Act Ii, Julius Caesar: Comparison Of Relationship Between Brutus And Portia And Caesar And Calpurnia

2522 words - 11 pages

Act II: Development of Relationships between Husbands and WivesRelationships between characters play a great part in Julius Caesar, the Shakespearean tragedy about the scheming of Caesar's death, which then are shown to affect all aspects of Roman life. Some relationships show the concealed discord between characters, some show the conniving spirit of those who desire power, while others show how some hearts are devoted entirely to the greater good of the republic. The dialogue between Brutus and Portia, along with that of Calphurnia and Caesar, plays a significant role in the development of the plot. Portia is a symbol of Brutus's private life, a representative of correct intuition and ...view middle of the document...

I urged you further; then you scratched your head and too impatiently stamped with your foot" (2.1. 261-264). These odd mannerisms of Brutus lead Portia to be troubled once again, and when she inquires further about his affairs, he simply dismisses her with the wave of his hand. Portia also sees that Brutus' secrets have affected his physical appearance to a point almost beyond recognition. Brutus is restless, sleepless, and wisely she approaches him cautiously. All Portia wants to know, as a good wife, is the cause of his grief. However, even after Portia's long account of her grief and worry, Brutus is uneasy with this topic and coldly dismisses her, saying, "I am not well in health, and that is all" (2.1. 227). He avoids answering any questions about public business, but Portia is a more intelligent woman than that, and she finds fault in his pathetic defense, explaining that if he were sick, he would know how to obtain good health. Brutus feels intimidated once again, briefly stating, "Why so I do. Good Portia, go to bed" in hope of diverting Portia from finding the source of his grief (2.1. 280). Yet again, Portia is persistent, challenging Brutus by stating that Brutus is not ill, but has "a sick offense" within his mind, which she ought to know of.To gain his favor, she pleads with him by kneeling, demonstrating her willingness to be submissive. Archly and playfully, Portia tells of days long gone, and she cries, "And upon my knees /I charm you, by my once commended beauty, by all your vows of love, and that great vow /which did incorporate and make us one" (2.1. 290-294). Reasonably and logically, she tries to convey to Brutus of the meaning of marriage, where two beings become one and share a life together. Both being part of one body, she believes that she has the right to know of those mysterious cloaked men.At this time, Brutus feels a bit guilty of his past actions and knows that as husband and wife, they are not only two beings in one body, but equals, and lifts Portia up. Brutus shows his compassionate side, where he respects his wife and does not want her to feel inferior. Portia tells Brutus that if he were gentle, she would not need to beseech him while kneeling. Portia then restates that as a married couple, she is not just something, "to keep with you at meals, comfort your bed /and talk to you sometimes?" (2.1. 306-307). She does not feel like his wife and equal anymore, saying that she is not important when kept in the back of her husband's mind only for his pleasure. Guilty student. Portia, the rendition of the Roman modern woman, cannot live in that kind of state, believing that she feels used. She is very disturbed by the way she is treated, declaring "Portia is Brutus' harlot, not his wife" (2.1. 310). Slowly, Brutus understands his wife and feels shame when recalling what she has gone through. He tries to comfort her by saying, "You are my true and honorable wife, /as dear to me as are the ruddy drops /that visit my...

Other Essays On Act II, Julius Caesar: Comparison Of Relationship Between Brutus And Portia And Caesar And Calpurnia

Julius Caesar -- Character Dev Essay

896 words - 4 pages Development of Marcus BrutusMarcus Brutus, from the play Julius Cæsar, made many decisions. In making these decisions, he showed what kind of a person he was on a moral, intellectual, social, or practical level. Some of these decisions were good decisions and some of them were not. Through all of these decisions, though, it is shown what kind of a person Brutus was. Some of the decisions that Brutus made were not exactly the best

the use of flattery to achieve personal gain in Julius caesar - brampton christian school/English - essay

1182 words - 5 pages funeral. In William Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, major action in the play rests on the way Cassius, Brutus, and Antony use flattery as a tool to carry out their personal agenda. The first time the use of flattery is evident in the play, is seen through the way Cassius manipulates Brutus into being the face of his conspiracy. Cassius knows that Brutus is seen as righteous and noble in the eyes of the commoners, and that making him the face of the

nd Power Of Language In William Shakespeare's Julius Caesar - Bishop Ryan grade 11 - Essay

667 words - 3 pages Antony says, “ for Brutus, as you know, was Caesar’s angel / Judge, O you Gods how dearly Caesar lov’d him” ( iii, ii, 179-180 ) while he is giving his speech. He means that Caesar would have done almost anything for him and is trying to make the audience feel guilty; believing that Brutus betrayed someone who truly loved him. Therefore, Mark Antony is an example of how manipulation and language is used to change one’s perception when one thinks

an essay about who's the protagonist in Julius Caesar. quotations from the book are included. - Franco-Cité 12th grade - Essay

1545 words - 7 pages murder of Caesar. But Unlike Brutus and the other conspirators who are against the idea of Caesar making Rome a monarchy, Cassius’s motives are more personal. He also used Brutus, one of Julius Caesar’s best friend as a rival against him. To begin with, Cassius is the one who’s the most disapproving of Julius Caesar becoming king of Rome and he is also the driving force behind the conspiracy. Julius Caesar with the play being named after him is

