labor force-the players- receive nothing. Name another industry where the labor force receives nothing. You can't" (Nocera). The University of Alabama spent $36,918,963 and received $81,993,762 from football alone! That’s not including any other revenue all of the other sports are bringing in. The average salary of a D1 has gone up over 70% form 2006-2012, the average salary of a D1 coach was $1.64 million! With the theory of linear progression that salary would now be over 140% from 2006, which is $2.13 million/year. In 2016 alone Nick Saben, The University of Alabama's coach, made $6.9 million and in 2017 his salary increased by 62%. In 2017 he made an astounding $11.125 million! The schools could cut his salary by $10 million and use it for anything else and he'd still be making a very large sum of money.
College athletes sacrifice more than you’d expect to play their sport although people will say that the college is paying them by giving them scholarships but most athletes are poor and struggling and the NCAA has strict guidelines on players making money. "Those who feel that college athletes should be compensated for their performances argue the issue as a matter of fairness given how profitable college sports are in American society. Advocates for paying student-athletes paint our that compensation would make daily life more financially secure for student-athletes, especially because colleges and universities often have strict policies prohibiting student-athletes from holding part-time jobs out of concern that working would detract athletes from their athletic and academic responsibilities and possibly lead to injuries that could disrupt their participation in sports. Furthermore, neither colleges and universities nor the NCAA corporate office are required to provide accident insurance for athletes for injuries that total less than $90,000 in medical fees; the NCAA requires athletes to have accident insurance before they can participate in school athletic programs" (Garcia). If college athletes aren't allowed to work so they can make money, how are they expected to be able to buy the necessities for living? They're not, colleges expect student-athletes to live just like every other student when in reality, student-athletes are living a very different life and a far more difficult life. "Last year, the National College Players Association released a report called 'The Price of Poverty in Big Time College Sports' that concluded 86% of college athletes live below the poverty line" (The Washington Times). What this statistic means is that will over 3 quarters of the collegiate athlete world are broke and have basically no money to help them pay for food, clothes, and just all around basic need to live after they make it to the 'next level'. Nobody says that these student-athletes are supossed to live a luxurious life, but how is anyone supposed to survive when they're expected to spend upwards of 50 hours/week in the Pac-12 practicing, get enough sleep to be able to function properly, and do all of their academic responsibilities and do them all the right way? There's 168 hours/week. Students spend about 3-5 hours/day on academics, whether that in class or labs, The National Sleep Foundation recommends adults get 7-9 hours/day of sleep to function, and spend 50+ hours/week on their respective sports. That only leaves 20 hours/week for everything else that college students do. Now these statistics are taken without factoring in the exhaustion that these athletes feel after practice. Also, if at any point in time an athlete falls under a 2.5 GPA the college or university the athlete is attending can strip their eligibility which means they can no longer play and they lose their scholarship. As you can see, this is a very stressful lifestyle.
People will say that the college these students attend are paying them by giving them a scholarship, but most athletes are poor and struggling and the NCAA has strict guidelines on anything/everything outside of their sports. "Paying athletes anything beyond a scholarship would cause problems, particularly from a gender equity standpoint. What they seem to be referring to when he says 'gender equity' is Title IX federal regulations, which cut off funding of colleges if those colleges discriminate on the basis of sex. Paying male athletes more than female athletes could possibly be constructed as discrimination" (Meshefejian). Female student-athletes bring in far less money than male student-athletes so the schools would have to pay the male athletes more. "However, others argue that these athletes are producing revenues not only for the schools, which gives them the scholarships, but also for shoe companies, television networks, and the conference in which these schools belong to. Moreover, the equity problem could obviously be solved if all athletes playing for the schools receive the same base salary for their participation" (Meshefejian). I have come up with a way I feel these student athletes should be paid. My ideas are as follows:
D1 Schools: D2 Schools: D3 Schools:
Freshman- 1,000/month Freshman- $500/month Freshman- $250/month
Sophomore- $1,500/month Sophomore- $1,000/month Sophomore- $750/month
Junior- $2,000/month Junior- $1,500/month Junior- $1,250/month
Senior- $2,500 Senior- $2,000/month Senior- $1,750/month
The way that I'd set this payment system up is, the schools a student is attending would put money away in a savings account that the said student would not be able to access until they graduate. I feel that this system would increase the graduation rates significantly because knowing that if you graduate you'll have some money for you when you graduate that you can use to start your life just in case you happen not to make the pros. Only about 3% of all student athletes make it to the pros in all of college sports, which is not a very big number at all. These payments would only take place while the student is in school as well.
In conclusion, college athletes should be paid because collegiate student-athletes bring in a large sum of money for their school and college athletes sacrifice more than you'd expect to play the sport they love. After being given all of these facts such as: the amount of money colleges actually make, the time these athletes put in to entertain all of us around the world, and the strict rules and regulations the NCAA has on the athletes that play to make their pockets deeper, it's obvious that college athletes should be paid for playing college sports.


