Professional Ethics Case 2 Study Assignment 1 University Of Waterloo, Phil333 Assignment

1100 words - 5 pages

3
NORMATIVE ETHICAL THEORIES
PHIL 333, Assignment 1
Case 2.2
One main issue question pertaining to professional ethics stands out in this case: Was the doctor justified in trying an experimental treatment on Ms. Kay’s dog Sandy even though she had decided against it and asked that the dog be euthanized? In analyzing this case and the ethical issue presented, I would use two normative ethical theories – Rule utilitarianism and Kantian deontological ethics.
Rule utilitarianism states that the morally right action is one that is in accordance with a moral rule which general observance would create the most happiness. It evaluates a consequence as if it will be later replicated in the future. Rule utilitarianism does not evaluate individual actions separately, but supports rules whose acceptance maximizes utility. In this case, it will be evaluated whether performing such a risky experimental treatment on Sandy without the consent of Ms. Kay is in accordance with the rule. The rule that would apply in this situation will be for Dr Cee to only perform the experimental treatment if Ms. Kay consents to it. Professional ethical rules are rules that comply with professional ethics such as administering treatments to patients according to their guidance will, or legal decision makers. As such, I would say that Dr Cee’s action does not comply with this rule. Medical professionals are not allowed to undergo such procedures without a signed consent from the patient, or the legal decision maker. Rules that apply in accordance with professional ethics, generally promote over all happiness in accordance with rule utilitarianism even if the end result is not positive or good. Even though Sandy was free from all symptoms after the experimental treatment, but if such action will be later replicated in the future, then it will be a concern of trust. People will not feel comfortable to take their dogs to Veterinarians in fear that experimental treatments will be conducted on them in the same manner. This will result to too many sick dogs in the society, and in the long run will lead to higher medical expenses. Based on this case, rule utilitarianism would judge that Dr Cee shouldn’t have done it because it wasn’t Ms. Kay’s wish for Sandy to undergo such a lengthy and uncomfortable treatment – as described in case 2.2. As such rule utilitarianism is showing that Dr Cee’s act is unethical and will not maximize over all happiness in the long run.
I do not think that rule utilitarianism prescribes a solution to this case, but it offers some insights about the nature of morality, and the principle of impartiality as an essential part of moral decision making. I would think that if Dr Cee had opened up to Ms. Kay on how he felt about the experimental treatment even though ninety- five percent of the previous ones conducted in the lab failed, she might have reasoned with him to consent to the treatment. In this way, irrespective of the outcome, it will lead to overall...

Other Essays On professional ethics case 2 study assignment 1 - University of Waterloo, PHIL333 - assignment

Case Study 2 - Accident Causation - Saint Leo HRA-330 - Case Study Assignment

795 words - 4 pages Case Study 2 2 August 30, 2018 HRA-330 Case Study 2 Abstract This case study will discuss the concerns at hand as an HR representative. In this case study, Joe is the employee who brought some safety and health concerns to light and declined to continue you doing his current duties in fear of his life. Joann, his boss, declines his request and uses intimidation, threatening to fire Joe. This case is examined from an HR perspective and discusses

C304 Task 1 Professional Roles and Values - WGU C304 - Assignment

4432 words - 18 pages 1 Running head: PROFESSIONAL ROLES AND VALUES, TASK 1 15 PROFESSIONAL ROLES AND VALUES, TASK 1 Professional Roles and Values, Task 1 Billie Hoyt Western Governors University Nursing Theory Theory of Self-Care, Self-Care Deficits, and Nursing Systems by Dorothea Orem, 1971 states, “ When a client incurs an insult that renders him or her incapable of fully functioning, deficient self-care occurs, which makes nursing intervention necessary

Marketing – The Ethics of Emotion from a Can - Thompson Rivers University - BUSN 6011 - Assignment

1747 words - 7 pages Assignment 3: Marketing – The Ethics of Emotion from a Can BUSN 6011 Business Ethics & Corporate Social Responsibility - Winter 2018 Dwight Linton - TXXXXXXX Page | 1 Assignment Overview Read Ethics in Action 8.1, “Marketing—The ethics of emotions from a can,” and answer the Think Theory question on page 349. Assignment 3 Question: • In the light of the normative ethical theories discussed in Chapter 3, how can we evaluate the use of the

Counselling Notes for Level 2 Counselling Skills - Open University - Assignment

1493 words - 6 pages Level 2 Counselling Skills 19/09/2018 Digital Workbook Password: tsn2018_L2CSPA UNIT 1 – Using Counselling Skills Q1 Identify core counselling skills. (1.1) There are nine significant core counselling skills that can be used to help develop healthy working counselling relationships and during interventions/activities. These skills are unconditional positive regard, genuineness, empathetic understanding, active listening, questioning

Unit 2 Assignment about methods of policing - Purdue University CJ110 - Essay

2214 words - 9 pages Running head: Policing and crime analysis 1 Policing and crime analysis 8 Models of Policing and Effective Crime Analysis Billie S. West CJ110-01 Purdue University Global April 28, 2019 Models of Policing and Effective Crime Analysis One of the main goals of law enforcement is to prevent crime from happening. The purpose of this paper is to inform the reader about the different models of policing, how they work, and how effective crime analysis

