Example Of How Not To Write An Historical Essay

1501 words - 7 pages

I am writing in regards to Filomena's performance in my history class. Rather than wait until her report comes out this week to write a sentence or two, I would like to deal with her writing ability fully to keep you completely aware and hopefully come to some idea that could best help her improve. I am not sure if you are in contact with her homeroom teacher but suspect that as is too often the case, the school waits until things get too late to inform parents.I find that this school admits and promotes any student regardless of ability and then by the time they reach IB2 they are far out of their depth with the school unable or unwilling to help them. One of my IB1 students for example ...view middle of the document...

One of the examples of civilians being treated hard is disease. They were kept locked in houses with no cleaned drains which caused gangrene and other disease, they didn't have fans which were used to push the germs out through the window. Many people were dying because of poor health care and no medical treatment. In order to keep the civilians alive they would have to move them to another house that was clean, had a good environment and a good medical treatment.Such a paragraph concerns me for a number of reasons. Firstly, it was again the same question I had assigned for homework. I WENT OVER IT INDIVIDUALLY WITH FILOMENA BOTH IN CLASS, AFTER CLASS AND ONLINE. Secondly, after some time writing essays, there is still no topic sentence, concluding sentence, structure. This must be the case for all her classes. Most importantly, the ideas are completely off the mark. There is no evidence, no facts, no justification. To be told that civilians were simply moved to other accomodation due to lack of fans which led to gangrene is ground for deep worry. I know of no European country at that time that left its citizens without any medical treatment etc. As the next paragraph shows, pronouns are used without any reference so that one never understands who 'they' are:Another example of poor civilians is hardwork, they made them work very hard, even little kids. In 1914 they decided that children have to work also, they were sent to different places like factories, yards and the mills. They weren't even opaid for their jobs, thousands of kids which worked in a sewing machines, died because when the machine got stuck cause of the tread. The kid had to go under the machine and untangle it, it was a huge risk because once you fix it, it starts working and you will get killed. Parents had different k\jobs there were times that were locked in another place without seeing their kid for years. They even splited mothers from their babies. Because of this people were loosing their lives so they could satisfy someone.It goes without saying that none of these points were mentioned in class or can be found in her textbook. To be asked to accept that "thousands" of children died due to faulty sewing machines and that babies were taken from mothers during the Great War at this level is impossible. No attempt has been made to use real facts we learned in class and studied, or any sense of context. This leads me to her last point:The civilians were treated really harsh no matter if it meant it was a woman, man or child. They thought that being a man was a successful way of what they intended to do, but it wasn't because they kiled innocent people. One of the ways of killing civilians by Germans was by putting them in a room naked and spreading poison gas, which killed them slowly. Another way is either to make them die of hunger and thirst or either...

Other Essays On Example Of How Not To Write An Historical Essay

"Color" A short example of how to use 'color' in writing

264 words - 2 pages The sunset viewed from my neighborhood begins slowly, but ends quickly. At first an orange-yellow fills the sky. The color is vibrant, flooding into its onlooker's eyes instantaneously. New colors form on the faces of the few lone clouds as the sun continues to creep its way down to the edge of the horizon. Crimson, pink, burgundy, violet, and indigo all mixed in one beautiful show. As the sun touches the horizon, the area where the sun would

An Example of Perseverance in Sports

451 words - 2 pages For most people, winning is harder than losing, but in a sport as competitive as wrestling that is not the case. There is a lot of pressure put on you to be the best you can be, and that's why I like it so much. I was never really a great athlete, so when the opportunity came up to join the wrestling team when I was a freshman, I was a little skeptical. My first few weeks on the team were challenging; I couldn't beat anyone at practice, and I

This essay is an example of abstract writing on Time being the mother, the friend, and the snake

580 words - 3 pages how deep the cut. Do not be deceived, for Time is also the snake that suffocates. Time is she who emphasizes distance, and hazes you from what happiness you've been bathing in. She is the smoke which clouds your thoughts making it harder and harder for you to breathe. It is she who whispers doubt in your ear and plants fear and regret onto your mind. Time is who makes you realize that you are not where you really want to be. ...And when

In Not More Than 300 Words, Write A Descriptive Account Of Harmen Steenwyck's "Still Life: An Allegory Of The Vanities Of Human Life"

372 words - 2 pages "An Allegory of the Vanities of Human Life" by Harmen Steenwyck is an oil painting which falls within the genre of a "Vanitas" popularised by Dutch painters during the 17th century. The theme of this type of painting is meant to evoke thoughts of the futility of possessions within human life.The angle of vision is close to and looking down drawing the spectators gaze upon a wooden table housing various objects. A strong shaft of light, perhaps

How The Future Looked In 1899 An Essay In Response To A Newsweek Article Citing Ninteenth Century Predictions Of How The Future Will Be

607 words - 3 pages been teetering of the edge of destruction.All quotes are from a January 1, 2000 article from NewsWeekYou may contact me if you need it.The teacher gave me a perfect and also encouraged me to write another essay for extra credit after she graded this essay.

