Assignment On Mill And Justice Philosophy

1546 words - 7 pages

Mill and JusticeIn Mill's chapter five (The connection between justice and utility) Utilitarianism he focuses on the idea of what makes an action just? However, before one must understand the meaning of Utilitarianism (Utility) to fully grasp the concept of justice. The definition of Utilitarianism is " An ethical theory holding that the proper course of action is the one that maximizes the overall "happiness", by whatever means necessary." (Dctionary.com) As we discussed in class, the Principle of Utility is "An action is right if and only if it brings more pleasure, overall for all the people effected by it". In chapter five, Mill discusses the concept of Utility, yet somehow is able ...view middle of the document...

The third example is "Universally considered just that each person should get what he deserves (whether good or evil) and unjust that someone should obtain a good or be made to undergo an evil which he doesn't deserve." (31) This is probably the easiest example to be able to understand. If someone does the right thing, then they should in return receive good things, if someone does the wrong thing, then they shouldn't get anything good. The fourth example, "It is agreed to be unjust to break faith with anyone, to fail to do something we have said or clearly implied that we would do or disappoint expectations raised by our conduct." (31) In other words, this can changed if the receiving person has shown a good deal of disrespect and hatred towards you. The fifth example, " Everyone agrees that it is inconsistent with justice to be partial- to show favour or preference to one person over another in matters to which favour and preference don't properly apply." (31) What Mill is trying to say here is that no one thinks it's unjust to have a best friend, or boyfriend, or favorite teacher. Impartially though is an obligation, something that "out to influence" something. Equality and impartiality are almost the same. When someone is seeking justice, they often think of equality of your rights.When thinking about the difference between a wrong action, and an unjust action, normally I would think they have the same meaning, but they don't according to Mill. As we discussed in class, an action is wrong if and only if it brings more pain that pleasure overall for those affected. However, an action is unjust if and only if it's wrong, and if it violates someone's rights. There is a clear distinction between the two concepts. While discussing what it means to be "wrong" Mill tells his readers that when someone accuses of someone else that they have done something wrong, it really is just implying that that person should be punished for their wrong actions, either through the law, your peers, or even yourself. It goes the same when we say someone has done something "right", they both coincide with " The notion of fitness to be punished which is the underlying characteristic between morality and expediency."(33)Mill begins to get on the topic of "rights", and discusses "what is a persons right?" Speaking legally, Mill says the law gives a person an individual right of ownership. Whether injustice is going on or not, they're two things that are happening here. The first, is that a wrong is being done, and the second being that a person is wronged. " Some person's having a right correlated with the moral obligation constitutes the defining difference that separates justice from generosity or beneficence. Justice implies something which it is not only right to do, and wrong not to do, but which some individual person can claim from us as his moral right." ( 34) It is hard to put a finger on what is considered "morally right" because so many people have differ...

RELATED

What is Justice in the perspective of Thrasymachus and Glaucon in Plato's Republic - Philosophy - Essay

626 words - 3 pages David 1 Last Name 2 Peter David Professor Mesing Philosophy February 5, 2018 Short Paper (Pair #2) What is justice? The dictionary definition of this word says that it is the legal or philosophical theory by which fairness is administered. However, in Plato’s book “The Republic”, two characters named Glaucon and Thrasymachus have their own version of what this word exactly means to them. In this essay, I am going to thoroughly analyze and make a

Utilitarianism and John Stuart Mill - Hofstra University; Philosophy 14 - Essay

656 words - 3 pages Nora Darragh Utilitarianism Originally established by Jeremy Bentham, the functional belief of Benthamism was well altered by his successor John Stuart Mill, who popularized it as Utilitarianism. Utilitarianism is a form of consequentialism and its main concept is that whether actions are morally right or the opposite. Mill’s doctrine of utility explains that in order to obtain happiness, there must be a pursuit in gaining happiness and the

‘The ends always justify the means’. Do they? Discuss in contrast to utilitarianism - Open Uni - Essay

1612 words - 7 pages common types of utilitarianism are Act and Rule utilitarianism. Act utilitarianism, popular with classical utilitarian Jeremy Bentham, focuses on a more simplistic hedonic calculous of an action. Rule utilitarianism, product of which spans from John Stewart Mill, focuses on the types of actions categorising them into higher and lower pleasures. In this essay I will mark the distinctions between the two types of theory from Bentham and Mill whilst

On Liberty Paper detailing what the book is about and how this book impacted politics - CBC Raines - Book Report

991 words - 4 pages English philosopher, jurist, and social reformer regarded as the founder of modern utilitarianism. His father deliberately set out to create a genius who could carry on Bentham's philosophy of utilitarianism. Mill spent his career as an administrator for the British East India Company, the company charged with ruling the colony of India, and later as a university administrator, while constantly studying and writing about utilitarianism and other

Comparing Letter from the Birmingham Jail to Philosophical writers - freshmen - Final Essay

1302 words - 6 pages Adrianna Garcia Professor Weissman Philosophy December 5th, 2017 Philosophy Final In Martin Luther King’s letter from the Birmingham jail, he addresses the claims made against him by the clergymen of Alabama. These clergymen believed King’s demonstrations to be “untimely and unwise,” which King finds to be an odd claim; since they have failed to recognize the recent incidents that have occurred in Birmingham. As King addresses the many claims

