Robert Westall 'the Scarecrows' We Are Unable To Sympathize With Simon's Point Of View Because He Fails To See The Points Of Others

1186 words - 5 pages

I disagree with this statement to a certain extent in that, Simon, a young man in his late teens should be enjoying his life by going out to parties and seeing his friends, but instead of that he has been living a quite cheerless and unhappy life because his father, Derek died a few years ago.Now because Simon does not have a stable life it would seem to the reader that he would want to bond with his mother, Debbie and his baby sister Jane, but Debbie has sent him to a boarding school where he hardly sees them.With Simons dad dead he wouldn't want a replacement for a new father because it would show he is trying to take the original dad's place, but Debbie on parents day turns up in a big, white Range Rover with a man. Joe. Evidence of this is page 20 it says,"There was a gap in the middle around the Range Rover, Mum and the man."This suggests that Simon has seen the man and also has a slight suspicion that Debbie and Joe may be starting a relationship he defiantly does not approve of. When Simon comes home he notices many differences in his mum, two examples of which are shown in the form of speech on page 20,"4 times in three weeks she'd gone out,""Hour long phone calls,"His mum had also bought lots of new clothes. Items such as frilly blouses, frilly skirts and leather boots were much out of character with Debbie, and so this showed that there were many changes occurring with the transformed mother; possibly suggesting that she actually was seeing Joe.Simon got called out from the school, his mum wanted to have lunch with him. In page 32 the evidence says,"Wood?" said Slogger. The head wants to see you."Soon after Debbie and Simon start to talk and she finally comes out with,"I am getting married again Simon."I think there was only one main reason to why Debbie took Simon to lunch and that was to try and get him in a good mood for what she had told him.Another reason why I disagree with the statement and that is because how is Simon supposed to see the points of others if the others wont see his point. Debbie without notice blurts out she was getting married again and Simon wasn't even informed that they were dating let alone getting married.Further more Debbie wasn't even going to enlighten Simon that she was going to move to Cheshire with Joe and Jane and the only reason why did was because Simon said,"I can't come home. Ever.""That's one of the things we've got to talk about. I'm selling the house."An explanation of this is Debbie obviously knew getting re-married was going to affect Simon's life because everything was going to change for him, and Debbie didn't want to hurt Simon more than she had done.Then she started to talk to him again, asking what he wanted to keep for the new house in Cheshire, but soon after that she began to choose what he kept and threw away. Reciting two important lines from the book,"Your Hamsters, give them away.""What about your Model Railway? Sell it. Give it away. Give it to Billy Turner."This is showing the reader that firstly she was asking Simon what he wanted to keep but then she made the suggestions for him.However, although Simon has been through a lot it suggests to the reader that he has to move on and try and accept what has happened. Debbie wants to get re-married she loves Joe and they have a very strong relationship which she said she never really had with Derek. Also when Derek was still alive he was planning to leave Debbie and the family. There is a line said by Debbie which showed that she wasn't happy the way things were without Joe,"You were fine Simon, I was lonely"This tells the reader that she wants to move on and start a new life.In addition, I agree with the statement because once Simon arrives at Joe's house in Cheshire, he turns very unforgiving and very short tempered with Joe. For example,"What are you going to do with the cats?""Keep them. ALL"This showed that Simon again is being very selfish and shows he wont listen to anyone and won't take anyone's points into account. It also puts forward that however hard Joe tries to start a fresh with Simon he turns his back on him and that he hates him for what he has done, which is marrying Debbie.An extra point to why I agree with statement is because when Debbie did come to Parents Day to see how Simon was doing all he could think about was how his mum was going to embarrass him, and how she was going to make a fool of herself. This happened when she started to play tennis against the Games Master. It may also suggest to the reader that Simon will not see Debbie's point of view, which is she was enjoying herself.A different point regarding why I agree with the statement is Simon will not see the point of what he did wrong. Joe had drawn a picture of Simon and once the painting had been finished he egoistically ripped the picture off the wall and ruined it. Verification of this is page 128. It says,"Simon""That picture was worth a hundred pounds.""I don't care"This showed again, however hard Joe tried he could not get Simon to accept his presence. This may also suggest to the reader that not only did he rip up the drawing, it may suggest he wants to rip up Debbie's and Joe's relationship.My conclusion to this essay is the following. Although Simon has been through a dreadful event he must pick himself up and try to see what other people want and not just him, i.e. his mum wanting to marry Joe.

RELATED

"What Christians believe about life is up to them. They should not try to make others accept their position." State whether you agree, give reasons, and consider more than one point of view

527 words - 3 pages the law, following their conscience and rejecting evil, but they are not a Christian, some people could say that there is no need for Christians to enforce their beliefs on the person, because as they are already leading a good life, God would be pleased with them.I believe that Christians have don't have a right to make others accept their position, because people must think for themselves, but they should go on carrying out one of their tasks

Depression an expository point of view the causes and how to prevent it. - English - Expository paper

524 words - 3 pages the U.S., more women are diagnosed with depression than men, with the median age of onset being 32 for both genders this is mentioned in the website Bridge to Recovery. (Major Depression, 2016) (Everyday Health, 2013) (Bridges of Recovery, 2019) Most people when asked what depression is think that it’s when someone is so sad that they feel worthless and constantly think about taking their own lives. What they don’t know is that

"The Shining Houses" Essay - Point Of View

388 words - 2 pages "The Shining Houses" by Alice Munro uses Mary's point of view to show how younger generations mistreat the older ones.Mrs. Fullerton, one who is of the older generation, is an individual that does not fit in with her new, younger neighbors. Despite that, Mary gives her and her story credence. However, Mary feels the division between Mrs. Fullerton's generation, and the younger one that she is a part of, as she felt as though she was going

Why were the Arabs unable to defeat Israel in the war of 1948-9, 1956 and 1967?

