What Was The Relationship Between Masculinity And Chivalry In Medieval Society? Medieval History Essay

3742 words - 15 pages

B074116
What was the relationship between masculinity and chivalry in medieval society?
The figure of the knight or chevalier dominates the image of the medieval world. Arthurian Romance and troubadour lyrics tell stories of heroes, damsels in distress and lavish courts filled with women of beauty and men of honour. Looking at chivalry in such a romanticized way results in viewing it as being a purely positive force in society that helped to create order and shape a group of potentially barbaric and violent men into cultured and valorous knights who used their swords to protect women and God alike. However when looking closer it becomes clear that such a reading is untenable. Even within chivalric literature there are contradictions and the heroes’ ideas of right and wrong are juxtaposed to reveal a complex and fluid ideology. This complexity is furthered when one starts to think about the men in the story and what makes them men. The notion of masculinity in the medieval world was surprisingly as complicated as it is today and there is danger in assuming that masculinity can be discussed as a singular concept. It is better to think of the term masculinities and view each section of society as having its own set of rules and values which helped to create how men should act. Chivalry was one of these set of ideals that helped to create one kind of masculinity within society for a particular group of men. The relationship between chivalry and the masculinity it created though was not black and white. I want to understand how chivalry helped to shape masculinity and create warriors? What this kind of masculinity looked like? And if chivalry did actually create anything that resembled the romantic ideal Knight.
I will begin by first looking at the notion of chivalry and what the term fully means, before moving on to looking at how these ideals played out in the life of a Knight. I will be using the text traditionally known as L’ Histoire de Guillume le Marechal or the History of William Marshall (2002) edited by A.J. Holden to find evidence for how chivalry was enacted and helped to shape men. William Marshall played a crucial role in the creation of the Angevin Empire and is recognised as being the epitome of the knightly ideal and the text therefore is of great value in its representation of chivalry. Although it should be noted that when discussing passages from the poem it must be recognised that the work was created to bolster William Marshall’s reputation and fame and many of the events have been altered to present the hero’s actions in the most favourable light. In line with this, the purpose of the poem was to celebrate William Marshall, not just recount his deeds, therefore the narrative is constrained by the conventions and troupes of contemporary literary fiction and this takes precedent over historical accuracy. Furthermore the work was written 40 years after the Marshall’s death which again results in one having to view its historical...

Other Essays On What was the relationship between masculinity and chivalry in medieval society? - Medieval History - Essay

Advanced Medieval Essay Proposal - Advanced Medieval Literature - Essay

594 words - 3 pages such, throughout history it was generally used in a derogatory sense.” The boundaries are made clear between the Christians and the non-believers of Christianity, with the latter being categorised under the group “paganism”. Anyone who believes in religions and practices other than Christianity are thus swept under this category, and looked down upon. Both Christianity and paganism practice magic, prayers, and rituals to aid in the healing or

To what extent was homosexuality the norm in classical Athens - Ancient History - Essay

4303 words - 18 pages clearly… exactly what the role implied in the sexual relation…all that constituted something of a blind spot.”[footnoteRef:14] There was a thin undrawn line, between that of prostitutes degraded by homosexual penetration and that of a respectable man with open sexual preferences who could maintain their honour due to the value of the relationship to the young boy. Cohen argued that all homoerotic relationships brought shame to the younger partner

what was the impact of residential schools in canada - history class - essay

589 words - 3 pages What was the impact of residential school's policy on the first nations communities in the early 20th century? By: Marina Santos Residential schools have been a part of Canadian history for many years, and it has left a large impact on many first nation communities in the 20th century such as families dealing with the effects of separation and loss of traditions, children having their natural community and supports violated and lastly how it

Martin Luther and his theology. Protestant reformation in the Medieval time. First reformer. - University of St Thomas - Theology

1634 words - 7 pages fully dedicated and had a hard time. He was too much into fasting, prayer, and work. Somethings he uses to torture himself by fasting and other fellow monks were worried about him. During his time in the monastery, he developed a close relationship with the bible. One reason of Luther being too much into the fasting and paying was that he thought the righteousness of God means that God judges people for their sins. So, he was trying to prove

Examine the relationship between power and knowledge in contemporary development - Geography - Essay

2407 words - 10 pages to produce, map and govern the Third World. This essay will use the framework introduced by Foucault to investigate how the development dispositif as the sum of its individual parts produces and manages the relationship between power and knowledge in contemporary development. Before delving into the ways in which power and knowledge command contemporary development it is necessary to isolate the relationship of these terms outside of it. Power and

