Real Religion In 20th Century Modernist Texts Final Essay Engl 273 Final Essay

2460 words - 10 pages

Sarah Jane Chrysler
Professor Kerkering
ENGL 273
May 1, 2019
Real Religion in Twentieth Century Modernist Texts
Religion is one of those hotly debated topics that is on the taboo list of things to not bring up at a dinner party; politics, economics, and religion. In the end of the nineteenth century and beginning of the twentieth, with the movement of many novels going from a more naturalistic style of those in the early part of the century, to something more modernist. With the directions of the world changing at rapid speeds that seemed to be increasing on the daily, this movement to modernism was the literary response to it all. Modernism brought in larger questions than many novelists before their time were willing to ask, let alone look for the answers to. These were questions of the meaning of life, how values came to be, and what people truly believed in. Two pieces that handled this movement in vastly different ways are; Willa Cather’s, My Antonia, and William Faulkner's, Light In August. While completely different settings and characters, these two novels tackle the difficult conversation of religion and spirituality in vastly different ways. While one is more outright in having the necessary conversations about religious and spiritual differences in the world, the other takes more of an understated approach with symbolic notions. It is simple to ignore or even leave the larger religious and spiritual contexts of both books unnoticed. While in My Antonia the religious differences between the two main characters are evident and clear to the reader, they are less so in Light In August. Rather than outright they are more symbolic. These two novels achieve religious and spiritual contexts while keeping it out of the forefront of the reader’s thought.
In the first mentoned novel, by Willa Cather, My Antonia, religion is something that is sort of skirted around as the Shimerdas and the Burdens are aware that they have religious differences and try to do the correct things for what their own beliefs. The interesting part about the fact that their religious differences are so apparent during all of this is it is just one part of the very apparent differences that these two families are facing, but in all of that their religion is a huge part of their identities and how they have built their own personal self images. While Antonia is Catholic as much of the european population in the United States was at the time, this was quite different than much of the native american population that was Protestant, as the Burdens were. Although the exact years are not know it is estimated that the story is taking place roughly, between 1890-1910. Along with this period of time comes the ideals that came with the manifest destiny movement of the time came the importance by many immigrants to maintain some sort of identity to their past lives in the countries that they came from. The Catholic and Protestant differences are just one of the religious/spiritual parts of this piece. Although dealing with almost all possible differences the two characters, Jim and Antonia, are able to have a similar sense of spirituality.
They find this together in the way that they connect to nature and landscape. This takes the spiritual part of religion, removes the political/institutional divides, and provides common ground upon which they are able to find solace. One of the most clear examples of this comes in the form of ‘the plough’ on page 185 of the text. “Just as the lower edge of the red disc rested on the high fields against the horizon, a great black figure suddenly appeared on the face of the sun. We sprang to our feet, straining our eyes toward it. In a moment we realized what it was. On some upland farm, a plough had been left standing in the field. The sun was sinking just behind it. Magnified across the distance by the horizontal light, it stood out against the sun, was exactly contained within the circle of the disc; the handles, the tongue, the share-black against the molten red. There it was, heroic in size, a picture writing on the sun.” This moment seems to be one of the most religious in the entire novel. It is a moment of pure connection to the earth in which they can connect with each other and the world they are living in, which seems to keep them focused on their differences.
This is in contrast to the way that William Faulkner's, Light In August, deals with these same issues. While both novels deal abundantly with ideas of belonging, identity, and escaping the past. In this piece specifically though, the symbolism is quite clear through the entire piece. While it is still subtle as it is symbolism rather than being outright stated, it is almost more clear than in My Antonia. It is through the use of unconventional means that Faulkner was able to turn this entire piece into a religious text. With a multitude of main characters that seem, in the beginning of the text to be unconnected or connected by miniscule means, by the end many of them become connected, almost as the disciples from The Holy Bible become connected through Jesus Christ. One of the main characters, Joe Christmas, is clearly the christ figure in this novel. For one thing his initials are JC, the same as Jesus Christ’s. Moreover, he is given the name ‘Christmas’ due to his birthdate. While these are smaller and more trivial parts of this connection, they are still evident. Additionally, Joe died at around 33 years of age, similar to the age that Jesus was at the time he was killed. Still, Faulkner continued to point to Christmas as a Christ figure in the fact that he was not, in any sense of the word, a ‘good guy’. This is pure irony. In The Bible, Jesus is drawn to the outcasts, the ‘sinners’, and the type of people that Joe Christmas is regarded as.
While there is no point in which Joe is able to become a better person, the timeline of the book is fluid and not told in a linear way so the reader is able to grasp what happened in his past and the things that have come to make up who he is. As was the case with My Antonia, there is something less political than a religious aspect, but more spiritual, in the ways that these characters deal with life. At the time period much of life came down to pure circumstance. Joe, having been orphaned allegedly had ‘black blood’ in him, which confused his sense of identity from such a young age he was never able to truly form his own identity outside of the criminal lifestyle he was living. One of the most evident moments of this comes at the beginning of chapter 6 on page 119 as Christmas thinks to himself “Memory believes before knowing remembers. Believes longer than recollects, longer than knowing even wonders.” This is taking place in the past at the orphanage he lived in. Throughout the novel some event that Christmas experiences will send him suddenly into his mind to a memory such as this one. It seems as though this is pointing to the idea that the past is something that is inescapable, while it is possible to change one’s future, it is not to change the psat. With that being said Joe Christmas knows that his legacy will be one of insignificance, the opposite of that of Jesus Christ. That being said, the implications of a single moment, the moment from the quote above can have an effect lasting ages beyond that single event, decision, or lapse in judgement.
