Abortion Argument Should We Ban Abortion In The United States English Essay

1939 words - 8 pages

Rethinking Abortion Advocacy
written by Coleman Hugh
Last Tuesday, the Governor of Alabama signed the most restrictive anti-abortion bill in America
into law. The new law bans abortions even in the case of rape and makes performing an abortion
a Class A felony, punishable by up to 99 years in prison. Despite the low probability of this law
going into effect, it has provoked a slew of commentary from both sides of the aisle. To call it
“commentary,” however, suggests that people are engaging in thoughtful attempts to persuade
one another. In reality, the abortion debate has had all the intellectual rigor and emotional
maturity of a pissing contest.
In an effort to be part of the solution, I’d like to explain why I’m pro-choice. Without doubt, my
position will put me at odds with pro-lifers. But it will also put me at odds with many
pro-choicers. Indeed, part of the reason I feel motivated to defend my position is because of how unpersuasive I find the central argument of the pro-choice movement. It’s painful to watch a
movement use bad reasons to defend a position when good ones are available.
The bad argument I’m referring to—often sloganized as “my body, my choice,” or its corollary,
“they want to control women’s bodies”—can be summarized as follows:
1. It’s a woman’s right to choose what to do with her body.
2. A fetus is part of a woman’s body.
3. Therefore, it’s a woman’s right to choose what to do with her fetus.
The first premise makes sense. A person should be free to do as they wish with their own body. If
someone wants to pierce their ears or donate a kidney, it’s their right to do so, because those are
their body parts. No one else’s moral concerns need to be traded off against theirs. The second
premise, however, is false because a fetus is not merely a body part. Given enough time, a fetus
will become something with distinct moral worth: a baby. The same cannot be said about a
kidney.
When someone gets an ear pierced, they don’t stop to consider the event from their ear’s
perspective. After all, their ear is a part of them —which is to say its ethical concerns align with
its owner’s by definition. If a fetus were really akin to a body part, there would be no reason not
to abort it the moment before delivery, on a whim—like an impulsive ear piercing. Given the
widespread repugnance of that conclusion, and given that there are far better pro-choice
arguments available, the “my body, my choice” argument should be retired permanently.
On the other side of the debate lies an equally bad argument, namely that life or personhood
begins at conception because science says so. To the contrary, there exists no consensus among
biologists about what, specifically, divides life from non-life. Moreover, science doesn’t even try
to tell us when personhood begins because none of the ethically important dimensions of being a
person—for example, conscious experience, the ability to feel pain, the capacity for
self-sustaining growth, and so on—flips on...

Other Essays On abortion argument should we ban abortion in the united states - english - essay

We the people of the United States of America - CMIT - essay

527 words - 3 pages “We the People, Greater than Fear” In the artwork we the people, are greater than fear, Shepard Fairey builds the argument that the people are greater and powerful than fear itself, while being united. He uses textual evidence, reasoning/facts, and emotion to strengthen and have a good persuasiveness for his argument. He did a good job with explaining his point across and towards his audience at the time. To support his argument, and understand

Should Schools Offer Sign Language in Addition to Foreign Language? - English 101 - argument essay

1484 words - 6 pages Richmond,1 Haisley Richmond Professor Miller English 101 October 15, 2018 Should Schools Offer Sign Language in Addition to Foreign Language? “One in eight people in the United States aged 12 years or older has hearing loss in both ears, based on standard hearing examinations.”(Lin, FR). Sign language has been proven to benefit not only the deaf community but also hearing people. By offering sign language hearing, people can strengthen their

preventing obesity in children in the united states of America - english 101 - research paper

1198 words - 5 pages Justin Pepponi Billy Clem English 101.001 1 April 2018 Prevention of Childhood Obesity Childhood obesity is not only an issue in the United States, it is an outbreak. The number of overweight and obese children in America has increased wat too much over the past years, and if there is no action taken it will just keep going downhill. A trend of fast food has flooded every state in the country, leaving every state in a poor nutrition state. Fast

abortion pro and cons and why people should get one - cross - essay

751 words - 4 pages Jorleny Torres English 200 Prof. Virginia Woolums February 20,2018 Abortion Introduction: A. Should Abortion be legal? Abortion is a controversial issue that many people have nowadays. Abortion is a process where the mother kills the fetus. B. The main reasons for an abortion are rape, teenage pregnancy, prostitution and disability diagnosis.  C. Abortion should be made legal because abortion is a women's right to make decisions about her own

What Is Abortion, And Should Is It Moral?

