In Your Opinion, What Is Most Responsible For The Tragedy In Romeo And Juliet?

1663 words - 7 pages

There are three key areas that we can look at to see what factors were most responsible for the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet. These are Fate and Destiny, Circumstances and Characters. These factors should cover the broad spectrum of causes and factors that contribute and perhaps be the most influential in the culmination of the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet.The first group of factors that I am going to look at is the interference of Fate and Destiny. An example of Fate and Destiny playing a part in the tragedy is in Act 1 Scene 2 Lines 72-87 where Benvolio suggests to Romeo that they go and gate crash the Capulet masked ballROMEO: "A fair assembly: Whither should they come?SERVANT: Up.ROMEO: ...view middle of the document...

I will explore this option later.One other example that ties in with the factor of Fate and Destiny playing a part in the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet is in Act 3 scene 4 Line 16CAPULET: "Monday, ha ha! Well, Wednesday is too soon,A' Thursday let it be - a' Thursday, tell her,She shall be married to this noble earl........................................Therefore we'll have some half a dozen friends.And there an end, But what say you to Thursday?PARIS: My lord, I would that Thursday were tomorrow."In this passage Capulet's and Paris's planning go some way to sealing the fate and destiny of Juliet because they are controlling events without her knowledge. The fact that Joliet's father made the decision for his daughters future as the wife of Paris had far reaching consequences for everyone, this can be describe as an analogy of a pebble been dropped in a pond and the ripples and consequences effects everybody's lives, however in the Renaissance and Shakespearian eras it was the custom for powerful families to arrange their children's marriages so the thought of consulting Juliet on whether she shall marry Paris or not does not enter his decision making progress and he does not consciously see anything wrong in doing this because it was the accepted norm at the time.In the above paragraphs I have given three different instances of Fate and Destiny playing a part in the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet. The quotes have been written in chronological order they all show relevance and describe instances of Fate and Destiny playing a part in the tragedy.The second major factor that contributes to the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet is the circumstances of various events that may have contributed to the tragedy.A basic example of circumstances contributing to the tragedy is the rivalry between the too families. This rivalry is shown throughout the play but the first account of when we the audience knows this is at the very beginning of the play when the chorus gives his opening speech."Two households, both alike in dignity,In fair Verona (where we lay our scene),From ancient grudge break our new mutiny,...........................................................The fearful passage of their death-marked love,And the continuance of their parent's rage,..........................................................What here shall miss, our toil shall strive to mend."This speech not only tells us of the rivalry between the two houses but it also tells us from the start that Romeo and Juliet will take their lives" A Pair of star crossed lovers take their life:"Another example that shows circumstances playing a part in the tragedy is in Act 3 Scene 1 from line 50 onward. This passage tells is of the confrontation between Tybalt and Romeo and Mercutio. (See 2nd quotation of 1st page) This passage is when Tybalt seeks vengeance of Romeo gate crashing the Capulet masked ball, however Romeo refuses to be baited and Mercutio decides to fight Tybalt himself. This particular...

Other Essays On In Your Opinion, What Is Most Responsible For The Tragedy In Romeo And Juliet?

Romeo And Juliet-Responsibility For Their Deaths

1323 words - 6 pages towards their daughter only pushed her closer to her death. For these reasons, Lord and Lady Capulet take on responsibility for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet.The characters in Shakespeare's story of Romeo and Juliet all can be held responsible for their tragic fate. Friar Laurence, Tybalt, and Lord and Lady Capulet all take on active roles in the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. Their unreliability, careless mistakes, and abusive behavior towards the star-crossed lovers all make them accountable for the their fall. Therefore, the lesson learned is that intentional and unintentional mistakes all have consequences.

Romeo And Juliet Essay

1309 words - 6 pages proud me no prouds, but fettle your fine joints 'gainst Thursday next to go with Paris to Saint Peter's Church, or I will drag thee on a hurdle thither" helps highlight the fact that Juliet is forced to marry Paris and has no choice. This quote shows that Juliet hides her feelings for Romeo from her father because of the family feud and since she is forced to marry Paris against her will, she goes to extremes in order to avoid the marriage and

Romeo And Juliet

1147 words - 5 pages Chan 1Andrea ChanMrs. AshmanESLAO1.1Romeo and JulietRash behaviour is an action that happens without thinking about the consequences, which may cause someone trouble. In the book Romeo and Juliet, there are many acts of rash behaviour. They are shown through fights and ignorance. The rash behaviours change the outcome negatively because they lead to more angers and deaths.The rushed love between Romeo and Juliet is the most important

How Does Baz Luhrmann's Gain Sympathy For Romeo And Juliet And Engage The Interest Of A Modern Audience?