Should College athletes be paid - english 101 first paper - REsearcb

2756 words - 12 pages Kleam Logan Kleam Comment by Michelle Krueger: There should be a header in the top right corner with your last name and page number. Michelle Krueger ENG 201 March 7, 2018 Should Student Athletes be Paid? College athletes are indisputably some of the hardest working people out there. Student-athletes not only live the livelife of an average student but they also have a tough schedule with their sport. The biggest debate in college athletics is

why college athletes should be paid - FCC/english assignment - research paper

2285 words - 10 pages Morrison 9 Payton Morrison Professor Contreras English 3 7 December 2017 Why NCAA D1 Players Should Be Paid To Play? The question that was brought this writer was if they think D1 collegiate athletes should be paid to play their sport? In their opinion there could be pros and cons to both sides. It is very difficult for college students to maintain a full time job yet alone along with a sport. College athletes should get paid for putting

Should college athletes be paid? - Interboro High School - Argumentative

936 words - 4 pages Sean Myers Mrs. Salerno Period ⅚ College Athletes Essay The argument made by Ann Kaufmann in ​College Athletes Should Be Paid​ is that college athletes, specifically football and basketball players, should be compensated for their play. More specifically, Kaufmann argues that since basketball and football bring in the most money by a very noticeable margin, the athlete's for these sports are the only collegiate athletes that should be paid

Student Athletes should be paid - Illinois State University com 110 - Essay

2295 words - 10 pages Mitchell, Horace, and Marc Edelman. "Should College Student-Athletes Be Paid?” Over 86% of the student athletes in the NCAA such as Napier live in poverty. Coaches are getting paid seven figure contracts and the NCAA College sports industry generates $11 billion in annual revenues which are steadily increasing, yet they continue to say that they can’t pay student athletes. Credibility: As an ex-student athlete here, I have always taken an

Should the Electoral College be Abolished? - english 10 - Research Paper

1325 words - 6 pages Kankel Reid Kankel Ms. Marquez English 10 1 Mar 2017 Should the Electoral College be Abolished? In the past sixteen years politics have become the increasingly important in the United States, and as a result, more and more citizens have gotten involved and have started to care passionately about becoming involved and vocal. In addition to more Americans getting involved in the past decade and a half, two presidential elections ended with the

Why Elderly drivers should be restricted - Public Speaking - Persuasive Speech

1042 words - 5 pages Free PERSUASIVE SPEECH OUTLINE Name: Jackie Salami Topic: The Elderly Driving Title: Old people should not be allowed to drive. Introduction: I. Imagine this, you're driving. That white Prius starts braking for no reason. You're already stressed because you're late. You speed up to cut off the driver and who do you see driving? THAT one grandma. II. You don't really notice how dangerous old drivers are until you're tailgating one. III. Even though

college tution, in this essay i argue why college tution should be free - English I/ Northampton community college - Essay