Julis Caesar And The Women Around Him

4393 words - 18 pages and so still wanted a male heir. Gelzer, a modern historian, believes that Calpurnia may not have been a nonentity tossed about by political expediency but instead, a strong, educated woman, at whose side Caesar still slept as usual after fifteen years of marriage, and that the relationship was strong enough that she would worry about his safety and he would heed her advice. His useful perspective is significant as it provides a reasonable

Relationship between Louisa and Bounderby - Eton - Essay

433 words - 2 pages . Louisa only knows the upper class of Coketown, she complains to her father about not interacting with people who are unlike Bounderby and Gradgrind. Therefore, Dickens uses Louisa’s inquisitive nature to show respect for her father’s wishes and to highlight a certain rebellion within her. The respect consequentially distances the relationship between father and daughter, and is further strained by Gradgrind’s factual nature.

Comparison Between Clash Of Titans Movie And Myth

740 words - 3 pages compare and contrast the film, Clash of the Titans, to the story of Perseus compare and contrast the film,�Clash of the Titans, to the story of Perseus. Andromeda and Perseus Essay : The Story begins with Andromeda and Perseus. There are many Similarities and differences between what happens in the movie "Clash of the Titans" and the actual myth about Andromeda and Perseus. The three main similarities between the movie

Comparison paper between the declaration of independence and the constitution - GOV 200 - comparison paper

721 words - 3 pages Comparison Paper Michael Gordon GOVT 200- C01 The United State Constitution, The Declaration of Independence, and Thomas Jefferson’s Letter to the Danbury Baptists are altogether different in their expectations. The Declaration of Independence was the first of the three documents. It was just a proclamation to the World, mainly Britain, that these colonies were coming together as one and forming a new government completely separated from

The Relationship Between Diet And Social Behaviour And The Incidence Of Colds

2405 words - 10 pages transfer of rhinovirus type 14 from environmental surfaces to hands. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 59, 1579-85.AN APPLE A DAY. . .We are conducting a survey that looks at the relationship between what people eat and how often they catch a cold or the flu. Please take a few minutes to fill out this questionnaire as accurately as you can. All responses are anonymous.1.Are you Male or Female? (circle one)2.What is your age? (please fill in

Liberation From Sexism and Patriarchy in The Color Purple - Caesar Rodney High School, Adv. lit 11 - Essay

1826 words - 8 pages learned to abandon her vindictive state of mind and found peace through abandoning social norms. Pants no longer brought fear into her mind but strength and rebellion” (Harris). This small and seemingly inconsequential act of defiance allows Celie to begin her liberation from patriarchy. At one point in the novel, Celie and Shug converse on this specific topic: “Well, she say, looking me up and down, let's make you some pants.” “What I need pants

Comparison between Samurai and Knights - Seneca and Under graduate - Essay

1164 words - 5 pages of conducts to perform. They were hired for the protection of the Daimyo or the Dukes. The loyalty was formed based on the relation between the vassals and the lords. The peasants provided food to the samurai which gave loyalty to the Daimyo. The samurai used to protect the peasants in return and the Shogun used to give land to the samurai for the protection. Similarly, the knight used to protect the peasants for food and they were rewarded by

Similar Papers

Julius Caesar Essay

523 words - 3 pages Gaius Julius Caesar was a Roman military and political leader. He played an important part in the transformation of the Roman Republic into the Roman Empire. Caesar was born in Rome into a well-known patrician family, which supposedly traced its ancestry to Julus, the son of the Trojan prince Aeneas.Caesar was elected quaestor, who supervised the treasury and financial affairs of the state, its armies and its officers, by the Assembly of the

The Prince And Julius Caesar Comparative Study Sscbwb Essay

1036 words - 5 pages behaviour, continuing to blur the lines between virtue and vice by arguing, “there’ll always be something that looks more morally right but would actually lead to disaster,” thus positioning his audience to question their own doubts about unethical means of obtaining power. Thus, Machiavelli emphasises the necessity for a leader to disregard moral scruples when effectively attaining power. Contrastingly, Shakespeare, in Julius Caesar, uses the

Manipulation In Julius Caesar Essay

1158 words - 5 pages ." Shakespeare shows that Cassius wanted to kill Caesar because of personal greed but purposely made Brutus think he was only doing this for the good of the people. If Cassius had not persuaded Brutus to join the conspiracy then Brutus would have never been in the situation of having to kill the noble Julius Caesar. A form of persuasion that Shakespear uses in this play is with Portia, the wife of Brutus, and Calpurnia, the wife of Caesar. Both

Julius Caesar Tragic Hero Essay

645 words - 3 pages tragic hero because he realized his mistake and wished upon doing it but he could do nothing to fix it. That is why I chose Brutus as the tragic hero and not Caesar. So it is clearly stated that Brutus is the tragic hero in the play Julius Caesar. The series of events leading up to the death of Caesar and beyond made Brutus the tragic hero. Brutus was simply an honorable and respected man. But because of his flaws in character and decisions people began to go against Brutus. This made Brutus leave his family behind. Like I said above it catches up to him and soon leads him to his own death.