Patagonia's Anti Growth Strategy - University of Scranton 504A Management Module - Week 2 Discussion Assignment

2030 words - 9 pages has continued unabated: this year, the company expects to gross about six hundred million dollars. All of this would be jet fuel for the engines of modern cynicism, if not for the fact that Patagonia, a privately owned corporation now in its fifth decade, has a distinguished record of environmental philanthropy and investment. The company has often made risky choices in favor of its ecological and social ethics, including early bets that

final exam assignment information technology - University of potomac - Assignment

1651 words - 7 pages Final Exam 8.1 1 Assignment 4.1. 3 Week 8- Assignment 8.1 Dishank patel University of the Potomac – Virginia Campus CBSC235 Foundation Of Cyber Security. Professor P Jaikaran 06/24/2018 Abstract As of late system security has turned into

C204 Managing Human Capital Task 1 - Western Governor's University - Assignment

2913 words - 12 pages BKM1 - BKM1 TASK 1 2 BKM1 - BKM1 TASK 1 4 BKM1 TASK 1 Parker Swinford 00891098 Western Governors University Management Communication C204 Running head: BKM1 - BKM1 TASK 1 1 A. Compose a motivational email to internal staff that discusses two advantages and two disadvantages of the product and explain how to mitigate the disadvantages should they occur. To: All Sales Personnel From: Parker Swinford – National Sales Manager Subject: Exciting New

network and security homework 1 - george mason university - assignment

657 words - 3 pages MIS 320 – 004 HW Assignment #1 1. As related to networking, what are protocols? In short, network protocols are the rules for communications between them. The long definition is Network protocols are formal standards and policies comprised of rules, procedures and formats that define communication between two or more devices over a network. 2. What are the two parts of a MAC address? The two parts of the mac address are, Organizational

strategic Management and Techonologgy week 1 - San Ignacio University - Assignment

567 words - 3 pages 1 Running Head: HOMEWORK 1, CHAPTER 1 & 2 4 CHAPTER 1&2 San Ignacio University Strategic Management and Technology Prof. Dr. Lemus JENNIFER TELLES Discussion Questions Page 10 1. Why is innovation so important for firms to compete in many industries? The increasing importance of innovation has been driven largely the globalization of markets and the advent pf advanced technologies that enable more rapid product design and allow shorter

International Finance Chapter 1 Questions - Athens University International Finance - Assignment

646 words - 3 pages their products as other firms enter those markets (product cycle theory). Questions & Applications 1. (#5 a.) The operating characteristics of the firm and the risk perception of international business will influence the degree to which a firm becomes internationalized. 2. (#5 b.) The Internet allows for easy and low-cost communication between countries, so that firms could now develop contacts with potential customers overseas by having a

Similar Papers

Group Assignment For Semester 2, 2018 University Of Adelaide Assignment

730 words - 3 pages Assignment Advance Funds Management (M) Semester 2, 2018 Assignment Brief: Your 3-member Mutual Funds Analysis team has recently been hired to (i) Create an Australian Equity Active fund, (ii) Analyse a US bond fund, (iii) Create an Australian/US multi-asset (Equities and Bonds only)class fund. Requirements: 1. Create and Active Australian Equity fund Each team will create an active Australian equity fund. This portfolio will have a tracking

Jet Blue Case Study Written Assignment New York University / Sales And Marketing Case Study Written Assignment

1064 words - 5 pages JetBlue Case Study JetBlue does a phenomenal job of fully addressing all the needs, wants, and demands of its customers. The needs of JetBlue’s customers come down to three simple necessity of food, security, and physical ability to seat and get to their destination. The airline offers free foods and beverages to ensure its customers hungry and thirst are sustained. Then the idea of safety comes from JetBlue's stellar airline service and

Adult Health Post Operative Case Study Eidth Cowan University Assignment

3912 words - 16 pages NCS2101 ADULT HEALTH CASE STUDY TABLE OF CONTENTS · INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………1 · BACKGROUND OF THE CONDTION………………………..…1-2 · MANAGEMENT…………………………………………………...3-5 · POSTOPERATIVE EDUCATION………………………………….5 · POSTOPERATIVE COMPLICATIONS…………………………....5 · INVOLVEMENT OF INTERDISCIPLINARY TEAM……………..5 · CONCLUSION………………………………………………………6 · REFERENCES……………………………………………………...7-9 · APPENDIX 1………………………………………………………10-11 · APPENDIX REFERENCES

Biblical Worldview Assignment Pt 2 Liberty University Assignment

637 words - 3 pages Aline Aidar RLGN 105-005 September 28th, 2018 Worldview Writing Assignment Part 2 A worldview is someone’s perspective of the world based on their origins and morality; it is to see the world through a pair of lenses, that is usually related to a particular culture and beliefs, which makes people acquire a common sense about what is right or wrong, and also about existence. Moreover, it is a personal perception of life, and the development of