Evaluate the view that Utilitarianism continues to offer a useful way of resolving moral dilemmas - St ambrose college, 6fr - Essay

1523 words - 7 pages Free . Mill emphasised, and based his theory, upon the idea that there are many different ‘types’ of pleasure, and categorised these pleasures into two sections, ‘higher’ and ‘lower’ pleasures. His thought was that there is something different about pleasure of the mind such as art, music, literature, philosophy and bodily pleasures, alcohol and other material objects. He also recognises that we have a strong internal conviction that an action cannot be

Aristotle Vs. Plato

599 words - 3 pages PLATO VS. ARISTOTLE Dialectical & maieutic Organic systematization, distinction of themes and problems according to their nature and differ- ing methods of resolution Faith/religious based arguments Rigorous, theoretical logos based arguments Used mysticism in philosophy Philosophy based on concrete things of exper- ience Speculative interests Speculative interests and empirical interests employing anthropology Use of mathematical

Candide: Thoughts of Voltaire on Optimism, Philosophy and “The Other” - High school - Essay

1720 words - 7 pages Büyükçulhacı 6 Alp Hazar Büyükçulhacı 13.01.2014 Candide: Thoughts of Voltaire on Optimism, Philosophy and “The Other” “Candide or Optimism”; with its main character Candide constantly roaming around the world carrying questions of good and evil, and through the lines of the book take place the thoughts of criticism that flow through the river of philosophy on the terrain of satire, is a short novel of François-Marie Arouet or best known as

Is pornography harmful to society - Human relation - Essay

2299 words - 10 pages . Law Review, 1997, para 13 Home Office, 'Consultation: On the possession of extreme pornographic material' [2005], para 31 R v Coutts, [2007] 1 Cr App R 6 CPS, 'CPS Guidelines, Extreme Pornography' (cps.gov.uk 2008) accessed 2 May 2014 Dyzenhaus, David, John Stuart Mill and the Harm of Pornography, “Ethics”, vol. 102, n. 3, 1992, pp. 534-55 John Stuart Mill, The Subjection of Women, 1869 Criminal Justice and Immigration Act 2008 s 63(6)(b

Malcolm X's Changing Philosophies - English - Research Paper

2202 words - 9 pages the life of a true Sunni Muslim. I must repeat that I am not a racist nor do I subscribe to the tenets of racism. I can state in all sincerity that I wish nothing but freedom, justice and equality, life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness for all people” (Malcolm X). Malcolm left behind the philosophy that the long term solution of black oppression is Black Separatism, and even began questioning his own short term solution of Black Nationalism

Bibliographical Notes Classical Theorists - Western - Assignment

733 words - 3 pages authorship between the writing of each other (Bourdeau, 2015). Shortly after the writing of “Course of Positive Philosophy”, he was interrupted because of a ‘cerebral crisis’ due to overwork and depression in marriage (Bourdeau, 2015). Comte was hospitalized and classified as “not cured”, but thanks to the devotion and patience of his wife, Comte recovered gradually (Bourdeau, 2015). During what period of the world history that he was living and

Utilitarianism and Capital Punishment - Study of Religion - Essay

1222 words - 5 pages order to increase our happiness and pleasure, thus allowing us to live a good life. Utilitarianism is the moral theory that states that the the level of morality of an action is determined by “the balance of good over evil that is produced by that action” (Pecorino, n.d.). The most important classical utilitarians are Jeremy Bentham and his protégée John Stuart Mill, both of which were renowned theorists and social reformers. Their fundamental

Is self-determination a good idea? - Durham University - Theory & History of IR - Formative Assignment

1823 words - 8 pages nationalities.’ (Mill, 1972, p.361) However, Mill still saw an exception in nations containing supposedly less developed ‘barbarians’ that would require ‘tutelage’, a belief stemming from Said’s argument of a constructed identity that depicted other peoples as inferior and ‘worthy’ of Western domination (Brown, 2006, p.78). A post-colonial, modern critique counters this in arguing that through self-determination, there is the potential for non

A Movement: Romanticism and Liberalism Interference - English 3200 - Research and paper discussing the Romantic Era

1889 words - 8 pages their number, or the demand for labour has increased, that the market price of labour will rise to its natural price, and that the labourer will have the moderate comforts which the natural rate of wages will afford. 3. Utilitarianism: philosophy guiding 19th century English social reform Utilitarianism was a reaction against the Enlightenment principles and the French Revolution. It sought to be concrete rather than abstract. The word utility meant

Digital Revolution and Freedom of Expression - Criminology 2018 - Essay

2181 words - 9 pages , also known as suspicion of government.[footnoteRef:3] Cyberspace and cyber technologies support and contribute to Mills arguments, while also contributing to ensuring civil liberties, such as right to education, privacy, and freedom of expression. [3: Mill, John Stuart, “The Structure and Content of Rights”, On Liberty, Oxford University Press (1859) at 356] The search for truth and betterment of the community mainly deals with the importance of