1702 words - 7 pages pregnancy with drugs, and surgical abortion empties the uterus with instruments. Aside from the two afore mentioned types of abortions, there are basically two other choices, carry the baby to term and raise it, or carry the baby to term and put it up for adoption. Therapeutic abortion in the first twelve weeks of pregnancy (first trimester) has no restrictions in the United States (Healthwise 1). Individual states may restrict therapeutic abortion

Abortion: Whether Or Not It Should Be Legal

1200 words - 5 pages murder. Abortion is killing another person and abortion is not in self-defense. Abortion is murder and takes the life of another human being. Abortion is murder and should be illegal in the United States of America.Lastly, abortions are dangerous to a mother and the fetus. First, there are other options to getting an abortion. These many safe options include absent nuance, putting the baby up for adoption, or putting the baby in a foster home where

To what extent should we consider The Picture of Dorian Gray to be a Gothic novel? - English Lit - ESSAY

2891 words - 12 pages ESSAY 5: To what extent should we consider The Picture of Dorian Gray to be a Gothic novel? Oscar Wilde’s first, and only, novel published in 1890 in Lipincott’s Magazine. Despite the censorship that the editor made unbeknownst to Wilde, his text still largely offended its bourgeoisie audience due to its critique on moral sensibility and public morality in the upper-class society. Wilde, irrefutably, includes many stereotypical conventions and

High School Students Should Be Drug Tested - English 1510 - Argument

1542 words - 7 pages Tackett 1 Tackett 4 Olivia Tackett Professor Jeffrey Hensley English 1510 4 March 2019 High School Students Should Be Drug Tested Drug abuse: a worldwide epidemic that has spread to our youth. The younger generation determines the future of our society. Can we really rely on the youth to better our world if they’re already starting to abuse drugs at such an early age? Schools try to manage their students’ use of drugs by setting anti-drug

Abortion rights Pro life vs Pro choice - English 110 - Compare and Contrast

1141 words - 5 pages Amanda D’Agostino Assignment #5: Evaluating, Comparing & Contrasting Two Readings ENG 110 College English 1 Section #.08 October 30, 2018   In today's society there are many topics that are carefully thought to be controversial. However, possibly no coexistent issue causes more controversy than abortion. A person can hardly read a newspaper, turn on the television, or even have a conversation with a friend without the topic coming up one way or

Should Welfare Involve Drug Testing? - Ohio University; English 1010 - Argument Paper

937 words - 4 pages Argument Essay The world changes every day. More people are born, more jobs collapse, and more opportunities present themselves. Government is such a powerful aspect of our lives, and there is not much we can do about it. The government seems as if it is beginning to take over and control our lives. Telling us what we can and cannot eat, how to treat others, and how to raise our children. These are parts of life that are meant to be decided upon

Abortion In the USA , illegal ? - Social Science - Essay

1995 words - 8 pages she should provide the right to decide if she need to abort or not. References Huq, M. E., et al. "Why Abortion is Illegal? Comparison of Legal and Illegal Abortion: A Critical Review." Mymensingh medical journal: MMJ 26.4 (2017): 944-952. Zane, Suzanne, et al. "Abortion-Related Mortality in the United States 1998–2010." Obstetrics and gynecology 126.2 (2015): 258. Sedgh, Gilda, et al. "Adolescent pregnancy, birth, and abortion rates across

Similar Papers

Should Universal Healthcare Be Implemented In The United States English Essay

477 words - 2 pages 1 Jaydin Shiloh Kim Bravo English 11 Period 2 4/15/18 Should Universal Healthcare be implemented in the United States Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit, sed diam nonummy nibh euismod tincidunt ut laoreet dolore magna aliquam erat volutpat. Ut wisi enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exerci tation ullamcorper suscipit lobortis nisl ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis autem vel eum iriure dolor in hendrerit in vulputate

Reason Abortion Should Remain Legal English Assignment

940 words - 4 pages deciding not to. There are many different circumstances that come with each pregnancy, and it should be our decisions to make. Unfortunately, we live in a world and society where nothing is perfect and bad things happen all around us. Thankfully, at this moment abortion is legal in the United States, though there are restrictions. Yet, in many countries abortion is illegal. We must put a stop to this and make a change for the women around world. The

Immigration In The United States English Research

2173 words - 9 pages weakened Americans' interpersonal communication skills. School districts should not cut back on fine arts classes. The Need for Reform to Protect the Dreamers in the United States Youngstown State University Abstract The purpose of this research is to establish that immigrants need of a well structed path to citizenship. The importance of not separating establish families for the mere fact that our system is broken, and how politics have hindered

Whether We Should Ban The Cigarettes Or Not Mlc Cigarettes

959 words - 4 pages that a 10 percent increase in cigarette prices will lead people under age 18 to reduce their smoking by 5-15 percent. In total, according to the recent study of Turkey, the increasing of the taxes on cigarettes led to a reduction in tobacco sales by 12% between 2008 and 2012. American research also provides a good illustration of the impact of tobacco taxation against the consumption of tobacco, which we can see how effective this policy is. Smoking