Looking beyond the religious symbolism of Joe Christmas, there are countless other examples of this throughout the novel. One of the most prevalent and obvious is that of the dead sheep. For Christmas, during his adolescence at least, it was difficult to conceptualize anything sexual. After experiencing two people having sex at a young age when he was not only not supposed to have seen that, but also became sick due to other circumstances he was yelled at and never was able to disassociate those uncomfortable feelings about the things he’d witnessed and experienced at that time. So when one of his school friends decides to explain how a woman’s menstrual cycle works Joe is repulsed, bordering on afraid. His feelings become so overwhelming that he feels the need to go and shoot a deer. Something about this new knowledge of the female period was so unsettling to the young boy that he could only think to shoot something. After taking aim and pulling the trigger, on pages 185 and 186, “he knelt, his hands in the yet warm blood of the dying beast, trembling, dry-mouthed, backglaring. Then he got over it, recovered it. He did not forget what the boy had told him. He just accepted it. He found that he could live with it, side by side with it. It was as if he said illogical and desperately calm All right. It is so, then. But not to me. Not in my life and my love.” This, the first of the killings that Christmas would commit, was a borderline ritualistic moment for him. It became a source of solace for him. Of course there is the biblical symbolism in this being the Lamb of God. Through this, Joe Christmas is not only killing the sheep, but bringing about a moment of foreshadowing. He so easily lured the sheep to him to make it a simple shot. This is to say that it would be a simple path to destruction for himself. It was a very clear path that was easy for Joe to run down. He walked, as this sheep did, straight to his own demise.
In the same way that Joe depicts a Christ like figure, he also can be seen along with Lena as a disciple. Just as Jesus Christ brought so many unlikely characters together, so did Christmas. But that being said one of the distinct differences here is that Joe was lost and seeking identity, while Jesus was not. Joe stands along with the young and pregnant Lena, the ever elusive Byron Bunch, the outcast Joanna Burden, and even the isolated Reverend Gail Hightower. All of these characters were running and hiding. Most are running from something in their past but one is running towards something. Almost as a disciple would (metaphorically) run toward Jesus Christ, Lena was running into the face of adventure. She was running toward the idea of not being nailed down to her past, and even as her child is born she continues to seek adventure. This was something rather different for the time period. For a young girl, who was unmarried to have a child and live a life on the road, it was not something that would be simply accepted. Lena was willing to shatter social norms in pursuit of the life she wished for.
These attempts to flee the burden of one’s past are highly connected with the religious and spiritual aspects of both pieces. For Antonia Shimerda, she is getting stuck in the crossfire of two different identities trying to collect her. As she was starting to identify more and more with being a Nebraskan it was difficult with the people around her doing everything in their power to remind her that she is an outsider and an outcast. Dealing with this sort of persecution, similar to that of Jesus in The Bible, is relatable to the experience of Joe Christmas with the possibility of him having black blood. Both of these characters understand the difficulty of associating with any one group due to a displacement beyond their own control. The main, and most significant difference between the two characters (beyond the physical and other such differences) is that in spite of all of this Antonia decided to seek out acceptance and belonging whereas Joe Christmas did not. He continued to run away from any sort of anchoring or roots. Antonia Shimerda found association. She decided that even though she would never be a true “American” she could find common ground with others on the grounds of being a Nebraskan. This is one of the associations that brought Antonia and other main character Jim, closer together. Joe Christmas on the other hand, lived by the idea that, and used the fact that he did not know who he was as an excuse and a cop out to keep from having to hold himself accountable. If he had no roots, then he could easily run to anywhere at any time.
The significance of religious and spiritual symbolism in these two works is abundantly clear. They both examine the meaning of how one views oneself, identification and association with others, and the overall importance of knowing the above. The facts that Joe Christmas lived his entire life with the mindset that he would never fit into one single category, or that he would never want to belong to/associate with a group as that would require commitment and he felt the need to have an escape route planned at all times, is what ultimately lead to his demise. Although he is a Christ figure, he can easily be confused with someone more associated with the Devil because of his actions. He was killed because he murdered a woman and burned her house down. Yet he is still more like Jesus Christ in the way that his misfortune ultimately brought much of this small corner of the world together. Antonia decided to take her misfortune in another direction. Rather than pitying herself she sought out community and belonging. She did everything in her power to keep herself from being isolated. She found common grounding through spirituality in the land and through it was able to connect through that while still holding onto vastly different religious beliefs. This is something that Joe Christmas would never learn, by not holding any beliefs and harboring anger his death was almost a release from all of the unhappiness and fear that came with living a life on the run. Faulkner’s novel does not make it clear whether this is a critique of religion or something celebrating it. The sure fact of the matter though is that the piece is riddled with religious symbolism throughout. Surly though, Cather’s novel is a celebration of religious differences and the importance of spirituality that comes along with associating with a group and having one’s own personal identification. All of this though, was an important part of the modernist movement.