Medieval china, why china grew so fast - History - Research

1181 words - 5 pages disciplined and had a better structured government along with better work and technological force. They led the era with their wisdom, technological advances, and a little help from mother nature. In conclusion, Medieval China was an empire before its time. Works Cited Baker, P. (2015, Febuary 10). Medieval European History. Retrieved from SJSU History: http://www.sjsu.edu/people/patricia.backer/history/middle.htm Centricity. (2016). China During

Relationship between Louisa and Bounderby - Eton - Essay

433 words - 2 pages How does Dickens vividly portray Louisa and Mr Gradgrind’s relationship? This scene shows Mr Gradgrind and Louisa deliberating over Mr Bounderby’s proposal to Louisa. Mr Gradgrind is in favour of the marriage however, Louisa does not want to marry him. In this dialogue, Dickens shows the reader the respect Louisa has for her father; how Gradgrind’s philosophy has inhibited his ability to properly care for his daughter, and the extent of

Darwinism and the American Society - History-144 - Essay

712 words - 3 pages eugenics, affected immigration and everyday life in America within the nineteen hundreds in many various ways. Rather than believing that God created individuals and everything within the universe, Darwin’s theory declares that the evolution of species from a certain process was how humans were formed. This affected society in America changing people’s ideas including different tactics such as immigration, imperialism, and health. This was used

A study of blacksmiths in medieval times - Dramatic Arts - subclass

650 words - 3 pages weaved in. These Gauntlets of Titans Stone become your main source of damage while using the Gauntlets you gain the following benefits. -You can use Intelligence instead of Strength for the attack and damage rolls of your Gauntlet strikes. - You can roll a d4 in place of the damage of the Gauntlet Strikes. This die changes as you gain Artificer levels. Level 3: 2d6 Level 6: 2d8 level 9: 2d10 - The Gauntlets are dual wielding so those same rules

Ensign Essay, Relationship between Masterchiefs and Officers - ROTC - Essay

595 words - 3 pages all of the hard and dirty work, and they’ve earned their way to where they are. So it’s important for the newly commissioned officers to listen to their enlisted counterparts and spend the first several months actively listening and paying attention. As the United States Naval Institution website describes in a more personal account of a relationship between a new officer and an experienced enlisted, the chiefs know that their superior is an

Critically assess the relationship between social inequality and public health - Health Policy - Essay

3453 words - 14 pages in nearly every country in the world today present not just a moral danger, but a mortal danger as well.” The relationship between social inequalities and public health is an undeniable one that is intensifying with the notion that poor health is more and more becoming due to social inequalities. Undoubtedly income is the overall factor that ties public health to social inequalities as fundamentally, the distribution of income is what creates

Similar Papers

The Effects Of The Feudal System On English Medieval Society History Higher Essay

729 words - 3 pages Phyllis Brady Access to Humanities A The Effects of The Feudal System on English Society in The Medieval Society The idea of Feudalism was first introduced in 1066, after William the conqueror defeated the Leader of the English, King Harold at the battle of Hastings. The Feudal system was a simple structure comprising of the upper classes such as Kings, the Church and landed classes and the lower classes such as the villeins and the peasants

To What Extent Was The Usa A Racist Society Between 1919 And 1941?

854 words - 4 pages The USA was a racist society to a large extent between 1919 and 1941, however it peaked in the years during and immediately after the Depression, as blacks and immigrants faced antagonism due to their holding of jobs, however menial they were. Whilst some gains were made in the black rights movement, there were still underlying racist tones throughout the country.Racism, especially towards African Americans, was ingrained in the average white

Essay Describing Women In The Medieval Times British Literature Essay

1034 words - 5 pages different backgrounds with different stories but similarities between the two. One character being fictional and the other being a nonfictional character that actually lived through problems society viewed women as. The Wife of Bath would have held power over men if she would’ve existed during those times in the Medieval period, the amount of number of unions was so high that it was frowned by the society of stong Christians values. Because of

Brief Outline Of Death And Diseases In The Medieval Era

951 words - 4 pages believed are; (also in included some facts about medieval medicine)Medicine during the medieval era was multi-faceted, relying on the skills of several classes of practitioners. The ill and aged were treated by university trained physicians, monks, or folk healers, depending on the patient's socio-economic class. Though medical practices and procedures in the middle ages are generally considered obsolete and relying on herbal remedies, prayer