1429 words - 6 pages Free Dean-Tuggle1 Maiya Dean-Tuggle Professor. Supinski English I April, 2018 Why students should get Free College Tuition In today’s society secondary education could mean the difference between poverty and living comfortably. There is such a large number of people who don’t go to college to get the extra education because they don’t have the money to pay for it. A large amount of people in the U.S skip going to college and getting a degree because

Should alcohol be sold passes 11 - miles college - research paper

511 words - 3 pages Free Talton Talton Jeniah Talton Ms.Gumbs English 102 10 July 2019 Should Alcohol be sold after 11? There are many people who consume alcohol on a sociable basis. However, there are also people that are underage to be drinking alcohol as well. Drinking a substantial amount of alcohol on a daily basis can cause harm to the human body. It also can affect a person’s judgement and sense of reasoning. Of course no one should get intoxicated, but when a

Why Marijuana should be legalized - Amarillo College - Research Paper

913 words - 4 pages The Blunt Truth Isaac D’Agostino Amarillo College The Blunt Truth THE BLUNT TRUTH Marijuana is the name given to the dried buds and leaves of varieties of the Cannabis sativa plant. It goes by names including pot, grass, cannabis, weed, hemp, hash, ganja and many others. Marijuana, since its discovery, has been used as a recreational drug by many individuals and has always been seen as a “safe” drug. Unfortunately, it is still illegal

How mouthguards should be mandatory in field hockey - english - essay

797 words - 4 pages Free plastic, and the stick made of carbon, fiberglass and Kevlar. This should not be a debate on whether the athlete chooses to wear one or not. Even with rules in place to protect the athlete accidents happen and that's why we have equipment to ensure an athletes safety in places that need it most. Field hockey is more dangerous than most other sports like soccer or basketball. With a hard stick and ball the injuries are inevitable. A way to reduce

High School Students Should Be Drug Tested - English 1510 - Argument

1542 words - 7 pages Tackett 1 Tackett 4 Olivia Tackett Professor Jeffrey Hensley English 1510 4 March 2019 High School Students Should Be Drug Tested Drug abuse: a worldwide epidemic that has spread to our youth. The younger generation determines the future of our society. Can we really rely on the youth to better our world if they’re already starting to abuse drugs at such an early age? Schools try to manage their students’ use of drugs by setting anti-drug

Should animals be kept in zoos? - English - Essay

1077 words - 5 pages Aroosha Irfan 4/10/17 Block 3 Argumentative Essay Animals in the Zoo Did you know that zoos help to create connections between people and animals? A majority of people​ ​enjoy going to the zoo, but certain groups of people believe that zoos must be totally eradicated in next two decades. However, I am completely against this idea. Animals should be kept at the zoo for educational purposes, to help fight wildlife extinction, and although many

Should Teens be tried as adults? - English 1302 - Essay

1355 words - 6 pages Free Granger 2 Brianna Granger Professor Brannon English 1302 13 April 2018 Why teens should be tried as adults Today, the crime rates are higher than ever, and adults are not the only ones committing these crimes. One issue today is that juvenile offenses and whether the juvenile offenders should be tried as adults in criminal court. No matter how old you are, I feel that the punishment should fit the crime no matter the age. There are times when

Why Jamaica is the perfect place to be on vacation. - English - Persuasive Essay

895 words - 4 pages Jamaica is a island located in the heart of the Caribbean Sea. Its full with culture every corner you turn. This magical island is full with love and excitement in ever smile. From the clear water beaches visited by thousands of tourist each month, to the hot steaming food made by the best cooks in the world. Jamaica is the perfect place to be on your next time off. A trip here is a cultural experience that reflects the islands many cultural

Capital Punishment should be used for serious offences - Mercer community college and Government - essay

1611 words - 7 pages Free Capital Punishment Should Not Be Suspended Capital punishment also known as death penalty is a form of punishment in which a person who has been convicted of a serious crime is executed under the precept of the criminal justice system.The death penalty has been in existence for thousands of years and has gained wide acceptance in the United States since early colonial times. Despite the growing acceptance of the death penalty as an appropriate