Britain's decline - 20th Century history - uni - essay

1717 words - 7 pages adherence began from the late nineteenth century, signalling an evolutionary change of ideas. Paired with changes occurring in society during the 1960’s ‘revolutionary’ period of expressiveness and shifts in cultural viewpoints, the resulting ‘death’ of the Christian religion was unavoidable, with the Church today still battling the repercussions of the decade. Though it is true that the causation and impact of the crisis has been disputed by many

Into the wild Final Essay English 11 - English - Final Essay

1605 words - 7 pages society Chris turned his search inward and lived an unencumbered life. Chris was never happier than when he was off on an adventure. He was comfortable when alone with himself, and even when he was facing death in the Alaskan wilderness he was still content. One cannot ask for much more out of life than to be happy. In one of his final acts Chris took a picture of himself waving goodbye with a not that said: “​I have had a happy life and thank

US105 Final Essay about Speeches - US105 - Essay

1477 words - 6 pages US105 Final Essay The 1850s was a time of calamity and prosperity for African Americans, slavery, and women. In the beginning, Confrontations over slavery mounted, each national political party was dividing into factions along North-South lines. A ten-month-long debate over a series of resolutions, the Compromise of 1850, which intended to reduce the crisis between North and South that had “unhinged” both political parties. Also, the Women’s

Final Advanced Criminology Essay - Advanced Criminiology - Essay

3525 words - 15 pages protesting against the government in the context of unemployment, taxes, privacy, security etc. As AI development is vastly advancing, human labour is put into jeopardy as more robots and autonomous systems are becoming replacements. Extending these ideas about AI intelligence, it can be used to both mitigate risk and add to risks that must be managed. Throughout this essay, what will be sought out to uncover is the major domains in which human

What were living and working conditions in Australia at the start of the 20th century? - history - essay

575 words - 3 pages used to 'disperse the natives' was by setting up the Native Police Forces. This force was made up of only indigenous men who were trained by the colonists' troops. The settlers used tribal rivalries to instigate violence between different clans of Aboriginal people. Violence against the Aboriginal peoples continued, in some parts of Australia, until the third decade of the twentieth century. It has been estimated that between 1788 and 1900, violence, dispossession and disease caused the Indigenous population to decline by around 90 percent.