An Informative Historical Research Essay On The Lon Chaney Classic "THE WOLF MAN"

2108 words - 9 pages classify as the "golden age" of Hollywood, the genre of "Monster Horror" was not yet refined, and it is fascinating to study the effects these films had on society upon their original release. Using the 1941 classic "The Wolf Man" as an example, I will examine the varying factors which led to the film's initial success, and how they have attributed to the mythology of Universal "Horror" as it is interpreted today.It is not uncommon to associate the

Book: Guadalupe, Mother Of The New Creation By Virgil Elizando - Answering The Question: How Does Elizando Present The Guadalupe Apparaiton As An Example Of "Conversion Within One's Own Tradition"?

1595 words - 7 pages possibly purer form, without the rampant corruption present in the European church. Conversion became an attempt to make good Spanish Catholics out of a misunderstood indigenous people.The Nahuatl that converted to this Spanish Christianity found himself/herself caught between two worlds and two cultures, accepted fully by neither, despised by both. On the one hand, the Indian convert was seen as a traitor to his family, ancestry, and historical

Patsy Cline: Write An Essay On An Influential Figure In American History And Why They Were Influential

969 words - 4 pages couldn't find an opening. She then became a club dancer to earn money to further her dream. Patsy was finally able to sign a contract with William McCall's 4 Star Sales Co. The first few singles she recorded were not successful. However the way she acted on TV as well as her personal aura got her a lot of regional fame (Jones, Margaret). Patsy's turning point came about in 1957, after winning "The Arthur Godfreys Talent Show" competition. At the

Write a poem of not more than 40 lines about a journey

304 words - 2 pages with native children,the thunderous roar out of place.The guide laughs at our conceit,points upwards.We clamber over boulders,escorted by monkeysgreedy for human delicacies,to see this creamy torrentfall to its ruin in a glassy pool.We are not alone.Red and gold fish dart andweave through a seethinghorde of rowdy touristsbathing in sun dappled water.A whoop. The monkey man callsdown his minions.'Cashew, Cashew, 50 rupee'.Survival of the strongest,the ruthless, the most commercial.We bask until near dusk.Until the dust of four wheel drivessettles and the light dims.The journey home is humdrum,lacking desire.

How To Listen To Music, Not Just Hear It

1091 words - 5 pages find the best room to put that chair in, so you can listen to you music. The room can be any normal room with four walls but, the room can't be wide open. For example, it can't be an unfinished basement with concrete walls and a cement floor. The sound will not be able to bounce off the walls and give the effect as if the sound is coming from behind you, as well as in front of you (the surround effect). A good room to listen in, is a typical family

Transfer Of Learning: Not Just An Afterthought

1782 words - 8 pages organizations.Learning Begins with Knowledge about Self Operating under the assumption that all learning is relevant, both formal and informal, Argyris (1993) observes that ?success in the marketplace increasingly depends on learning, yet most people don?t know how to learn?. Most people do not know which learning methods work best for them. Being a learner requires self-examination and an understanding of one?s own learning style, values, belief

Similar Papers

An Example Of How To Write An Assessment Report

379 words - 2 pages and has thus often contributed to a positive outcome of the meetings.Work-related achievements:Over the course of the last six months, Jeremy has succeeded in having several optimum contracts signed for our company. Furthermore, he was solely responsible for the working conditions-improvement campaign which took place last month. This was an extremely successful undertaking which has had an excellent outcome without causing additional costs to

How 'roseanne', The Tv Show Relates To The Sociological Aspect Of Women And Work. I Had To Write This For An Extra Credit Paper, It's Not Great, But It Gets The Point Across

524 words - 3 pages Ever since I started college in the fall, I haven't really been able towatch as much television that I would like to. I have been able too catchsnippets here and there, but nothing really "in depth". One show that I usedto watch was Roseanne. Some of the things that seem natural to thecharacters on the show reflect what we have been studying all semester inthis class.Roseanne, a wife and a mother of three, is a stubborn, loud, andobnoxious

I Am Not Doing An Essay, Just Give Me Info So I Can Write An Essay #Juniorinhighschool

560 words - 3 pages toothbrush.That afternoon the Army dentist yanked seven of his teeth. On the third day, the Army issued him a jock strap,The Army has been looking for Herman for 51 years. Two Soldiers were required to sit through General's Boring speech. After about an hour one soldier looks at the other and says, "my butt is falling asleep." The other one responded and said, "I know, I heard it snore three times." One summer afternoon a particularly pious

How In The World Am I Going To Write A Essay?

374 words - 2 pages avoid people and situations that may elevate your anxiety level. Strategy 2 Alter the Situation: This one I feel is an important one. It encourages you to deal with your feelings and to communicate effectively. Also, be willing to compromise when you do state your feelings. This strategy also advises that you manage your time more effectively to avoid being anxious over deadlines and other looming priorities. Strategy 3: Instead of getting upset about things try to look at them form a more positive stand point. Also evaluate how important what you're worrying about is. If it isn't that important then why stress? Another...