458 words - 2 pages Although the odds were against Israel, they managed to defeat the Arabs and benefit from the wards because of their strengths and Arab weaknesses. Israel was successful because they were organized and disciplined and they had help from foreign powers.Arabs didn't want to recognize the state of Israel. During the war of 1948-9, the Arab states were weak and divided. Their defeat was because of their poor leaders and they had no planned attack

Explanation of how the sphere is linked to others - asss - asasas

880 words - 4 pages , liquid or ice. Water moves in a cycle as it collects in the clouds before falling to the earth in the form of rain or snow. Then it collects in rivers, lakes and oceans before evaporating into the atmosphere and starting the cycle over again. The geosphere (lithosphere and atmosphere) and hydrosphere are closely linked. When there is a change in the atmosphere it results in their being a change in the lithosphere. The hydrosphere links with

A Libertarian Point Of View Essay

1345 words - 6 pages that which can betaken care of by individuals or their families or communities. The most important thing thata government can do is protect the right s of the individual. A government should reservethe rights of the individual in any case provided their actions are not harmful to others. Ibelieve that along with individual rights and small government there are other importantthings that government should keep in mind. I believe in a strong sense

This Essay Has Quotes And Points Of View From The Books Thoreau And Emerson

919 words - 4 pages Why Should We Read?Why should we read? What does reading provide us? What are the consequences of not reading? These are the questions you should think about when reading a book. Reading plain and simple books are not enough for our minds. We need to challenge ourselves to improve our self's. The challenges reading provides us will help us exercise our minds and in return we will gain knowledge. Books are like a new world waiting to be explored

The life of Edward Jenner, from his point of view. - concordia, 6th grade science - essay

602 words - 3 pages saved many lives. In addition to doctoring, I still had much interest in geology, specifically fossils. Despite my huge medical career, made a dynamic find in uncovering the remains of a Plesiosaur, a prehistoric dinosaur. My thoughts of geology expanded more and more until my main interests were doctoring and geology. My extra-curricular thoughts were always an inspiration to others,​ ​triggering​ many geological and fossil-related finds and

With Reference To Masculinity And Or Femininity Discuss The View That Lifestyle Magazines Offer Their Audience A Conservative Construction Of Gender

1022 words - 5 pages implies that the men who read this magazine should be more stylish and sophisticated than other men. The model on the cover of esquire is a man but he is used as an identification figure rather than an objectification figure. The model is Will Smith who is a celebrity and so the readers identify with him and aspire to be him. The audience for this magazine are probably slightly older about 18-30 and therefore their ideologies of gender will be

Abortion Pro-Life Point Of View

1693 words - 7 pages American market. If this approval is obtained, the drug could be available sometime this year under the name of Mifeprex (Rosenblatt 250).This pill will not change anything, except for the fact that a woman doesn't have to go see a doctor in order to have an abortion done. With Mifeprex, a woman can have an abortion in the privacy of her home with no help from anyone. To many, this may seem stupid, but for others it may seem like a great idea, because

Similarities And Differences Between William Shakespeare’S “Sonnet 55” And Robert Herrick’S “To The Virgins To Make Much Of Time”

745 words - 3 pages Similarities and Differences Between William Shakespeare's "Sonnet 55" and Robert Herrick's "To the Virgins to Make Much of Time"William Shakespeare and Robert Herrick are well-known names. They have written many poems that are still relevant and popular. There are some similarities between certain poems they wrote, which makes it possible to compare specific poems of Shakespeare and Herrick with each other. For example Shakespeare's "Sonnet 55

How does Eliezer’s point of view on God change throughout the events in the novel ? - MVHS Widner - essay

979 words - 4 pages Night Essay Eliezer’s struggle with faith and view of God is a dominant conflict in the novel. Before being moved into the ghetto at the beginning of the book, Elie pursued Moishe the Beadle, a teacher of Jewish Mysticism. Moishe the Beadle is sent to a concentration camp, which he escapes from, and makes his way back to their town of Sighet to warn others of all the terrible things he had witnessed at the concentration camps. Nobody believed

Ostpolitik: What Were The Aims Of Brandt's Ostpolitik And How Did He Seek To Achieve Them?

1330 words - 6 pages After the events of the Cuban Missile Crisis, tensions worldwide, including within Europe, eased significantly, all sides agreeing to work towards a policy of détente. The leader of the Federal Republic of Germany (FRG), or West Germany as it was named at that time, Willy Brandt, decided to review the policies that the FRG had up till this point held regarding Eastern Europe. Under the Hallstein Doctrine, relations with Eastern Europe had

Is Seeing Believing- Answering the long anticipated question cn w believ what we see - Philosophy, University Of Nottingham - Essay

462 words - 2 pages switch to high def view in the night time and can see like thermal cameras , if they saw a rat (usually their prey) It would appear something like this : Just because humans basically dominate the world doesn’t mean our view is the most accurate (most definitely isn’t) . At this point in time nobody know who views the world most accurately since there are so many ways of viewing it . So in conclusion , this , to me makes our vision unreliable and

Sympathize with the revolutionaries - East High School - Research

732 words - 3 pages , often criticising the evil of the revolutionaries themselves. It does appear clear however that Dickens shows great empathy for the situation of the French working class and highlights the necessity of a social change. We can see this through the heartless attitude of the Marquis Evremonde to the child his carriage has killed. The Marquis seems to be a symbol of the aristocracy that is used to shamelessly exploiting the nation's poor for its own ends