In the time of Butterflies Final essay - Johnson high school - esssay

449 words - 2 pages Free “In the Time of Butterflies” By Julia Alvarez Final Argumentative Essay (_____/7) Prompt – Courage has been seen as an essential human virtue for centuries. Think about one of the Mirabal sisters as she is portrayed in the novel In the Time of the Butterflies. What kind of courage did she show? What was the source of this courage? How was it expressed? Did she ever fail to show courage at a critical moment? In essence, of the four sisters, which

Connecting ideas on short stories form the early 20th century - year 13 - Connections essay

1414 words - 6 pages English essay: Statement: Writers consistently use short stories as a lens through which they view society Intro: The lens in which writer’s view Mansfield’s short stories, are through the way she portrays the gender roles and expectations in the early 20th century. In comparing two of Mansfield’s stories from different decades, we can see a shift in the views of gender roles and expectations in the early 1900s. Examples of this view can be seen

The Roles of Advice Literature, Experts, and Child-Savers in the 19th and 20th Century Childrearing - The University of Memphis/ HIST 4863 - Essay

969 words - 4 pages Heather Alexander History 4863 Midterm Question 2 The Roles of Advice Literature, Experts, and Child-Savers in 19th and 20th Century Childrearing. Before the 19th century, there was a time in the United States when child abuse was completely legal, and it was acceptable for children to work long strenuous jobs with no consideration for schooling or childhood whatsoever (1). Poor children also ran rampant in the streets, stealing what they could

“The gender dynamics of Stardust and The Witches." - 20th Century Children's Fiction, NUIG - Essay

1526 words - 7 pages “Analyse the gender dynamics of two novels from the reading list, focusing in particular on powerful malevolent female villains.” For centuries, fairy-tales have formed the backdrop of our childhoods, sowing the seeds from which our imaginations blossomed. While many believe that within fairy-tales “there is always the happy ending” (Newell 6), several 20th century fairy-tales would argue otherwise. The primary aim of this essay is to

final draft for bio and or histroy - bio/history - essay

482 words - 2 pages Final draft Introduction- Ships have contributed to our economy by providing a variety of jobs, like for example; boatsteerers, harpooners, blacksmith, carpenter, cook and etc. (Source 2) As an individual I personally think that ships have changed our society and economy/cultures. As a group we’d all have to agree that it have changed our economy and culture for the better. My reasoning for that statement is that it makes trading items easier

Final Project One - Zappos, Inc - SNHU OL-215 - Essay

1231 words - 5 pages 5-2 Final Project One Application of the Fundamental Principle of Management for a Successful Company ZAPPOS, INC. Principles of Management OL-215 ZAPPOS, INC. 5-2 Final Project One Introduction In 1999, founder Nick Swinmurn realized no existing online retailers specialized in shoe sales. There were many mom and pop type stores that sold online. However, it wasn't until Nick had several unsuccessful attempts to buy his shoes

Final paper outline international politics - international politics - essay

1221 words - 5 pages Nguyen 2 Phuc Nguyen Prof. Halle Carol IS140A:PS144A 3th September 2018 Final Paper I. Problem A decade ago, North Korea was known the last country that still choose to close from communicating with other countries. The country itself is poor, and the citizen of the country lives in a very bad condition. Even though the citizen is suffered, the country chose not to open to the world until recently year. IN 2018, North Korea starts to talk to


894 words - 4 pages women in society. When she speaks about “a room of one’s own”, she is referring to a place where a woman could stay to write. But in order to have this “room”, women had to have economic independence, and that was not very common in the early 20th century. In this essay, a woman named Mary Beton is asked to give two lectures about women and fiction in literature in two women colleges. While sitting in the grass of one of the colleges, she is told

An Analysis of the Ethics in Post-Modern Journalism - University of Houston, Intro to Writing final - Essay

627 words - 3 pages An Analysis of the Ethics in Post-Modern Journalism In our current social media driven world, journalism is at a great impasse. Print media is in its final death throes and online media is bombarded by a need to have the most views, this creates an atmosphere where the ethics of journalism have been called into question. Is it right to use someone’s publicly published statement for profit? Do journalists owe impartiality and an unbiased

Gender and sexuality in 20th century plays - 20th century plays - essay

1404 words - 6 pages of passion. She has the passion of a python. She just devours me whole every time, as if I were some overlarge rabbit…She'll go on sleeping and devouring until there's nothing left of me” (Osborne 38). Alison’s sexuality come into play here and is portrayed to the readers as a large reason behind hers and Jimmy’s marriage. But in this case, sexuality is something that gives her power, shifting the gender dynamics. Another twentieth century play