936 words - 4 pages innocence.The scene in which Romeo and Juliet first meet is one that is instantly different from that amidst the actual party. The music suddenly changes from fast paced and loud, to much more serene and soft creating dramatic interest for the audience. These changes show that something significant is about to happen and pulls the audience in. Romeo and Juliet first see each other through the fish tank between the bathrooms. Camera angles are quite a

Romeo and juliet and the theme of death

489 words - 2 pages Slash, cling, clank these are the sounds that are heard in a sword fight as a man is killed. In the play Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare the theme death is portrayed many times by the characters Marcutio, Romeo, and Juliet.The first instance of the theme death was in act 3 when Marcutio challenged Tybalt to a sword fight. 'Ask for me tomorrow, and you shall find a grave man.'(Act three, scene 1, line 104.) Also as Marcutio is dying he

Romeo And Juliet: Main Chapter

326 words - 2 pages him.Friar Romeo Alack, Alack, what blood is this which stains The stony entrance of this sepulchre? What mean these masterless and gory swords To lie discolour'd by this place of peace? Romeo, oh pale ! who else, what Paris too? And steep'd in blood? Ah what an unkind hour Is guilty of this lamentable chance ! The Lady stirs.Juliet Oh comfortable Friar, where is my Lord? I do remember well where I should be : And there I am, where is my Romeo

Public Opinion In California

1731 words - 7 pages actively seeking to improve the imageof, and therefore the public opinion regarding public housing. The OaklandTribune (2003) reports that a new public housing project is aimed at attractingboth renters and home buyers with varying incomes. As is stated in the article,the project "represents the new model for public hous! ing because it will offer amix of low- to medium-income apartments , townhouses and even single-familyhomes" (Oakland Tribune, 2003

Romeo And Juliet Of Sheakpear Is Not A Love Story.It Is A Story About Infatuation Of Young People

1116 words - 5 pages changeable man like Romeo what will happen when Romeo meets a girl who is more beautiful than Juliet? Youth that is the time we are not mature enough to give a right decision, and we are easily to mistake infatuation for love. And Romeo and Juliet is not the only one people who mistakes like that. My cousin also make mistake like that. He falls in love with her colleague at the first sight, and he thinks that she is the true love of his life

Political Issue in the Bhopal Gas Tragedy

486 words - 2 pages what indigenous businesses can pay, then they attract the best workers, which hurt employers in surrounding businesses. Also, all of the above types of businesses destroy the local culture by introducing an American climate.Along the way it had become rather convenient for some Indian officials to ignore the goodwill and contributions that UCIL had made to India during more than a half century of doing business there. The government of India brought a suit against Union Carbide in the United States, even though the disaster occurred in India and the nation has a well-established court system based on the same legal principles as those in the United States.

Disadvantages and advantages of home schooling. Situations in which home schooling would be better for a child and for an educational system. OPINION!!!

629 words - 3 pages This is a very controversial issue for myself as I wasin 4-H while in high school and I knew a lot of home schoolers. In fact some of my good friends switched from public school to home schooling in the middle of their high school years. Some of my own opinions ondisadvantages of home schooling include the loss of cultural and economic differences, for example in most public school and many private school situations you are going to have kids of

This essay tells what is true and what is false in the movie Braveheart. So it tells the historical accuracy of the film

545 words - 3 pages country. Wallace was an outlawed because he did not the sign Ragman Roll, which bound signatories in loyalty to England's King Edward I, which is true. Wallace like the movie showed organized other outlawed men into an army, however what was not shown was that he had a partner, Andrew Moray, who was killed at Stirling Bridge. The most glaring and important piece of fiction pertaining to Wallace was the fact that he was a landed commoner with a

Similar Papers

Romeo And Juliet : Describe The Main Idea In Your Text And Explain What You Learned From It

1188 words - 5 pages "Romeo and Juliet" is an Elizabethan play of tragedy, written by William Shakespeare. Romeo and Juliet is about two "star-crossed" lovers, of feuding households, who die for the ultimate price of love, and each other. Shakespeare communicates the underlying main idea of love through contrasting the many different forms of love which appear through the play. Various characters in the play talk of love from many different points of view. We are

What Events In The Play Of Romeo And Juliet Do You Think Changes The Course Of Action From Romance To Tragedy?

355 words - 2 pages Romeo and Juliet, two lovers who long for eachothers warmth and love. Romeo and Juliet's love caused horror and pain for both families, the Capulets and the Montagues. The epic tale went from romance to tragedy because of the irrasponsibility of the characters. The tragic story took place in the city of Verona. The familes of Romeo and Juliet have been torn apart for a reason beyond the text. Juliet belonging to the house of Capulets and

"Haste Is Waste" In Romeo And Juliet

943 words - 4 pages me not of fear!" (4.1 Line 121). After a mixup and Romeo gets misinformed that Juliet is dead, he gets so upset and kills himself without really thinking about it. If he only waited a little while, or consulted Friar Laurence, he would find out that Juliet really was not dead. "Well, Juliet, I will lie with thee tonight./ Let's see for means- O mischief, thou art swift/ To enter in the thoughts of desperate men!" (5.1 Lines 35-36), Romeo says when

Confusion In Romeo And Juliet Essay

548 words - 3 pages Peter LigeiroWilliam Shakespeare's highly acclaimed drama Romeo and Juliet is the story of two lovers against fate who by their death end the quarrels between their families, the Montague's and the Capulet. After meeting each other at a masquerade, they fall in one. However, the dread between the houses proves too strong as the story ends with a tragic ending. People who become masters of their trade have first to become masters of the tool. For